Wednesday, July 13, 2022

What It Would Take for Democrats to Dump Biden

What It Would Take for Democrats to Dump Biden

Jonathan Bernstein | Bloomberg — Read time: 4 minutes


Democracy Dies in Darkness

What It Would Take for Democrats to Dump Biden

Analysis by Jonathan Bernstein | Bloomberg

July 12, 2022 at 3:58 p.m. EDT

A lot to think about.

A lot to think about. (Photographer: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

The most predictable story in the world gets recycled whenever a first-term president becomes unpopular and his jittery party starts wondering whether other options are better than nominating him for re-election. So with President Joe Biden’s approval ratings sagging below 40%, here comes a column by Ed Kilgore at New York magazine asking whether Democrats are “stuck” with Biden in 2024.


To answer, set aside (legitimate!) questions about whether Biden, now 79, is too old for a second term. Tune out consideration of whether Democrats believe he would be a good second-term president. Turn to the way electoral politics actually unfolds.


Unpopular presidents have lost re-election bids — Donald Trump, George H.W. Bush, Jimmy Carter, Gerald Ford. The last two times an unpopular president who was eligible dropped out of a re-nomination fight, in 1952 and 1968, his party lost anyway. This is hardly surprising. If a president is unpopular, then his party will be unpopular. George W. Bush couldn’t run for a third term in 2008, but given his low approval ratings, Republicans never had a chance that year.


Story continues below advertisement

All of this suggests that if Biden remains unpopular, the Democrats are probably doomed whether they nominate him or not. Indeed, given partisan polarization, it’s unlikely that candidates matter much in most presidential elections. But we don’t and can’t have side-by-side comparisons, and it’s not surprising that party actors would be wary of re-nominating an unpopular president, regardless of what the evidence suggests.


Which gets back to the question whether the 2024 Democratic nomination is Biden’s if he wants it. Party actors have no formal veto over any candidate. But they do control many of the resources — money, expertise, party-aligned media — that are critical to winning primary elections. If a united party wanted to dump an incumbent president, it surely could at least severely injure him.


After all, most White House staffers, and almost all presidential appointees in the executive branch, have backgrounds as loyal Democrats, not mainly as Biden supporters. Imagine if Biden’s cabinet threatened to walk out unless he agreed to end his campaign for re-election. He could go on anyway. But it’s hard to imagine him doing so. Similarly, Biden would be hard-pressed to continue if enough major Democratic donors refused to support him, or if he had difficulty staffing his campaign with experienced party operatives. Of course, if things came to that point, it might not matter anyway, since a president that unpopular among party actors would probably be trounced in primaries.


Story continues below advertisement

But realistically, even the least popular presidents keep the support of half or so of their party’s voters, and it’s likely that many party actors would stick with Biden if he tried to run. His cabinet and White House staff would probably do so because they like holding their jobs, if for no other reason. In the era of campaign finance abundance, it’s hard to believe that even an unpopular president would fail to raise plenty of cash. And some organized groups within the party would want to reward even unpopular presidents for their support. That was even true for Jimmy Carter, the president with the fewest ties to his party after four years in the White House; one reason he was able to defeat Senator Ted Kennedy and win re-nomination in 1980 was that some unions and other organized groups choose to back him.


The real question, then, isn’t whether Democrats are stuck with Biden. It’s about a scenario in which enough party actors want a second term for him that he has a solid chance for re-nomination, but enough others want a new candidate that it’s also possible that he could lose. If that’s the situation, it really comes down to what’s in one politician’s head, and that’s always difficult for outsiders to predict.


Remember this about Joe Biden, however: His talent has always been to adjust his positions to remain right in the center of the Democratic Party. If the center of that party wants him gone, he’ll probably go.


Story continues below advertisement

There are no guarantees; no politician drops out of a winnable presidential election casually, and there’s nothing easier for a politician and those around him or her than to convince themselves that they are indispensable. Biden surely could make that case to himself. But he also has a built-in excuse for bailing out — age — that few presidents have had. And he really is a party man. So my best guess is that if enough party actors push, he would back away.


It’s also possible that he intends to retire anyway, and just isn’t ready to say so.


This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.


Jonathan Bernstein is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering politics and policy. A former professor of political science at the University of Texas at San Antonio and DePauw University, he wrote A Plain Blog About Politics.


