Thursday, August 11, 2022

Why Evangelicals Worship Trump: Sarah Posner interview

 
Opinion Interview | Why Evangelicals Worship Trump
It’s more than a cold-blooded marriage of convenience.
April 7, 2021 BY AMY E. SCHWARTZ
Opinion, Politics, Summer Issue 2020

10
JUN
An opinion interview with Sarah Posner

What do President Donald Trump and the religious right see in each other? No journalist is better equipped to answer this question than Sarah Posner, who spent decades covering the rise of the Christian evangelical movement within the Republican Party (she even wrote an undergraduate thesis on the topic in 1986) and penned award-winning coverage of the alt-right during the 2016 presidential campaign. Watching evangelicals become improbably entranced with Trump as the campaign progressed, she had an “aha moment,” she writes in her new book, Unholy: Why White Evangelicals Worship at the Altar of Donald Trump. Trump’s divergence from the pattern of previous favored candidates, his appeals to racism and nativism, all faded before the anointing of “the strongman the Christian right had long been waiting for.”

Trump doesn’t sound like a traditional president, but when you think of him as a televangelist, it starts to make more sense.

Many consider the alliance a cold-blooded marriage of convenience. But the “purely transactional explanation for the Trump-evangelical merger,” Posner writes, fails to account for “the deeper bond between Trump and his devoted flock. Although Trump is illiterate in evangelicals’ lexicon and spent his adult life flagrantly contravening their sexual mores, his evangelical supporters are nonetheless starstruck.”

To understand why, Posner argues, you have to delve further—into the religious right’s resentment of, and recoil from, what conventional wisdom deems a half-century of progress toward greater inclusion and expanded rights, and into the long-standing grievances to which Trump gives voice so fluently.

What is it about Trump that entrances the Christian right?

For one thing, they’re entranced by power. But also, to charismatic and Pentecostal Christians who watch a lot of televangelists, Trump acts in a very familiar way. Televangelists get up on the stage and tell a long, meandering story about themselves, with faith healing and miracles and seemingly random anecdotes. It’s a central idea in that culture that you can speak something into existence—it’s true because they say it is. Trump doesn’t sound like a traditional president, but when you think of him as a televangelist, it starts to make more sense. He talks about himself, and about some great thing he did, and he rambles on and on, and that’s a very familiar style to a lot of people. They don’t find it strange the way the media does.

What surprised you most in 2016?

I was surprised not only that white evangelicals were embracing Trump, but that they were doing so at the same time as the alt-right. In some ways, it makes sense; a lot of the mobilization of the Christian right was originally driven by racial grievance. But on the other hand, they’d been sensitized to that as an image problem after 2012 and were openly trying to make their movement less white. So it was surprising that they’d turn away from that. When I interviewed Steve Bannon in 2016 at the Republican National Convention, before he became Trump’s campaign manager, Bannon told me, “Look, the alt-right and the Christian right need each other. We can’t win an election without both.” At the outset, many evangelicals liked Ted Cruz or Scott Walker. But they came together with Breitbart and Bannon and Stephen Miller and were willing to look past what they were doing. They might not have planned it, but they’re OK with it.

What role does anti-Semitism play?

That’s one of the most mystifying things about this. The Christian right loves to talk about its love for Israel and the Jewish people.

And the alt-right is overtly anti-Semitic, and some of them are outright Nazis. At one point in 2016, I’d been at AIPAC and at a Nazi rally, and at both places there were people supporting Trump. I think the Christian right is just willing to pretend this element is not part of Trump’s coalition. Each side has policies it wants enacted, and each side is getting some of what it wants. The Christian right is clearly more powerful, with a well-funded infrastructure, and the alt-right is a lot more ragtag. So the philo-Zionism of the Christian right is the predominant view in Trump’s orbit. But we’ve all seen the rise of anti-Semitism, not only around the world but also in the United States. Trump doesn’t have the language or the willingness to forthrightly condemn it, and it demonstrates the limits of the Christian right’s supposed love of Jews and Israel.

Could the alt-right become more uncontrollable because of the pandemic?

It could. You have these gun-toting protesters who are a small number relative to the population but who can cause a lot of harm and damage. So you have militias storming state capitols, and the Christian right suing governors over the stay-at-home orders, and it all mingles together in the idea that the stay-at-home orders violate our freedom. That’s how Trump has held this coalition together all along, with the idea that political correctness or liberalism has kept us down.

 

 

 

 

Moment Magazine participates in the Amazon Associates program and earns money from qualifying purchases.

 

 

Wednesday, August 10, 2022

Actually, Elon, You Can Count Twitter Bots. Here’s How

Actually, Elon, You Can Count Twitter Bots. Here’s How

Analysis by Tim Culpan | Bloomberg

June 21, 2022 at 11:24 a.m. EDT

Elon Musk’s assertion last month that the number of Twitter bots is as “unknowable as the human soul” may well be a negotiating tactic from a man who’s probably feeling a bit of buyer’s remorse. Yet tallying up how many machines are running around on Twitter Inc.’s platform is a pretty straightforward process, if only everyone can agree on what they’re counting.


A “very significant matter” deterring Musk from closing the deal at the $44 billion price originally agreed is “whether the number of fake and spam users on the system is less than 5%, as Twitter claims, which I think is probably not most people’s experience when using Twitter,” he told Bloomberg News Editor-in-Chief John Micklethwait at the Qatar Economic Forum on Tuesday. Other items to be overcome include debt financing and a shareholder vote on the acquisition, he said.


With shares of the social media company trading at 30% below Musk’s purchase price of $54.20, there’s $15 billion worth of reasons for the South African businessman to find loopholes and push for a discount. His comment Tuesday is similar to one made in a June 6 filing, when he claimed that Twitter refused to provide the information needed “to facilitate his evaluation of spam and fake accounts on the company’s platform.”


