Sunday, July 24, 2022
Radical Taxation - Dissent Magazine - Vanessa Williamson
Saturday, July 23, 2022
Russia’s Economy Really Is Crumbling Under Sanctions
La Dolce Mailbag by Matthew Yglesias
Friday, July 22, 2022
I'm worried about Chicago by Matthew Yglesias
I'm worried about Chicago by Matthew Yglesias
— Read time: 8 minutes
I'm worried about Chicago
Slowing national population growth plus remote work spell big trouble for Midwestern cities
The large hedge fund Citadel announced last week that it’s leaving Chicago.
That’s hot on the heels of two even larger companies, Boeing and Caterpillar, departing for greener pastures. This has naturally prompted a lot of narrowly partisan and narrowly political bickering in and around the state of Illinois. But stepping back, I think it’s an opportunity to reflect on some more fundamental issues. In particular, while the shift to remote work is a challenge for all kinds of places, I think it’s a dire threat to places like Chicago that were affordable but slow-growing before the pandemic.
These are the kinds of places that get discussed least in the American discourse, which tends to pay a lot of attention to the struggles of the expensive coastal metro areas (New York, Boston, Seattle, San Francisco) and the fast-growing Sun Belt ones (Atlanta, Houston, Dallas, Phoenix). But as we are reminded every time we look at the Electoral College, there are still a lot of people living in these low-cost, slow-growing parts of America. Of these places, Chicago is by far the largest. And while it’s perhaps not quite as economically successful as Minneapolis or Columbus, it’s also clearly the economic center of the region.
So if Chicago enters a downward spiral — which I think it will — that bodes poorly for a whole bunch of other central cities but also I think really for the region as a whole.
Expensive cities are going to get cheaper
I grew up in Manhattan, a place I love, but everything in Manhattan is impossibly expensive — including both the housing and the office space.
This to me is a really good reason not to live in New York. But how did it get so expensive? Well, there was a lot of demand for New York, but that demand ran up against what’s known in economics as “inelastic supply.” In other words, it’s really hard to build more. Some of that is due to fundamentals; the economics of knocking down a building that is already enormous in order to replace it with an even more gigantic building are really bad. But a lot of it is due to zoning, historic preservation, and other supply constraining policies.
The low supply elasticity means that when demand for NYC surged, the response was much higher prices and a slightly larger supply.
A city like Houston, where the history and policy are different, has seen the other outcome: a huge surge in the number of homes (and people) and only modest increases in price. All things considered, the Houston way is better.
But one thing New York does have going for it is that even though Midtown is currently unusually empty due to the Zoom shock, it shouldn’t stay empty for too long. Before the pandemic, Midtown Manhattan office space was very expensive due to high demand and inelastic supply. Now that demand for office space in general has fallen, the price of Midtown office space will fall a lot, but at the new cheaper prices you’d still expect someone to lease it. Ultimately, all the retailers serving the office commuters should have customers. And the same thing happens on the residential side. To the extent people leave the city now that they no longer “have to” live there for work, the price will fall, and someone else moves in at the new lower price.
This price adjustment is a problem for the tax base, and local officials might completely bungle it. But it’s fundamentally a solvable problem. There is tons of “shadow demand” for both dwellings and office space in New York.
This is to say that I expect post-pandemic New York to more closely resemble pre-pandemic Chicago — a city that was poorer than New York but that had very appealing big city amenities and noticeably lower prices. The first two times I went to Chicago, all I could think about was, “why doesn’t everyone move here?” Then I went in February and I found out. But still. For anyone who liked cities but wasn’t a billionaire, it had a lot of appealing qualities. But that greater affordability means that Chicago doesn’t have the same cushion in the face of a relative decline in demand compared to America’s exurbs and rural areas.
Chicago housing might get too cheap
Housing costs are up a lot nationally as part of overall inflation, which can create sort of distorted impressions of what’s going on. I’ve spoken to Realtors, for example, who were under the impression that the D.C. real estate market was “going crazy” at least until recent Federal Reserve interest rate hikes.