More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com/opinion

Tuesday, July 12, 2022

Pro-life austerity: good luck with that


www.slowboring.com
Pro-life austerity: good luck with that
Phoebe Maltz Bovy
6 - 7 minutes

Phoebe Maltz Bovy is the author of "The Perils of 'Privilege.'" She has a newsletter, Close-reading the reruns, and is co-host of the Feminine Chaos podcast.

In the New York Times, conservative columnist Ross Douthat reminds us that the Court overturning Roe v. Wade did not make abortion illegal in the United States, but merely opened up the legal possibility of states doing so: “While the pro-life movement has won the right to legislate against abortion, it has not yet proven that it can do so in a way that can command durable majority support.”

Douthat warns against a post-Roe landscape that’s pro-life for fetuses but not babies or their mothers:

    You can imagine a future in which anti-abortion laws are permanently linked to a punitive and stingy politics, in which women in difficulties can face police scrutiny for a suspicious miscarriage but receive little in the way of prenatal guidance or postnatal support.

For Douthat, this outcome would be a problem. For those who would prefer for women to hang onto our reproductive rights, it is, conversely, a glimmer of hope. Because “stingy politics” is not so much an imagined future as what the right is, in fact, offering.

As long as Roe stood, hypocrisy accusations could only go so far. Maybe in some theoretical America, without abortion, conservatives would embrace a broader pro-baby, pro-family agenda. Maybe the occasionally gestured-at “culture of life” was simply waiting for this go-ahead from the Supreme Court.

But in the wake of Dobbs, right-wing activist Christopher Rufo tweeted the following:

Behold, a stale, moldy scrap. But a bargain!

That sterile (yes, intended) phrase “cost neutral” refers of course not to the cost for new mothers, for whom this offering certainly does have a cost, but to the taxpayers generally. Among the numerous problems with such a plan — first proposed in 2018, then again in 2021 — is that it would impoverish elderly women for having, decades prior, taken time off for a newborn. And symbolically, it disincentivizes having a baby perhaps even more than not having maternity leave at all. “You can have leave now, as long as you work until you’re 80” is a way of telling women that procreation puts you in direct debt to the state. Practicalities aside, there’s something sinister about it.

Yet cost neutrality is the plan’s whole selling point. Mitt Romney, quoted on Marco Rubio’s website, said, “We are reintroducing the New Parents Act in order to give parents the flexibility to take time off from work with pay during the first weeks of their children’s lives, without growing our national debt, raising taxes, or creating a new entitlement program.”

The meagerness of the offerings is striking. Consider “the first few weeks,” and then match that up against the American Academy of Pediatrics’ advice to breastfeed for “two years or more.” Whether or not new parents nurse (and assuming they’re able to locate formula if not), recovery from childbirth takes months, not weeks. If conservatives want Americans to have more babies, or rather, do not want Americans having fewer babies, why go this route?

Might it not be simpler to just suggest paid maternity leave, without the bit where you have to pay it back? And what of other programs, from universal health care, including for babies and new moms, and free or not outrageously expensive childcare?

It’s tempting to chalk it up to American exceptionalism, or the fear that the moment you allow an “entitlement” you end up in some kind of communist free-for-all where no one aspires to anything, and everyone wears identical potato sacks. Let the state help out with newborns, goes the thinking, and the next thing you know, we’ve retroactively lost World War II, the hamburger has been outlawed, and every child will be sent off to a drag-queen-run kibbutz. It’s not austerity or a lack of political courage, it’s “freedom.” As an American living in Canada, whose childbirth fees were the takeout ramen my husband picked us up afterwards, I sometimes want to shout south of the border, “It doesn’t have to be like this! You can have freedom and also not do co-pays at the pediatrician!”

Another possibility is partisan inertia. Even if it’s what Republican voters want, paid parental leave is deeply off-brand. The right wants to venerate traditional motherhood but also maintain its own tradition of categorizing women in need of state assistance as welfare queens.

But whatever the explanation for Republicans’ commitment to stopping their pro-life agenda the moment the life in question exits the womb, it’s certainly a missed opportunity for them, if their goal is not just overturning Roe but reducing abortions nationwide. American women often seek abortion for financial reasons, which is also why many families have fewer children than they’d like. Even the best safety net in the world doesn’t eliminate all reasons for abortion. But a pro-life movement that is focused on being sad when women don’t have babies they want might make more headway than one that tells women who don’t want (more) babies that they’re wrong.