Story continues below advertisement

Let’s pause here. So far we have three different terms — bot, spam, and fake accounts — which could have entirely different meanings. Not all bots are fake, and not all fakes send spam.


There are numerous ways to categorize accounts on Twitter, but the simplest and most useful may be to examine every Twitter handle on two bases. Human, where an actual person sets up and runs activities on the account, or automated where a piece of human-written software acts on behalf of the account to tweet, retweet and like. The latter, can be called a bot.


There are also authentic accounts, where the entity operating the account is the same as that which it purports to represent, and inauthentic where this is not the case. This second category would be considered fake.


Story continues below advertisement

There’s a lot of gray area when sorting accounts, and we shouldn’t assume a bot account is bad and human is good. For example, many corporations and media outlets do much of their posting and retweeting using third-party software. Technically, their Twitter account is being run by a bot, but we like to think of them as “good bots.” Those that keep tweeting crypto scams are “bad bots.”


In addition, inauthentic accounts are frowned upon, but quite often lay harmlessly dormant for months or years on end before being reactivated to harass individuals or spread misinformation. We’ve seen this in Chinese state-backed entities and ruling-party linked actors in India. Catching an inauthentic account is extremely difficult. Some are run by bots, but by no means all of them. And just because an account is operated by a human with a pseudonym doesn’t mean it’s malicious.


“Through a combination of machine learning and monitoring by our teams, we proactively detect accounts whose activity indicates that there are attempts to manipulate Twitter conversations in an automated way, ie ‘bad bots,’” Twitter said in an email to Bloomberg Opinion. 


Story continues below advertisement

Sorting bot, fake and spam accounts by these categories is as much art as science. In fact, counting bots is the easiest part, and Musk’s claim that at least 20%, and as high as 90%, of users fall into this category is out of whack. It’s an entirely calculable number because Twitter itself lets external developers build bots and plug into its data feed. All you need to do is apply for a developer account and connect to the company’s application programming interface, known as an API.


Twitter counts how many of these are in use, and puts that figure into the “hundreds of thousands” of monthly active developer accounts. If we generously round that up to one million, then we’re look at 1 out of 229 million users,(1) or less than 0.5%. To be clear, not all of those developer accounts actually post to Twitter — meaning tweet, retweet or like. In fact, thousands of developers use the API to passively gather data, which could be used for marketing and research. That’s a far cry from 20%.


To be fair, there is another way to run a Twitter bot without using the company’s API, and that’s by mimicking a real person. Because Twitter’s platform runs on a web browser using standard protocols, clever software developers can exploit this openness to create a bot that appears to be just like a human on Chrome or Firefox. Twitter can’t count these interactions as easily, but it does have systems in place to hunt them out, and shut them down if need be. If 20% of its users were browser-emulating bots, then there’s every chance Twitter would know about it. 


Story continues below advertisement

Chief Executive Officer Parag Agrawal has been pretty open about these challenges.


“Spam isn’t just ‘binary’ (human/not human). The most advanced spam campaigns use combinations of coordinated humans + automation,” he said in a thread last month. “They are sophisticated and hard to catch.”


To ameliorate his concerns, Twitter offered to walk Musk through its methodologies, which his lawyers curiously decried as being “tantamount to refusing Mr. Musk’s data requests.” If, instead, the new buyer wanted to access every Tweet since the first was sent in March 2006, that could certainly be arranged. But it’s unlikely to bring much satisfaction because Musk and his team would then be left sorting through reams of data to decide for themselves what is a bot, what is fake, and what is spam. 


Story continues below advertisement

With a $44 billion social media company and mountains of old tweets in his hands, Musk’s problem won’t be trying to know the unknowable, but deciding what exactly it is that he wants to know.


More From This Writer and Others at Bloomberg Opinion:


• Twitter Must Tackle a Problem Far Bigger Than Bots: Tim Culpan


• Why All the Social Networks Want to Be Like TikTok: Parmy Olson


• Elon Musk’s Twitter Has a Crypto Swamp to Drain: Lionel Laurent


(1) Twitter reports mDAU, monetizable Daily Active Users, its own metric for counting “real” users that may actually see ads posted to the platform. It may not be directly comparable to monthly active developer metrics.


This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.


Tim Culpan is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering technology in Asia. Previously, he was a technology reporter for Bloomberg News.


More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com/opinion

CHIPS+ could change the U.S. semiconductor supply chain, and more

CHIPS+ could change the U.S. semiconductor supply chain, and more

Sarah Bauerle Danzman — Read time: 5 minutes

But do industrial incentives work?

Analysis by Sarah Bauerle Danzman

August 9, 2022 at 7:00 a.m. EDT


President Biden is scheduled to sign the CHIPS and Science Act of 2022, or CHIPS+, this week. In late July, Congress passed the $280 billion package to support domestic semiconductor manufacturing capabilities, along with research and development in advanced technology. It’s a massive bill — by some measures even larger than the Apollo moon program.


CHIPS+ is big news for another reason — the bill signals how Washington is rethinking the government’s role in industry, in response to re-emerging great power competition and the fragilities of globalized production networks. CHIPS+ is simultaneously a broad-based high-tech industrial policy, jobs program and secure supply program. Will it also catalyze innovation? Here’s the politics behind the new legislation.


The U.S. doesn’t want to rely on others for chip fabrication


Story continues below advertisement

Silicon wafer chips, or semiconductors, have become integral to a wide array of products, including cars, smartphones and home appliances. The chip supply chain tends to fragment R&D-intensive activities, and concentrate wafer fabrication in a few places. But geopolitical risks — namely, competition with China — along with natural disasters such as the coronavirus pandemic boosted the argument for national security and economic resilience, and a U.S. government push to “reshore” semiconductor manufacturing capabilities.