In reality, though, the D.C. area’s 8 percent increase in rents is one of the smallest in the country. There’s been a large relative decline in housing demand in D.C., but in the context of overall rising prices. The right way to think about this is that metro areas like D.C., the Bay Area, Seattle, Chicago, Houston, and St. Louis have gotten cheaper relative to the national average, relative to wages, and relative to the cost of construction.
If you zero in on the city of Chicago, as opposed to the metro area, you can see that it’s gotten cheaper since the pandemic struck and people place less of a premium on convenient commuting access to the Loop.
And while cheaper is in some ways good, it can actually be bad if your city was already cheap. Before the pandemic, Issi Romem wrote a great analysis that compared the cost of houses in different metro areas to the cost of building a house. Places with very high ratios on this chart are places where land is super-expensive and new housing is hard to build. That’s bad. Then there’s a healthy Chicago/Atlanta zone where homes are more expensive than construction costs, but only a little bit more expensive.
But then you have the Detroit Zone where the cost of buying a home is less than the construction cost of building one.
Once a city slips into this zone, bad things happen. Suddenly if you’re a landlord, it doesn’t make sense in cost-benefit terms to do timely repairs on your building. If you’re an owner-occupant, you’re of course going to treat yourself better than a profit-seeking landlord would and so you do the repairs anyway. But that just means your house has become a sinkhole for money and sweat equity. Construction jobs tend to vanish. If a home gets foreclosed on or becomes badly damaged, there’s a tendency for it to become vacant, dealing a blow to the city’s tax base and creating a source of blight. If your home value to replacement cost ratio is really high, then a negative shock to demand just means the city reaches a new more affordable equilibrium. But if it’s already modest, as it was in Chicago pre-pandemic, then you can easily tilt into a cycle of decline.
The downward spiral
When cities start shrinking, things can get really bad.
The tax base shrinks, but legacy pension obligations don’t, and the ratio of taxes to public services becomes worse.
With the number of customers in structural decline, it’s harder for any local restaurant or retail business to succeed, so people with aspirations to found their own business tend to migrate elsewhere.
Under-used infrastructure is wasteful and expensive to maintain.
Because the existing stock of buildings isn’t worth replacing or refurbishing, your city’s capital base wastes away.
We have seen lots of examples of this happening to American cities, mostly in the midwest but also in a lot of smaller northeastern industrial cities. Sometimes a city in decline turns around the way Boston and New York have, by reinventing themselves as information-age havens. But this is the exception rather than the rule, and I think it’s also more attributable to good luck1 than to any smart policy choices made by the leaders of those cities.
Chicago becoming distressed is potentially very dire because so many other midwestern cities were already depressed before the pandemic, and their central business districts will be experiencing similar blows from remote work. And since cities are impacted by the cities they’re connected to, Chicago joining the cycle of decline will, I think, tend to drag down Detroit and Cleveland and St. Louis.
San Francisco vs. Austin and New York vs. Miami have a kind of fun regional rivalry dynamic that is intensified by the fact that these cities symbolize larger ideological trends. But the entire Midwest slipping deeper into a funk as its cities decay and its biggest employers depart is just depressing, and people don’t generally seem to want to talk about it.
The rising tide we don’t have
Someone is sure to say, “You’re always complaining about NIMBYs and how the rent is too damn high and now you’re telling me it’s bad if Chicago gets cheaper?”
The thing to remember is that in this post, we’ve been talking about prices falling due to a fall in demand.
That’s different from prices falling due to an increase in the elasticity of supply.
My general view is that whether we’re talking about labor or housing, restricting supply in order to raise prices is a terrible idea. But prices rising due to strong demand is good. The problem facing Chicago and other midwestern cities is that low demand is not an affordability strategy — it’s a recipe for failure.
And the solution, fundamentally, has to come from outside the region. The only reason that falling relative demand for Chicago is translating into falling absolute demand for Chicago is that overall American population growth has slowed to a crawl as the once-robust flow of immigrants has turned into a trickle and the birthrate has continued to decline. In the longer run, we should be doing much more to support parents and children. But in the shorter term, the country would benefit from significantly more immigration. I’d be thrilled to defer to immigration skeptics about exactly which immigrants we let in and under which terms, but it should be more people. Make them speak English, make them pass some public charge test, make them have college degrees or score over 100 on an IQ test or whatever you want.