But that’s where we’re at. Right after Roe was overturned, Republican Senate candidate J.D. Vance offered a very of-the-moment traditionalist take:

The time-honored pro-life strategy of dividing women into cat ladies and moms, doubtless extremely useful for persuading abortion-seeking women, most of whom are mothers, that the procedure should be banned.

And then there was the pro-life activist couple, holding a (much-memed) “We Will Adopt Your Baby” sign. Well. A woman who finds herself a few weeks into an unwanted pregnancy can simply wait the nine months, give birth, and hand the resulting baby over to them, if they’re still standing there with that sign when that day rolls around. A culture of life, of sorts. But at least handing your baby over to a well-dressed couple is a solution that doesn’t cost the American taxpayer a cent.

Winning Without the Courts Lee Drutman


democracyjournal.org
Winning Without the Courts
29 - 37 minutes
Features

The Supreme Court and other federal courts are lost for a decade. What is progressives’ recourse? Getting serious about multiparty democracy.
By Lee Drutman Aziz Huq
 from Winter, No. 63 – 24 MIN READ
Tagged ConstitutionDemocracySupreme Court

For two decades, the principle of political equality and the conservative Supreme Court majority have been locked in a struggle over the foundational rules of American democracy. And the principle of political equality is losing. Bigly.

With the Supreme Court (and many lower courts) likely to stay conservative for at least a decade (if not longer), any approach to political equality that depends on the courts is a losing battle. And right now, every approach to political equality in the democratic reformer toolkit, from regulating gerrymandering to enforcing voting rights to attempting to limit money in politics, is vulnerable to activist conservative litigation.

It is time for a new approach that does not depend on the Courts to referee the zero-sum partisan voting wars that now dominate our elections—and will for the foreseeable future. The only way to achieve political equality is to change the rules of the game—in ways that get around the conservative courts. This means breaking out, further, of the binary, two-party system, and becoming a proportional, multiparty democracy.

Such a big change is needed because of three fundamental transformations in the American political landscape, which have devastated the prospects for political equality.

The first transformation is the extent to which conservative jurisprudence has taken a hard-right turn against the very thought of political equality. It instead privileges the autonomy of (partisan) state legislatures and the freedom to spend unlimited money, claiming (wrongly, in our view) that any standard of fairness is arbitrary and, so, unprincipled. This is the plumb line uniting cases involving campaign finance, gerrymandering, and voter suppression, and it amounts to a guiding principle for a new generation of conservative legal scholars and justices.

The second transformation is the extent to which the entire system of American elections now depends on courts to referee “close” electoral calls. Since the 2000 debacle that was Bush v. Gore, we’ve entered a new era in which elections for control of the House, Senate, and presidency are so close, and partisan voting so predictable, that electoral outcomes can easily hinge on the details of the electoral rules. This invites both aggressive manipulation of voting laws beforehand, and then an electoral lawsuit carpet-bombing during and after the election. The main winners here are courts, which take center stage deciding elections. There are also signs that conservative justices are salting away intellectual ammunition to pull another Bush v. Gore under the “right” circumstances: Just look at the warning shot that Justices Gorsuch, Thomas, and Alito fired before the 2020 election, threatening to step in if they didn’t like the way that Pennsylvania counted its votes, and directly citing the 2000 litigation.

The third transformation is the extent to which the courts have become overwhelmingly conservative, and will remain so for the foreseeable future. This is most obviously so at the Supreme Court, where conservatives now have a 6-3 majority that is likely to last for some time. Less visible is the extent to which the lower courts have also been transformed. Roughly a third of all active federal judges on appeals courts were nominated by Trump; almost all are young, Federalist Society-vetted, died-in-the-wool conservatives attentive to the signals emanating from allied politicians, scholars, and activists. If the Republican Party continues to wield state-level power to entrench its minority rule, these courts are likely to green-light the results. To the extent Democratic legislatures in Congress or even in the states attempt to intervene on the side of fairness, they will likely find an activist judiciary bent on blocking them.

The upshot of these three trends is simply this: The contemporary landscape for political equality is a blasted and pitiless one. Since so many obvious paths forward are now closed, a dramatically different approach—superficially more radical, but actually deeply grounded in American history and constitutional norms—is needed if political equality is not to become a mirage.