This marks a shift from confidence in free trade and efficient markets toward concerns over chokepoints in complex economic networks that adversaries could weaponize for political leverage. These concerns reflect multiple factors, including declining confidence in the benefits of globalization, concerns that China and other economies manipulate trade rules and institutions — and, of course, pandemic-related disruptions to supply chains.


While the United States accounts for 47 percent of the global chip industry, this rests on its dominance in R&D-intensive activities like chip design and manufacturing equipment. Most U.S. semiconductor companies operate on a “fabless foundry” model — they design microchip technology in house, but outsource production abroad. This business model makes sense from a “lean supply chain” perspective, and specialization in a small part of supply chain minimizes a company’s capital costs. Under this industry structure, U.S. production of chips declined from 37 percent of global supply in 1990 to 12 percent today. The United States currently has no capacity to fabricate the most advanced microchips.


Incentivizing domestic production is politically complicated


Story continues below advertisement

Chip fabrication is massively capital-intensive, and the countries with the largest market share of chip production heavily subsidize the industry. CHIPS+ attempts to make domestic semiconductor manufacturing more feasible by providing $52 billion in subsidies — and a 25 percent investment tax credit — for companies that build new U.S. plants, or expand or upgrade existing microchip fabrication plants in the United States. Much of the funding will go toward advanced chip fabrication, with $2 billion earmarked for legacy microprocessors used in many commercial applications, including automobiles.


The bill also authorizes an additional $200 billion for programs to spur innovation, including a new National Science Foundation Directorate for Technology, Innovation and Partnerships and $10 billion to seed 20 “regional tech hubs.”


The incentive programs were designed to distribute funds to the benefit of more rural and disadvantaged communities. The research on investment incentives, however, suggests such programs often aren’t sufficient to overcome locational disadvantages and can lead to wasteful rent-seeking.


Story continues below advertisement

Do industrial incentives work?


Whether CHIPS+ incentives can effectively foster semiconductor fabrication and high-tech clusters will depend on many factors, including the process for choosing which projects to support. In co-authored work, I show that investment incentives often reflect genuine development priorities. But, as political scientist Stephanie Rickard has demonstrated, electoral politics often shape which locations the central government chooses to support. And commentary by political scientist Nate Jensen points out that the CHIPS+ requirement to pair federal chip subsidies with state or local incentives could lead to fierce inter-state competition. Already, New York has created a $10 billion tax incentive program to lure certain semiconductor plants.


However, if any industry is a good candidate for industrial policy, it would be semiconductor fabrication — facilities are capital intensive and hard to move once built, they typically generate follow-on investment and complementary innovation, and can create good, high-paying jobs. As others have noted, semiconductor fabrication and R&D requires highly skilled talent, so the new U.S. subsidies may not be enough in the absence of efforts to address the STEM talent shortage through education and immigration policy. While CHIPS+ has workforce development provisions, the new bill is silent on making it easier for STEM professionals to immigrate to the United States.


Ultimately, whether CHIPS+ is an expensive boondoggle or an effective catalyst of innovation depends on program administration. The legislation gives the U.S. commerce secretary considerable discretion over the funding programs; it will be important to watch how the Commerce Department interprets its mandate and whether and how it insulates the department from the politicization of funding decisions.


Story continues below advertisement

What does this say about globalization?


Another question is whether CHIPS+ ultimately sacrifices open markets in the quest for self-sufficiency. The Biden administration has paired efforts to strengthen domestic capabilities with measures to coordinate supply chain resiliency among allies and partners — and anyone from Texas would point out that even closed systems aren’t immune to supply disruptions.


CHIPS+ won’t likely, on its own, stop U.S. companies from continuing to offshore production to China. During negotiations, Congress stripped the trade-related provisions from the original bill, including the National Critical Capabilities Defense Act, which would have added, for the first time, screening provisions for outbound foreign investment into “countries of concern.” Congress will likely revisit the outbound screening issue in the fall, however.


But CHIPS+ does include guardrail provisions to prevent companies benefiting from U.S. subsidies and incentives from building advanced semiconductor plants in China. Korean chipmakers Samsung and SK Hynix, for instance, report that CHIPS+ complicates their China investment strategy. It’s not clear, however, if CHIPS+ will allow companies that seek U.S. subsidies to continue to produce legacy technology in China.


Story continues below advertisement

Would overly restrictive provisions backfire, and lead to a full tech decoupling between China and a U.S.-led semiconductor coalition? While industry will likely lobby against this, my research demonstrates that firms often tolerate restrictions on investment if they also receive subsidized finance.


Sarah Bauerle Danzman is associate professor of political science at Indiana University and author of “Merging Interests: When Domestic Firms Shape FDI Policy” (Cambridge University Press, 2020). Find her on Twitter @sarahbauerle.

GOP hysteria over the Mar-a-Lago search is an invitation to violence

GOP hysteria over the Mar-a-Lago search is an invitation to violence

Dana Milbank — Read time: 4 minutes

Columnist |

August 9, 2022 at 6:14 p.m. EDT

I would like nothing more than to be wrong about this. But the reckless response by the GOP-Fox News axis to the FBI’s search of Mar-a-Lago makes it feel as though we’re falling into the abyss.


The threat of political violence from far-right extremists has been growing for years, but calls to arms reached a fever pitch in pro-Trump social media after Monday’s court-ordered search at former president Donald Trump’s Florida compound: “When does the shooting start?” “Summertime was made for killing fields.” “Lock and load.” “Tomorrow is war.” “Pick up arms, people.”