But it ought to be more people. Per capita GDP in Illinois is higher than Norway and more than 50 percent higher than Italy, to say nothing of the many countries around the world that are poorer than Italy. Whatever Chicago’s problems, there are billions of people on the planet who could secure superior opportunities in life by gaining permission to live there. And there could be big advantages to the United States in accelerating our population growth rate rather than allowing cities with below-average demand to slip into spirals of decline.
Wednesday, July 20, 2022
Good-bye to Biden’s Social-Policy Agenda
Tuesday, July 19, 2022
Amtrak's proposed Union Station renovation is a terrible idea / Matthew Yglesias
Amtrak's proposed Union Station renovation is a terrible idea / Matthew Yglesias — Read time: 11 minutes
Amtrak's proposed Union Station renovation is a terrible idea
An object lesson in American agencies' refusal to coordinate
A bit over a year ago, New York City premiered the Moynihan Train Hall at Penn Station, a very expensive train-related infrastructure project that did not increase the number of trains that can roll through Penn Station nor make the trains go faster nor increase the number of destinations the station can serve. In other words, it was a train project that had nothing to do with trains.
And now Amtrak wants to undertake a $10 billion reconstruction of Union Station in D.C. The project looks great in the renderings, but that raises similar questions. Amtrak is not saying this will allow them to provide new service to and from Union Station. They’re not saying it will increase the frequency of the trains that serve the station. Nor will the trains pass through, into, or out of the station faster. Because the renovation is not actually a renovation of the functional part of the station.
They’re also not talking about touching the historic Union Station building, a gorgeous architectural gem. Instead, the plan is basically to build a nicer shopping mall between the historic building and the platforms:
Visitors can make their way from the historic building to a new train hall, which is designed for daylight and for passengers to more easily spot where to catch their bus or train. The station also connects to Metro and DC Circulator services.
Parking is located at the lowest level, along with the majority of the pickup and drop-off area and two of the four concourses lined with retailors. From there, visitors have their pick of escalator or elevator to travel up to the train station. And above the train station is the bus facility. The project assumes increased use, so bus and train capacity has been added. The highest level offers an outdoor deck where people can be dropped off or picked up, or simply leisure along some green space.
There is also an ambitious plan to build a deck over the platforms themselves and the tracks north of the station to create a 15-acre mixed-use real estate development called Burnham Place.
These are just weird ideas to be seeking public funding for. Replacing the dingy existing train hall has some obvious upsides, but this is a commercial real estate project — either the nicer shopping facility will generate enough in additional sales and retail rents that it pencils out or it won’t. Either way, a real estate development project adjacent to the station should be a source of revenue for Amtrak, not something that it asks money for.
The point of spending public funds on train-related infrastructure upgrades should be to make the trains better.
The D.C. area needs infrastructure investments
As I’ve written a couple of times before, the D.C. area has most of the infrastructure it needs to stitch together MARC commuter rail to Maryland and VRE commuter rail to Virginia into a high-quality, high-frequency regional rail system similar to the RER in Paris or to the S-Bahns in the German-speaking world.
D.C. (unlike, say, Boston) already has a tunnel under the city that connects the tracks heading north to Baltimore to the tracks that head south. So just as some Amtrak trains currently pass through the city to serve points south, Maryland commuter trains could pass through the city to serve the huge job center at the Pentagon and then run out into the Virginia suburbs. And Virginia commuter trains could pass through the city into the Maryland suburbs and reach Baltimore. But a few changes are needed to make this a good experience that involves trains that run quickly and frequently at an affordable price:
Electrifying two of MARC’s three lines (one is already electrified) and both of the VRE lines
Replacing the MARC/VRE rolling stock with electric multiple units that accelerate faster out of the stations and can speed things up
Lots of small station upgrades in Virginia to create high platforms that let passengers board level with the train doors — this speeds ingress and egress and is a huge deal for accessibility
Replacing the Long Bridge over the Potomac River with one that has a higher capacity
Paying off a lot of wasteful conductors and replacing them with a system that requires spot checks of tickets in order to reduce labor costs and fares
These are non-trivial infrastructure investments, but they have a clear purpose related to transportation. Trips that are possible with the current infrastructure would become faster, more frequent, and more affordable with these upgrades. And many trips that are not currently possible would become possible. That’s the kind of thing the United States should be spending transportation infrastructure money on, making transportation infrastructure better.