We think we need now a federal law mandating multimember districts, with proportional voting for the House and the Senate (the House is straightforward, the Senate more complicated). This is no new-fangled or foreign import. The United States has an early, albeit woefully forgotten, history of using such multimember districts in the first half of the nineteenth century. Congress, moreover, has historically employed its unquestioned power over federal elections to toggle between districts and multi-member districts. (It does not have power, though, to impose the same directly on states’ own elections.)

Given this history, we think a federal law implementing multimember districts is plainly constitutional: And while it faces an uphill political path, radical districting reform may well become increasingly plausible, and even attractive, on both sides of the aisle. Or at least that’s what we hope to persuade you of here.
Closing Doors

For decades, pro-democracy advocacy organizations pursued the same strategy for advancing political equality writ large: Move power from partisans and elected politicians toward independent and nonpartisan experts, commissions, and courts. The logic was simple: Partisans and elected politicians are out solely for their own power. Only nonpartisan and independent bodies can be fair and neutral, and so support and expand political equality. This strategy relied heavily on liberal federal courts in the 1960s for key victories. But its intellectual roots go back even deeper to the Progressive Era, when reformers put similar faith in independent expertise and similarly distrusted partisans and elected officials.

Faith in the ability of independent experts to ensure a fair and equal democracy rests on two premises. First, it assumes that independent experts can agree on and enforce standards of fairness. Second, it assumes independent commissions, courts, and other expert bodies can be truly independent of partisan influence.

Both premises have proved fragile. Conservative jurists have successfully pressed the (false) view that fair standards are impossible in practice. And experience suggests that federal courts—let alone independent commissions, independent agencies, and other supposed nonpartisan bodies—cannot be completely insulated from partisan politics. It is certainly possible to imagine a counterfactual world in which Hillary Clinton won the 2016 election, her appointees set the courts in a more liberal direction for decades to come, and all of the investments in fairness-related reform and litigation strategies paid off. But five years later, our actual political reality is on a very different path. And yet our democracy reform and political equality strategies have not yet adjusted to this new reality, or the brute fact that the reform possibilities of 2022 are very different from the possibilities of 2015.

So just how much has conservative jurisprudence taken a hard-right turn?

Let’s start with voting rights, which has been very much in the news this year. For many decades, voting rights equality has been built upon Congress’s power under Amendments to the Constitution ratified after the Civil War. These were enacted to empower the national government to promote directly both racial and political equality.

The only way to achieve political equality is to change the rules of the game—in ways that get around the conservative courts.

The Roberts Court has pinched Congress’s Reconstruction powers in two different ways. On the one hand, it narrowed Congress’s power to act against discriminatory state law. In the well-known Shelby County decision, it invalidated the coverage formula of the Voting Rights Act. There, Chief Justice Roberts invented a new rule to the effect that Congress had to treat all states equally when it protected voting rights. This “equal footing rule,” of course, has nothing to do with the problem of selective defiance the Reconstruction Amendments were meant to address. It has no basis in constitutional text. And the Court has shown no interest in applying it in any other case or domain.

Where the Court does not have a constitutional makeweight to prevent Congress protecting people’s votes, it uses its power to interpret statutes to gut legislative interventions. Last June, a ruling on Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act made it effectively impossible to bring vote denial claims under that provision. The Court didn’t need to come up with a new constitutional principle to do this. It just read the statute with the acidity of an inborn enmity. Congress can technically revisit that statutory interpretation decision. But in practice judicial rulings tend to be very sticky in the teeth of partisan gridlock.

Next up: districting, or more specifically partisan gerrymandering. Until the 1960s, white politicians kept up the Jim Crow settlement by hewing to discriminatory districting plans. Urban neighborhoods, increasingly packed and dominated numerically by minorities, predictably drew the short straw: They had twice, thrice, or more the number of voters as rural areas—which dramatically reduced the political power of cities and especially the minorities in the urban core.

Neither state nor federal legislators were inclined to break up these racial lock-outs. It fell to the Supreme Court. Starting in 1964’s Reynolds v. Sims decision, the Court’s “one person, one vote” decisions broke down these legislative lock-ups.