In such a dangerous and unstable time, we need political and opinion leaders to appeal for calm. Instead, Fox News and other conservative outlets exploded with talk of “war” and “assassination,” an “attack” on the country and Trump supporters, and calls for revenge against a “corrupt” American “KGB.” Elected Republicans erupted in cries about the “weaponized politicization” done by a Democratic “Gestapo” and a “tyrannical FBI,” and about the need to “make sure these tyrants pay the price.” They called for retribution: “Destroy the FBI.” “No one is safe.” “You’re next.” “They’re coming for YOU.”


Story continues below advertisement

We know that violent speech, particularly when so many are already feeling desperate and on edge, leads to violent acts. We have been here before.


During the Clinton administration in the mid-1990s, far-right militia groups were proliferating over anger at the federal government’s clumsy moves against extremists at the Branch Davidian cult’s compound in Waco and in an earlier standoff in Ruby Ridge, Idaho. Conservative commentators and Republican lawmakers stoked the rage, warning “patriots” to resist a supposed attempt by the government to confiscate guns and impose a global government. They warned of government “black helicopters” and a “paramilitary style attack against Americans,” and they called for people to rise up against the “abuse of power.” In April 1995, on the second anniversary of Waco, a white nationalist detonated a truck bomb outside the federal building in Oklahoma City, killing 168, many of them children.


You're following Dana Milbank's opinionsFollowing

In 2010, during the Obama administration, far-right, anti-government groups were again proliferating. Sarah Palin, the former vice-presidential nominee, issued her “Don’t Retreat, Instead — RELOAD!” edict, while prominent Republicans touted guns to fight “a tyrannical government” and told activists to be “armed and dangerous.” They warned that the country was under “attack” from a “gangster government.” A wave of threats and actual violence ensued — office windows shattered, armed demonstrators marching across from the capital — and culminated in a madman’s killing of six and grievous wounding of Rep. Gabby Giffords (D-Ariz.) at a community event.


Story continues below advertisement

Now, as in both of those cases, we are approaching the midterm elections of an incumbent Democratic president’s first term. Now, as in both cases, right-wing, anti-government groups are ascendant. And now it is easier for a group, or even a single mentally unstable person, to unleash mass carnage. Explosives are lighter. Inexpensive switches made on 3D printers can turn ordinary Glock handguns into fully automatic weapons capable of firing more than 15 rounds per second. The internet and encrypted communications facilitate widespread radicalization and coordination.


Monday’s search of Mar-a-Lago puts us at a perilous moment. NBC News reporter Ben Collins, who tracks pro-Trump online forums, tweeted that the posts Monday night were “as violent as I’ve seen them since before January 6th. Maybe even more so.”


Responsible media and political figures would, at the very least, counsel people to wait until all the facts about the Mar-a-Lago search are known. Instead, Republican officials encouraged hysteria. House GOP leader Kevin McCarthy accused the Justice Department of “an intolerable state of weaponized politicization.” Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis claimed the “weaponization of federal agencies against the Regime’s political opponents.” Others referenced “3rd world Marxist dictatorships,” Democrats “abusing power with no recourse,” and an FBI trying “to take political enemies out.”


Story continues below advertisement

Meanwhile, Newsmax hosted former New York police commissioner Bernard Kerik, who claimed to be “deathly afraid” that Trump will face “assassination.”


And from Fox News: “This is the worst attack on this Republic in modern history, period,” said radio host Mark Levin. “We’re at war,” said former Trump adviser Stephen K. Bannon, baselessly claiming White House Chief of Staff Ron Klain approved the search. “We need to choke down the FBI and choke down the Justice Department.”


On and on, they ranted: Fox News’s Dan Bongino said, “You do not live in a constitutional republic anymore.” Former Trump administration official Michael Caputo said, “The FBI is the KGB” after the “military-style raid.” Former Trump budget director Russ Vought wanted to “dismantle the FBI into a thousand bits.” Trump daughter-in-law Lara Trump said, “This should shake you to your core.” Host Laura Ingraham threatened that “when we get power back, it’s time to hold everyone accountable.”


These are open invitations to the violent and the unstable to take matters into their own hands.

Democrats’ $80 billion wager: A bigger IRS will be a better IRS

Democrats’ $80 billion wager: A bigger IRS will be a better IRS

Jacob Bogage — Read time: 5 minutes


Modernizing the tax collector is one of the keys to the party’s climate change and health care bill, but the agency has many problems after years of underfunding

Image without a caption

August 6, 2022 at 6:00 a.m. EDT


The Internal Revenue Service headquarters in Washington. The tax agency may get a lot more money from the climate, health care and tax bill the Senate is considering. (Susan Walsh/AP)

A newly empowered Internal Revenue Service is one of the keys to the sweeping climate, health care and tax bill Senate Democrats hope to pass this week — with billions of dollars in new funds for the agency so it can collect money for the federal government by going after higher-income tax cheats.


The bill, known as the Inflation Reduction Act, would put $80 billion toward beefing up the IRS, in line with liberals’ long-term goals to strengthen tax collection and enforcement on corporations and high-income earners, while relieving low-income taxpayers of cumbersome and frightening audits. Some of the additional revenue would go to pay for the largest-ever U.S. investment in clean energy technology.


The idea is that the government could bring in more money by examining corporate and high-income returns than it does by pursuing lower- or middle-income taxpayers who make mistakes on their returns or underpay their taxes by small amounts. The IRS in recent years has grown more dependent on those types of audits because they are relatively inexpensive: They’re automated, and they preserve the agency’s limited personnel resources. But they also mostly fall on taxpayers who can’t afford to fight back by spending hours on the phone with the tax agency or hiring lawyers.