Alon Levy, outraged by the extraordinary expense of the $10 billion station renovation project, has billions in new Metro construction projects they think D.C. should do over and above these commuter rail upgrades. I would love for everyone to get their shit together and do that stuff, too. But what I’m struck by is that before you even get into details of what’s a good project and what’s a bad one or what’s cost-effective and what isn’t, there’s a basic category error in these station projects: I want America’s transportation agencies to spend money on ideas to improve ridership while they want to do generic real estate development.
Train stations aren’t airports
Ever since I started writing about Amtrak’s peculiar ideas about how to board trains, I’ve noticed that the agency is inevitably run by an American airline-industry veteran rather than by a foreigner who has experience working at a successful passenger railroad. So really basic points like “trains have multiple doors while airplanes have just one and this makes a difference” seem to slip their grasp.
While planes have a lot of good features, those features often mean that the air travel experience involves a lot of waiting around in airports. Not only are planes fast, but they can also connect arbitrary geographies, which lets airlines do two things very well that even the more successful train systems don’t:
Low-frequency routes — United flies once a day between D.C. and Rome. So if you’re booked on that flight, missing it carries a very high cost. To avoid the high cost of missing that flight, most people arrive quite a bit early and end up waiting in the airport.
Hub and spoke transfers — People from smaller cities across the southeastern United States can take small planes to Dulles and switch to a larger plane serving Rome or other major international destinations. But transfer passengers need to wait for their flight.
On top of these two sources of waiting around, airports are generally very far from the city center. And even when they are kind of close, the security requirements mean there is a hard boundary between what’s inside the airport and what’s outside the airport. So making the airport a pleasant place to sit around and wait is a crucial determinant of the trip experience. The fact that Dulles isn’t very nice is a legitimate reason for a would-be traveler on a connecting flight to prefer to go through a different airport. That’s a bona fide competitive disadvantage for United vis a vis other carriers that use nicer hubs. So while making the airport nicer isn’t the biggest priority in the world for the airline (if it were, they’d have done it already), it’s absolutely on the list.
Train stations aren’t really like that — transfers are pretty unimportant. What trains are good at providing is frequent service along a busy corridor, mostly to commuters. And most of all, the station is right in the middle of the city with no security barriers.
Train stations aren’t important
Historically, of course, train stations were very important locations for buying train tickets.
They also contained big signs alerting people about train departure times and track assignments. Today, though, these functions are much less crucial because people have e-tickets on their phones and because railroads should (though they oftentimes don’t) deliver schedule updates and track information to people’s phones. This means that in the modern world, train stations are more different from airports than ever since the main “a lot of people need to wait around here” functions of a train station are now obsolete. There’s absolutely no reason passengers couldn’t kill time at a coffee shop across the street from a train station and then zip directly to the track based on a mobile update.
None of which is to say that cities should be demolishing their train stations, eliminating ticket vendor machines, or pulling down clocks and signs with schedule information. As long as you have the building, you may as well use it.
But if you don’t, that’s okay. Consider the L’Enfant Plaza VRE station that’s south of the national mall. Even though this is right in the city, it’s essentially identical to a very humble commuter rail station in the middle of nowhere. It has some tracks and a couple of platforms. With through-running investments, more riders would use the station. But there’s no need for a huge investment in improving the station itself. Passengers who want to buy some food before boarding a train at L’Enfant can go to one of the food trucks that park nearby or to one of the shops in the surrounding city blocks. It’s just a place in the city. Its important function is that trains stop there and people can get off or on.
The existing historic Union Station building is already a very nice shopping-type venue — they’ve got a Chopt, a Chipotle, a Cava, a Shake Shack, a Blue Bottle, a Roti, a Potbelly, and I think a Pizzeria Uno. If the modern building between the historic building and the tracks is overcrowded, that reflects two things.