Fifty-five years later, the Court still recognizes that partisan gerrymandering—packing, cracking, and stacking voters into units politicians can manipulate—is an Equal Protection violation. But it has refused to remedy such violations beyond the one-person, one-vote context. In effect, Chief Justice Roberts has closed the courthouse door to those locked out of politics by gerrymanders, citing a concern that the Court will be seen as politicized. Of course, this is precisely the same logic that the Court reached for in the decades before it announced the one-person, one-vote rule for refusing to enter the “political thicket.” This logic, moreover, is circular: The Court does not become “apolitical” by refusing to remedy some constitutional violations as it simultaneously leans into the project of addressing others—say, those of wealthy campaign donors. In politics, all decisions are political. Non-decisions are simply decisions to affirm the status quo in ways that benefit one side or another.

A growing number of states have placed districting in the hands of independent commissions, sometimes via referendum. State courts too have started to show some interest in questioning the legality of particularly egregious gerrymanders as a matter of state constitutional law.

Yet even here trouble lurks on the horizon. There are hints that the Court might shut down the path of reform that runs through the people, rather than the federal courts, by use of a novel federal constitutional theory. The emerging theory goes as follows: Both the Elections Clause of Article I and Article II’s account of the Electoral College mention the word “legislature,” and therefore state courts cannot block extreme gerrymanders, elections officials cannot make discretionary decisions to address unexpected contingencies (such as pandemic conditions), and voters cannot be certain that their choice of presidential electors won’t be revoked post-election by the state legislature.

In 2015, the Court rejected a challenge to independent redistricting commissions on the theory that the Elections Clause of Article I gave state legislatures a monopoly on election-related matters. Justice Kennedy was the “swing” vote in that case. Chief Justice Roberts dissented. There is almost certainly a majority now for a reversal of that ruling. Another such challenge before the Court would almost certainly spell an end to independent redistricting commissions.

Worse, passing references in Articles I and II to state legislatures could be key to Bush v. Gore Mark II. A trio of conservative justices in 2000 cited the Election Clause to block presidential vote counting. In November 2020, some of the Court’s most conservative justices made noises suggesting the Election Clause or Article II could bar state courts from engaging in election-related rulings. Logically, the same would hold true for state election administrators. Hence, this “independent state legislature” theory offers conservative justices a blank check for intervening after a presidential election on the theory that the state legislature would have done the vote counting differently.

Finally, we come to the sordid question of money in politics. Since the 1970s, Congress and the states have used prohibitions on spending and contributions as devices to keep politics open to all, against the risk that super-wealthy individuals, corporations, and PACs will crowd out the concerns of less wealthy Americans. A Court sensitive to the risks of political suppression might have recognized and accommodated this concern, even as it guarded against self-dealing by incumbent politicians. Not so the Roberts Court. It has hidden behind a mechanical, airily decontextualized reading of the First Amendment to disallow most expenditure limits and some contribution limits.

The 2010 decision in Citizen United v. Federal Election Commission on corporate expenditures sucks up a lot of the oxygen in criticisms of the Court’s campaign-finance caselaw. But greater harm has been done by a subsequent decision from the District of Columbia Court of Appeals, which extended its prohibition to PACs, and a later Supreme Court ruling, striking down aggregate contribution limits for individuals. The Court has not only suppressed the constitutional difference between speaking and spending. It has added the even more pernicious idea that the government “suppresses” speech simply by offering matching funds to financially outmatched candidates. In effect, the Mercers and the Adelsons of the world are treated as delicate flowers that wilt at the state’s hostile glance.

Thanks to judges backed by the Federalist Society and its big-dollar donors, campaign finance now stands in tattered disarray. But the Roberts Court is not done. Until now, it has praised disclosure rules while killing spending and contribution caps. But a bait-and-switch is on the horizon. In July 2021, the Court in Americans for Prosperity v. Bonta granted a sweeping injunction against disclosure mandates in charity regulation. Bonta applied an “exacting” form of constitutional scrutiny not seen in campaign finance-related cases before. It seems a likely prelude to finding that many campaign disclosure laws are therefore invalid under the First Amendment as forced disclosures.

Notice two common threads: First, political equality loses at the Court’s hands, but Republicans consistently gain. Citizens United, an increasing volume of evidence suggests, has helped Republican candidates for office and moved state policy in a more conservative direction. Shelby County directly precipitated a “rash” of voting restrictions that also aided Republican candidates. And a recent study finds that Republicans have used their control of the redistricting process to increase their seat share in Congress by an average of 9.1 percent in the ensuing election. In contrast, Democrats did not see a significant overall increase in congressional seat share even when the party did control redistricting. Finally, we don’t need to explain which party gained from Bush v. Gore, or from a do-over by this Court.