Story continues below advertisement

The result is that the IRS’s prolific enforcement capabilities — which bring in on average better than $10 in revenue for every $1 spent pursuing audits — are often trained on the most economically vulnerable taxpayers.


More than half of the agency’s audits in 2021 were directed at taxpayers with incomes less than $75,000, according to IRS data. More than 4 in 10 of its audits targeted recipients of the earned income tax credit, one of the country’s main anti-poverty measures.


Congress and the White House, when led by Republicans, have starved the IRS of resources for so long, experts say, that even with an influx of $80 billion in new funding, the agency’s ability to transform itself is far from assured.


Story continues below advertisement

Some of its main computers still run on programming language that dates to the 1960s, called COBOL, the IRS has repeatedly told policymakers. The program is so old that college computer science courses rarely teach it anymore, forcing the IRS to spend heavily on training new hires in antiquated systems.


The IRS has 60 discrete case management systems that do not communicate with one another.


Its staffing levels have dropped by 17 percent since 2010, including a 30 percent decline in enforcement employees, because its budget has flatlined: Adjusted for inflation, its annual appropriation from Congress is down 12 percent over the same span, at $12.6 billion this year.


Story continues below advertisement

“Part of this is not expecting miraculous rates of return. It’s about stopping the decline,” said Douglas Holtz-Eakin, president of the conservative think tank American Action Forum and a former director of the Congressional Budget Office.


Republican lawmakers have bashed the legislation — which would be a signature achievement of President Biden’s first term — by claiming that a reinvigorated IRS would use its new resources to go after middle-class and poor Americans.


Speaking at a news conference Wednesday, Sen. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.), the head of the Senate Republican Conference, said the proposed spending would “put the IRS on steroids” and in total amounted to about “a million per IRS agent.”


Story continues below advertisement

“You don’t need that many IRS agents to go after a few people they say are very, very rich,” Barrasso said, adding that it would hit “families, farmers and the small businesses of Americans, that’s who’s going to bear the burden of this legislation.”


“This is an agency that only succeeded in answering about one out of every 50 phone calls during the 2021 tax season,” Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.) said on the Senate floor Tuesday. “Yet 4 percent of the $80 billion is going to taxpayer services; 57 percent goes to enforcement, so that the IRS can spend more time harassing taxpayers around this country.”


But experts say that’s a condition brought about largely by GOP policies, which drove the IRS into more audits of poorer taxpayers by depriving the agency of the resources it would have taken to go after wealthier targets who shelter potentially much higher sums.


Story continues below advertisement

IRS Commissioner Charles Rettig wrote to lawmakers on Thursday that his agency was committed to upping enforcement “in areas of challenge for the agency — large corporate and global high-net-worth taxpayers.” He added, “These resources are absolutely not about increasing audit scrutiny on small businesses or middle-income Americans.”


Rettig was appointed by President Donald Trump in 2018 after a career as a tax attorney in Beverly Hills, Calif. His term expires in November, and the Biden administration has been exploring other possible candidates for the role, people familiar with the matter told The Washington Post last month, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss private talks.


Without question, the proposed funding will help the IRS collect more revenue. An analysis conducted by the Congressional Budget Office, the legislature’s nonpartisan bookkeeper, found the IRS provisions would knock $203 billion off the federal deficit, far more than what Democrats expected when they introduced the bill.


Story continues below advertisement

Of the $80 billion total allotment to the tax agency, $45.6 billion will go to enforcement, marking a projected return-on-investment of $4.50 in revenue for every dollar spent on enforcement.


Experts say that figure — which is much lower than what the IRS typically brings in — has two potential explanations.


The first is that it could simply be a conservative estimate; with resources to hire hundreds, if not thousands, of employees, the agency could significantly exceed its revenue projections by both pursuing more tax cheats and by improving taxpayer services to make it easier for Americans to voluntarily comply with the tax code.


“If you are able to bring on a cadre of people who are really thinking forward … if they’re able to bring on the technology that allows them to bring on some of the data that they already have, that would have a compliance effect and help them going forward,” said Nina Olson, who served as national taxpayer advocate, the IRS’s internal consumer rights watchdog, from 2001 to 2019. “That would help, and I hope that’s what they’re planning to do.”


Story continues below advertisement

The second explanation, experts say, is that cracking down on higher-income taxpayers comes with diminishing returns — even if the amount of money involved is potentially far larger. Rich people who file complex returns have access to accountants and lawyers who can fight the IRS’s enforcement mechanisms, or at least draw the process out over years.


Even when the IRS is able to collect from those types of taxpayers, it will have expended lots of resources in the process.


“That’s not an effective place to go raise revenue,” Holtz-Eakin said, even if having an enforcement presence among the wealthy is important to maintain fairness.


Tony Romm contributed to this report.

Justice Alito is living up to promises to supporters of his nomination

Justice Alito is living up to promises to supporters of his nomination

Duncan Hosie — Read time: 7 minutes


His anger and commitment to expanding the meaning of freedom of religion are exactly what his champions wanted in a justice.

Duncan Hosie is a writer and civil rights lawyer. A graduate of Yale Law School, he previously was a Marshall scholar at the University of Oxford, where he received a master's degree in history.

August 9, 2022 at 6:00 a.m. EDT


In his first public speech since writing the opinion that overturned Roe v. Wade and eliminated the constitutional right to an abortion, Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. was angry. Speaking recently at a gilded hall in Rome, Alito ridiculed world leaders who criticized his decision. His sardonic broadsides went viral, with legal observers agape at the spectacle of a sitting Supreme Court justice swiping at Justin Trudeau, Boris Johnson and Emmanuel Macron.