One is that they don’t let people directly access the train platforms and wait there. The other is that they are stuffing the building with this additional tier of retail — a Sbarro’s, a Claire’s, a Victoria’s Secret, a Jamba Juice and a Juice Press, etc. — right where the most reasonable place for people to wait is.
I don’t feel that the crowding situation really is that bad or that it would necessarily warrant removing some of the existing retail. Giving people access to the platforms is a good idea for other reasons and would reduce crowding. But if the feeling is that something needs to be done that would cost money and alleviate crowding, then opening up the space and accepting reduced retail revenue seems like the obvious choice rather than a $10 billion construction project. Meanwhile, there is plenty of space to develop more retail options.
The Architect of the Capitol is the real villain here
Far and away the biggest design flaw with Union Station is that rather than being surrounded by a busy district of office buildings with ground-floor retail, it’s surrounded by surface parking lots (directly east of North Capitol and between 1st Street and 2nd Street) and a totally vacant park (between the station and D Street).
This is not land that is owned by Amtrak, so it can’t be the focus of an Amtrak-specific real estate development project. It’s instead controlled by the United States Congress, specifically the Architect of the Capitol’s office, which controls the Capitol building itself and the nearby congressional office buildings.
If you gave me magic powers, I would turn one of these blocks into a large new congressional office building and the others could be sold for private development. Pre-Zoom, I would have guessed that meant commercial office space, but these days housing is probably more likely. Either way, you’d have underground parking garages and plenty of street-level retail. The benefit to Union Station would be that the station is more knit into the neighborhood and there is less need for loitering passengers to specifically congregate in the station rather than nearby.
In the real world, of course, the issue is that Amtrak controls Union Station but does not control those adjacent parcels — that’s Congress. At the same time, we’re talking about the national legislature here and a state-owned railroad company. And the inability of the American public sector to coordinate with itself is a constant source of problems.
A failure to communicate
Think back to the idea of S-Bahn service for the D.C.-Baltimore area. Delivering it would require some infrastructure investments: a bunch of stations would need their platforms raised, plus a new bridge, electrified tracks, and new rolling stock.
But while this isn’t trivial, it’s very much doable, especially in a world where numbers like $10 billion are being thrown around.
The harder part is that for MARC/VRE through-running to work, MARC and VRE would need to coordinate with each other and with Amtrak. They would also need to lay off a bunch of conductors to reduce fares and operating costs. Now many more trains would be running under this paradigm, so there wouldn’t even necessarily be job losses in the aggregate. But jobs would have to be reallocated. And of course you’d need to cooperate with the Architect of the Capitol on developing the real estate assets.
Coordination on anything resembling this level just seems far beyond the capacity of American agencies.
A key element in the German S-Bahn model is fare integration. What you pay to get from Point A to Point B in Berlin is determined by how far you traveled, not whether you went on S-Bahn or U-Bahn or a combination of the two or whether or not a bus was involved. Currently, neither MARC nor VRE integrates fares with the Metro system run by WMATA. In New York, the commuter rail systems and the subway are both run by the MTA, but they don’t integrate fares. MetroNorth and LIRR can’t even agree on whether it’s “rail road” or “railroad.” And in D.C., WMATA doesn’t integrate bus fares with metro fares.
There’s no one single reason why America spends too much money on low-value transportation projects. Some of it has to do with NIMBYism and adversarial legalism. But a lot of it has to do with this inability to cooperate. Many of the highest-value projects require a lot of coordination to implement, and in practice a lot of agency project planning is driven by a desire not to coordinate. This Union Station plan isn’t the answer to the question “what’s a good way to improve train service in the D.C. area?” — it’s an answer to the question “what would be a cool asset for Amtrak to own and control?”
But that’s the wrong question.
Thursday, July 14, 2022
Republican Boycott of Jan. 6 Committee Is Backfiring
Republican Boycott of Jan. 6 Committee Is Backfiring
Jonathan Bernstein | Bloomberg — Read time: 4 minutes
Democracy Dies in Darkness
Republican Boycott of Jan. 6 Committee Is Backfiring
Analysis by Jonathan Bernstein | Bloomberg
July 13, 2022 at 1:57 p.m. EDT
Tuesday’s hearing of the House committee investigating the assault on the US Capitol of Jan. 6, 2021 provided a stark reminder of how the boycott by all but two Republicans has set the context of the proceedings. Remember: After Speaker Nancy Pelosi vetoed Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy’s suggestions for Republicans to serve on the panel, McCarthy pulled all Republican participation, leaving Pelosi to name two Republican adversaries of former President Donald Trump who defied the boycott.