Second, the Court is consistently unwilling to treat fairness or equality as manageable standards that might constrain incumbent office-holders. Conservative majorities of the Court, in other words, breezily claim to be merely calling balls and strikes, even as they disclaim any power to decide on the scope of the strike zone—except, of course, when it interferes with the liberties of powerful actors to shape the political process.
The Path Left Open

At this point, a dejected liberal may be tempted to toss this journal (or close their browser window) in hopeless disgust. But we draw a different conclusion: Radical, reactionary moves of the sort the Court has made demand new, equally radical thinking—a whole new imagination of political equality. Here’s where our proposal for multimember districting of Congress comes in.

We take a first step toward a more inclusive and fairer kind of democracy by questioning a taken-for-granted premise of American politics: That our politics must be framed as a battle between Democrats and Republicans—two parties with roughly equal support in the electorate, whose ability to gain unified control of government can hinge closely on how particular election and campaign rules benefit one party. Because certain legal shifts help Democrats on the margins, while others help Republicans in close cases, election litigation has become central to our politics. Were elections less close, or were the stakes of elections lower, what Rick Hasen calls the “Voting Wars,” in which each party turns to the federal courts seeking to find some edge or other that will eke out a victory, would not have escalated. And—notice—there would have been less pressure to staff the Court with “safe” (in partisan terms) hands.

A knife’s-edge winner-take-all partisan politics gives courts inordinate power to decide elections—and hence drives the politicization of the federal bench. As partisan divides subsume racial divides, statutes such as the Voting Rights Act lose their sense of common purpose. The quest for partisan advantage is taken as legitimating racial discrimination, undermining the victories of the Second Reconstruction.

But what if this binary, all-or-nothing kind of politics could be refashioned? What if it’s not constitutionally hardwired, but an accident of congressional design? Imagine what might happen if instead of having single-member districts (which tend to reinforce just two parties), representatives to Congress were elected in larger multimember districts. In a five-member district, for example, the top five finishers would go to Congress. Using a proportional voting rule, this would allow parties to earn representation with 20 percent of the vote. This would create space for more parties to compete, offering voters more choices, and making every vote matter equally. The larger the district size, the lower the threshold, and the more parties competing. Israel, with one single district for the entire country, offers an extreme version that creates too many parties. We favor something rather more moderate, like Ireland’s system, which might generate around five or six viable parties.

How would this change the possibilities for political equality without relying on courts?

The path forward involves multi-member districts for the House with ranked-choice voting, and an increase in House size to 700 members.

Start with gerrymandering. Put simply, proportional multimember districts make partisan gerrymandering irrelevant and useless as an instrument of defeating democratic choice. Decennial districting allows partisan legislatures in many states to maximize their party’s representation in both Congress and the state legislature by distributing their voters as efficiently as possible, while “packing” the opposing party’s voters in as few districts as possible.

This works because single-member districts make the geographical distribution of voters a supremely consequential matter. Any electoral margin greater than 51 percent in a district is effectively wasted votes. Especially in today’s highly polarized context, partisan voting is predictable enough that complex computer models can, in seconds, generate maps with the desired, reliable partisan outcomes. In addition, the single-member districting system tends to elicit just two parties simply because in a plurality election votes for third parties are “wasted.”

In a system of single-member districts, 60 percent of the vote in a district gets your party everything, 40 percent gets your party nothing. In multimember, proportional districts, 60 percent of the votes means 60 percent of the seats, and 40 percent of the vote means 40 percent of the seats. The quiddities of district line drawing lose their majority-making power. Shorn of the limits of single-member districts (which render third parties “spoilers” and votes for them “wasted”), many more political shades will bloom. Different parts of the public can band together to select a wider range of voices. With more parties, voting outcomes become less predictable—and so entrenchment gets harder, and equality closer within reach. Consider the recent elections in Germany, in which the center-left SPD surged back, winning the election with 26 percent of the vote. But the center-right CDU/CSU (Merkel’s party) got 24 percent of the vote, leaving it in a strong position to be part of a coalition government. However, with no party anywhere close to a majority, there was neither incentive nor opportunity to entrench power. Compare that to Hungary, where Viktor Orbán’s Fidesz party increased the share of lawmakers elected by single-member districts (and reduced the share elected by party list) to strengthen its advantage as the largest party, making Hungary’s voting system more majoritarian, and thus easier for a ruling party to entrench its power.