Alito’s headline-grabbing attacks crowded out discussion of another important part of his speech: his comments on religion. He bemoaned America’s “increasingly secular society” and its “turn away from” religion. He quoted scripture and, echoing St. Augustine, said “our hearts are restless until we rest in God.”


Alito also suggested two groups — nonbelievers and people who think religion is “just not all that important” — threaten “religious liberty.” These are fighting words that show a fundamental misunderstanding of the Constitution’s commitment to the separation of church and state. But no one should be surprised. These beliefs pervade the Christian Right, and in fact, Alito’s support for them are a reason he became a Supreme Court justice in the first place.


Story continues below advertisement

Alito rose to the Supreme Court thanks to luck, loyalty to the legal right and a game of musical chairs. When Justice Sandra Day O’Connor retired in 2005, President George W. Bush first nominated John G. Roberts Jr. to fill her seat. A few weeks later, he named Roberts to fill a new vacancy created by the death of Chief Justice William Rehnquist, and slotted his White House counsel, Harriet Miers, to fill O’Connor’s seat.


The religious right immediately recoiled at Miers. Some raised concrete objections. She had previously donated to conservative Democrats. Worse, social conservatives saw her answers to an election questionnaire in 1989 as insufficiently opposed to LGBTQ rights. Others fretted that she lacked the verve, ideology and chops to challenge the left — especially when the appointed hour came to overturn Roe v. Wade.


Some of this speculation was baseless; Miers had been a member of Texas Right to Life and led a charge to remove a bar association’s support for abortion rights in the mid-1990s. But Miers didn’t have an extensive paper trail on the issue, and she gave cagey and confusing answers when pressed by Republican senators about whether she believed in a constitutional right to privacy.


Story continues below advertisement

The right revolted over her nomination, going so far as to buy television commercials clamoring for a more conservative pick. Their mutiny, along with Miers’s uneven performance as she courted senators, made continuing with the nomination untenable for Bush and forced Miers to withdraw.


But the initial choice unnerved the President’s supporters, who began to question whether Bush was truly committed to using courts to achieve sweeping right-wing social policy.


In a bid to appease them, Bush then nominated Alito, a stalwart conservative whom the right trusted to remake America’s highest court. Alito had spent his life in the trenches of the conservative legal movement. Alito went to law school, in his telling, because he disagreed with Warren Court decisions about the separation of church and state and the rights of criminal defendants and voters. As a federal appellate judge, he consistently ruled against some (prisoners, death row inmates and victims of discrimination seeking redress in courts) and consistently for others (police, corporations and Christians).


Story continues below advertisement

Crucially, he passed the right’s anti-Roe litmus test with flying colors. In fact, as a Department of Justice lawyer in the 1980s, he helped craft a legal strategy to undermine the constitutional right to abortion. And as a lower court judge in 1991, he famously wrote a solo-dissent arguing that a state law requiring women to notify their husbands before obtaining an abortion did not unduly burden their privacy rights, a view later rejected by the Supreme Court.


The justice he would ultimately replace, Justice O’Connor, rebuked Alito’s extreme position, noting with two other justices that “a state may not give to a man the kind of dominion over his wife that parents exercise over their children.” To the religious right, Alito’s position on marital dominion was a virtue, not a vice, and they quickly mobilized to get him confirmed.


Nothing illustrated their commitment to Alito quite like the national telecast held on the eve of his confirmation hearing in January 2006. It was the third installment of a series called “Justice Sunday” intended to boost support for President Bush’s judicial nominees. Broadcast on Christian radio and television and beamed into churches all across America, this pro-Alito production had the potential to reach over 80 million households. The speakers were a who’s who of the religious right: televangelists, politicians, fundamentalist pastors, avowed Christian nationalists, conservative legal movement tacticians and right-wing gadflies.


Story continues below advertisement

To muster support for Alito’s nomination, Justice Sunday orators flirted with calls for the United States to become a theocracy and posited that Christianity should occupy a place of primacy in American life. Don Feder, the president of an organization called “Jews Against anti-Christian Defamation,” told Justice Sunday viewers point blank that America’s Constitution was made for government by Christians.


Rev. Jerry Falwell claimed in his address that there had been a “terrible move toward secularization in our county” that Alito could help staunch. “Let’s confirm this man, Judge Alito, to the U.S. Supreme Court, and let’s make one more step toward bringing America back to one nation under God,” he said. Name checking Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas, Falwell proclaimed that Alito would be part of a Godly “reconstruction of a court system gone awry.”


Speaker after speaker argued liberals persecuted American Christians, pointing to federal court decisions preventing Christians from using the government to promote their faith. And Sen. Rick Santorum (R-P. A.) told the Justice Sunday crowd that Alito would stand athwart to “extreme liberal judges” who were “destroying traditional morality, creating a new moral code which prohibits any dissent.”


Story continues below advertisement

After the Senate confirmed his nomination, Alito wrote an unusual thank you note to James Dobson, a key figure in the Christian right who spoke at Justice Sunday. “This is just a short note to express my heartfelt thanks to you and the entire staff at Focus on the Family for your help and support during the past few, challenging months,” the freshly-seated justice wrote. “As long as I serve on the Supreme Court, I will keep in mind the trust that has been placed in me.”


He has stayed true to that promise. The Justice Sunday speakers stewed in grievance and victimhood, conflating the loss of Christian cultural power with oppression. This thinking infused Alito’s recent speech in Rome. Echoing Santorum, he condemned the “growing hostility to religion, or at least the traditional religious beliefs that are contrary to the new moral code that is ascendant in some sectors.” And he suggested Christianity should be treated with special concern and regard in Western society, recounting his horror over seeing a young boy at a Berlin museum who couldn’t identify Christian iconography.