The hallmark of these hearings — seven this summer and one last year — has been that they’ve run smoothly. They start on time. There is no partisan sniping. No motions made and argued over. The use of taped segments — from depositions and from other evidence — has been professional and effective. The hearings even appear to end on time.
The committee has been shockingly effective at teasing each session in advance without giving away the bulk of their story. There’s even a ritual at the end in which Representative Liz Cheney of Wyoming, the senior of the two Republicans, previews the next hearing and drops a bombshell, supplying the media with a sidebar story and keeping everyone’s interest up to the last moment. This Tuesday’s Cheney surprise was the revelation that Trump tried (unsuccessfully) to contact a committee witness.
Story continues below advertisement
It’s not unusual for a lot of what happens in congressional hearings to be scripted; indeed, it’s pretty normal. But even when partisanship is minimized and members are cooperative (and yes, even in these days of partisan polarization, there’s plenty of cooperation), representatives almost always read off their own individual scripts, with no more than halting coordination even within the parties. For a hearing to be centrally scripted … that’s highly unusual.
Some of this would have been possible had there been additional, dissenting Republicans on the committee. But it would have been a lot harder. Even if the other Republicans had been pro-democracy and acted in good faith — unlikely, but let’s suppose — they probably would have appealed to the impulse of many journalists to hold both parties responsible for any disputes that break out. More likely, they would have deliberately provoked fights to make the story about committee squabbling, rather than the evidence presented. They also could have selectively leaked things from the depositions to take the steam out of the hearings. But even just adding minority member time would have broken up the force and the effectiveness of the presentations.
To be sure, it would also have given critics a chance to expose weak points in the committee’s argument. Tuesday’s session demonstrated how. The topic was actions taken by Trump after losing the 2020 election, from mid-December up to Jan. 6, with the committee trying to pin the eventual violence on Trump himself.
Story continues below advertisement
If the committee’s goal was simply to prove that Trump was aware of the potential for violence, including violence by organized militia-like groups, and even encouraged it, it was successful. However, I thought it was less successful at tying Trump directly to those groups. Overlap between the extended Trump camp and the extremist groups was exposed — Trump confidant Roger Stone, in particular, was involved with both — but a few skeptics on the committee could have pushed the majority harder about whether there was more to Trump’s involvement than simply inspiring anyone who was willing to follow him to commit mayhem.
I don’t mean to minimize what the committee did demonstrate, which was certainly more than enough to produce a legitimate impeachment and conviction if Trump was still president, and may now be enough for indictment and conviction. And the committee has said that it hasn’t yet revealed all the evidence it has gathered. But the feel of the hearing would have been different had there been someone present to poke holes at the conclusions drawn by the current members. Different, but perhaps not weaker; after all, one defense Trump can now trot out on the political stage is that no one is standing up for him in the committee, which is true even if the bulk of what is being presented is irrefutable.
One thing that is clear after eight hearings: Pelosi was correct to veto the Republican attempt to add committee members who were deeply involved in Trump’s plotting. But that still left McCarthy with plenty of options, including strong Trump supporters who didn’t get involved in planning to overturn the election and, in doing so, to overthrow the legitimate US government.
Story continues below advertisement
Because if there’s one thing that’s been obvious starting on Election Day 2020 and is even more obvious now that we’ve seen hours of evidence, not to mention 18 months of Trump’s public behavior, that overthrowing the government is exactly what Trump and his allies were attempting to do. Unfortunately, it seems that there are only two Republicans in the entire House of Representatives willing to side with democracy and against the former president. But they’ve made the committee a lot more effective.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
Jonathan Bernstein is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering politics and policy. A former professor of political science at the University of Texas at San Antonio and DePauw University, he wrote A Plain Blog About Politics.
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com/opinion