This thinking also permeates Alito’s jurisprudence. In 2015, for example, he argued in dissent that the Supreme Court’s decision-making same-sex marriage a right would be used to “vilify Americans who are unwilling to assent to the new orthodoxy.” Equal constitutional rights would be “exploited by those who are determined to stamp out every vestige of dissent” and cause the “marginalization of the many Americans who have traditional ideas” about the subjugation of LGBTQ people.


Story continues below advertisement

He has almost reflexively voted to erode the separation of church and state, undermine LGBTQ rights and dole out new privileges for Christians to free them from complying with secular laws. Perhaps most consequentially, he penned the theologically-inspired opinion overturning Roe that has led scores of states to ban abortion on religious grounds.


Justice Alito refracts his jurisprudence through the stained glass of the Christian right and its resentments, and he relishes being a combatant in the culture war. His Rome speech shows that he’s not stopping anytime soon.

Monday, August 8, 2022

Democrats' primary meddling is part of a bigger problem

 Democrats' primary meddling is part of a bigger problem


It's a bad system for picking nominees

By Matthew Yglesias

Rep. Peter Meijer has not amassed a particularly moderate voting record in the United States House of Representatives. But he did tell the truth about the 2020 election and voted to impeach Donald Trump, opening himself to a primary challenge from a Trump-backed candidate.


Interestingly, the challenger — John Gibbs — was also de facto backed by the DCCC, which aired “critical” ads saying things like, “Gibbs is pro-life and loves the second amendment.” The D-Trip, in other words, tried to raise Gibbs’ name recognition while portraying him as an orthodox conservative. Then having helped put Gibbs over the top, Democrats are now going to turn around and argue (correctly) that Gibbs is a dangerous extremist. I am not especially familiar with the congressional district in question, but the consensus seems to be that Meijer was an unusually strong candidate (his anti-Trump stance gives him credibility with independents and his family name is ubiquitous in the area because they own an important Midwestern grocery chain) whereas Gibbs is potentially beatable, even in a bad year for Democrats.


Democrats have employed this controversial tactic in a range of races across the 2022 campaign.


My initial view was that trying to get Republicans to nominate extremists is dumb. But then I felt like the backlash was overwrought and overstated. Now, I’ve looped around to “worse than a crime, a mistake” because I’m not sure these gambits have the tactical upside that cynical Democratic operatives think they do. After all, the upshot of the DCCC trying to help out Gibbs is that Meijer is now reassuring moderate voters that they should back Gibbs and the whole GOP ticket.


While the race was pretty close, the margin wasn’t razor-thin — Gibbs won 52-48. The DCCC didn’t actually invest that much money in the race, and Meijer and allies badly outspent Gibbs and his friends. All of which is to say that I think it’s really unclear that the DCCC’s intervention was actually decisive here. But it does seem to have been decisive in shaping Meijer’s reaction to losing a primary over opposing the violent overthrow of the American government. Instead of talking to the press about how the GOP is being taken over by dangerous extremists, he’s decided that Democrats are full of shit and he should throw in with the hard right.


Fundamentally, I just think this is a lot less clever than the people doing it seem to believe.


Getting the cost-benefit calculus correct

At the end of the day, it’s not good enough to just say, “Gibbs is more beatable than Meijer, so we should spend money helping Gibbs beat Meijer.”


Aside from the question of doing the right thing, other factors matter:


How much does our money really boost Gibbs’ odds of beating Meijer?


How much easier is Gibbs for Hillary Scholten to beat?


How much does it strengthen Gibbs in the general election for Democrats to have angered Meijer in this way?


What was the next-best use of this DCCC money in terms of running ads directly supporting Sholten or other Democratic candidates?


Given that the GOP is going to be running pro-insurrection candidates in the vast majority of races, regardless of the outcome in MI-3, how much does it help all of their campaigns for the Democratic Party to compromise its brand in this way?


I’m quite skeptical that the investment of even a modest amount of money in the Gibbs-Meijer primary pencils out.


My main contribution to this debate is to say that factor (4), the most boring thing on this list, also tends to be underrated.


If I were Jared Golden in Maine, I’d be pretty mad. Money that could have been spent on Bangor television ads touting his independent thinking and work to boost domestic fossil fuel production was instead spent on a weird bankshot play in Michigan that, via mechanism (5), makes life a little bit harder for almost every Democrat in the country.


Note that this is an individualized assessment of the circumstances. In Colorado, the DSCC spent some money trying to help Ron Hanks win the nomination to run against Michael Bennet. In that case, I think the cost-benefit analysis probably militates in favor of meddling. Every Democratic Senate incumbent that I’m aware of is positioned to badly outspend his or her opponent, so the opportunity cost of getting creative is low. And Hanks was probably genuinely unelectable in Colorado, so the expected value of putting him over the top was pretty high. Finally, the value of an individual Senate seat is a lot higher than the value of an individual House seat, so the risk of incurring national brand damage is less serious.


Of course, despite the DSCC’s efforts, Hanks lost.


Which, I think, is the fundamental issue here. Democratic Party political operatives cannot actually control Republican Party primary voters’ behavior. The ultimate culpability for nominating bad candidates like Gibbs lies with Republicans — a huge swathe of the party wants pro-insurrection figures — and the main effect of “boosting” insurrectionists has been to muddy the waters. This became a subject of national controversy because Meijer specifically seems really hung up on it, but the fact is, he probably would have lost anyway.


Republicans are responsible for their actions

A lot of Republicans in the media find that while they can’t defend the more indefensible aspects of Trumpism, at the end of the day they prefer that Republicans beat Democrats because that helps keep taxes low and make abortion illegal.


And from these anti-anti-Trump Republicans, we’ve heard an an endless procession of explanations for why the bad things about Trump are really Democrats’ fault. For that set, this meddling is the latest excuse for their own apologetics: “Democrats say it’s bad to encourage a violent mob to storm the United States Capitol and threaten to murder Mike Pence, but they also prioritize winning as many elections as they can over helping sensible Republicans.”


And I think that just doesn’t wash.


The GOP decided long ago that it was in its interests to take a hostile attitude toward a neutral, truth-seeking media and toward neutral, truth-seeking expertise. Discrediting knowledge-producing institutions is useful for promoting policies like regressive tax cuts or for pretending that regulation of public health externalities is never warranted. Before Pence was a potential victim of a murderous mob ginned up by his boss, he was a guy who ran around denying that smoking cigarettes kills people. The first time I met Pence, he claimed it was possible to privatize Social Security in a way that guaranteed higher benefits for everyone without creating moral hazard or increasing the deficit.


He did the right thing on January 6, 2021, and he deserves praise for that.


But the climate of lies and nonsense that Trump exploited is something that the conservative establishment cultivated and participated in for years before Trump waltzed in. He’s been able to exploit it and that, much more than anything Democrats have or could do, is the main issue here.


Outside of their own political conduct, conservatives often emphasize the importance of cultivating an internal locus of control and an ethic of personal responsibility. We are all in part victims of circumstances in everything that we do. But dwelling on that is unhealthy psychologically and can be socially quite destructive, and Republicans should make a genuine effort to take stock of what’s going on.


Donald Trump is the GOP’s biggest candidate quality problem

Polling currently gives Republicans a roughly 50-50 chance of retaking the Senate.


That’s a dismal performance considering that it’s a midterm with an unpopular incumbent Democratic Party president. And that dismal polling reflects the fact that Republicans have fielded a ton of individual candidates who are underperforming expectations. Some of those underperforming candidates, like JD Vance in Ohio, are clearly favored to win anyway. But others, like Mehmet Oz in Pennsylvania, stand a real chance of blowing clearly winnable races. And there are two common threads among the currently underperforming GOP Senate candidates:


The party nominated an “unconventional” candidate rather than a sitting House member or down-ballot state officeholder.


Donald Trump personally intervened to help the candidate win.


In most of these cases, there is no Meijer-like martyr figure. Nobody is totally sure why Trump favored Oz in the Pennsylvania race, but it wasn’t because there were no anti-impeachment, pro-insurrection Pennsylvania Republican politicians available. Trump just decided he wanted to support a Turkish dual citizen who lives in New Jersey.


Normally you expect party leaders to prioritize electability over ideological considerations. And to the extent that they do prioritize ideological considerations, you expect there to be some kind of logic to their actions.


But Oz doesn’t have any unusual policy views at all, as far as I can tell. He’s running as a standard-issue conservative Republican who just happens to live in New Jersey and lacks political experience. He’s a veteran, which is a good resume item for a non-politician, but he’s a veteran of the Turkish military — normally American political parties try to nominate people who served in the American military. It’s just a weird blunder of a choice. I’d say Trump is looking for sycophants and personal loyalists, but Vance once argued that Trump is like heroin, poisoning the communities he claims to represent. I thought it was an insightful article, but again, an odd choice when there are plenty of banal Republican politicians kicking around Ohio.


I’m inclined to believe that a lot of people in D.C. underestimate Trump’s smarts and that there’s some kind of angle he’s working that I just don’t quite see. But whatever the angle is, it’s not the best interests of the Republican party as conventionally defined. And that, much more than anything Democrats are doing, is the proximate problem facing the GOP.


I know this is a pretty hot take, but the whole “meddling” dispute has been a reminder that deciding nominations with primary elections is a kind of weird idea.


I was thinking about this when I realized that the U.K. Conservative leadership contest is happening as an American-style primary, since the British parties have apparently moved away from the parliamentary tradition of having party leaders be selected by the caucus of MPs. This is too bad, because I don’t think our way has a lot to recommend itself.


What’s interesting about the Meijer situation is that because the stakes with insurrection and election denial are so large, there’s actually a decent case against DCCC meddling. But in the more standard case where it’s just a primary between two different guys and one of them is kind of a bozo or has a track-record of making extreme claims, then I don’t think there is much of a reason not to meddle. The fact that Blake Masters is on record as favoring privatization of Social Security is just gravy for liberals that makes Mark Kelly more likely to win while having no downside, compared to Republicans nominating someone who’s more circumspect. As I’ve argued before, progressives are very lucky to have Joe Manchin in the Senate rather than running a conventional liberal who would lose. And Democrats would do well to nominate more Manchin-like figures in places like Texas, Florida, North Carolina, and Iowa where mainstream Democrats all-but-inevitably fall short.


By the same token, it’s in Republicans’ interests to make sure that Democrats stick as closely as possible to the Jamie Harrison playbook of losing badly while making out-of-state donors feel good about themselves.


It would be better for America for both parties to try to move closer to the median voter. But it’s good for each party to encourage the opposition to move further from the median voter. Primaries already seem to me to excessively encourage extremism by giving too much influence to expressive voters; the fact that they’re potentially subject to deliberate manipulation only makes them worse. And I think a lot of DCCC critics are not taking seriously enough how big their ask is — they want an organization whose only purpose on earth is to help Democrats win House seats to voluntarily forego a tactic that could advance that purpose. In the specific Meijer case, I think there’s an argument that they outsmarted themselves and genuinely shouldn’t have done it. But in general, hoping extremists win nominations on the other side is an effective tactic, and we’ll see more of it if it’s seen as something that works. What we ought to be doing is trying to develop a nomination system that is not as subject to manipulation.