In a recent line of partisan gerrymandering cases, the lawyers and legal scholars arguing against partisan gerrymandering have hoped to persuade justices that districting should treat both parties fairly, and proposed a number of tests for fairness that track proportionality. The Roberts Court rejected the possibility of such a standard, and closed off the possibility of finding one in the future. Yet if reformers believe proportionality should be the standard (as we do), proportional multimember districts are a more direct path—and they don’t turn on the Court’s willingness to act.

Independent redistricting commissions, also popular among reformers, do not entirely solve the fairness problem either. Rather, they rely on independent experts to trade off among competing values. Partisan proportionality is one such value. But so are district compactness, keeping communities together, competitiveness, and minority representation. These values are frequently at odds when mapmakers are constrained by single-member districts. So even if the Court finds independent redistricting commissions constitutional, they are at best a partial fix.

This basic dynamic of corrupting binary competition goes beyond districting to other voting rules. In a zero-sum binary party system, a party in power has powerful incentives to tweak the law to make the other party’s voters count for less. The more polarized the party system, the stronger the push to do so.

If majority control in one election confers the power to change rules for the next election, then elections are no remedy. And if majority control in turn influences lifetime judicial appointments, courts are no long-term solution. And if the Court refuses to recognize any standards of fairness, a win in one election can insulate one party from popular will for years or decades, even if it becomes a political minority. Given today’s demographics, it happens to be Republicans who see their political advantage from restricting the franchise. But the boot can easily be on the other foot.

On one view, the behavior of the current Republican Party is puzzling. For the most part, Republicans continue to support unpopular policies, particularly on economic issues, and now on COVID: The broad public support for raising taxes on the wealthy is just one example. Despite losing the 2020 election, the party has doubled down on extremism, instead of pivoting to the center. Instead of being welcomed, the party’s would-be moderates are being purged.

All this is because, in a two-party system, Republicans, even under the control of extremists, can win elections simply by not being the Democrats. Because many citizens vote on identity and social status issues, not economic issues, Republicans have a strong incentive to keep a focus on (non-)issues like critical race theory, portraying Democrats as far more radical than they are.

In a two-party system, with just two issue bundles, cross-pressured voters must trade-off their economic interests and their cultural values. In contrast, given a multiparty system, more parties can offer different bundles allowing voters to vote both their economic interests and their social values. No party can get away with being merely the lesser of two evils.

Similarly, in a two-party system, the power of wealthy donors is significantly magnified because it is easier for a party to succeed with an unpopular economic agenda as long as it focuses on cultural issues. With multiple parties, however, it is much harder to accomplish this sleight-of-hand.

It’s also easier for wealthy donors to capture two parties than it would be for them to fully capture five or six parties. Because most money in politics goes to negative campaigning, and because negative campaigning works much less well in a party system where being the lesser of two evils is not enough to win, outside money matters less in a multiparty system: Volunteers, party organization, and positive, policy-first messaging matter more. Our proposal is, in other words, campaign finance reform by other means.
How We Do This

If the Court won’t brook political equality, we need to advance it by a law that is beyond judicial challenge. The path forward with this law, we think, involves a mandate for multi-member districts for the House with ranked-choice voting, and an increase in House size, to 700 members. Ideally, we would use five-to-seven-member districts, although this may not be possible in many states. For the Senate, we’d install ranked-choice voting to gain some of the same benefits for state-level elections.

The first and obvious objection, of course, is that incumbents aren’t about to change the system that got them elected in the first place. And yes—we agree that current legislators have a powerful interest in the status quo. And we concede that, historically, major electoral reforms are indeed rare. But they do sometimes happen. Indeed, multi-member districts were common until 1842, when Congress used its unquestioned constitutional power under Article I, Section 4, to make a single rule for districting. At that moment, Whigs were trying to stave off a midterm rout, and hoped a districting rule change would save them (it didn’t). Although Congress went for single districts then, the 1842 Act confirms Congress’s power to choose the form of districting. Indeed, we think there is no serious constitutional argument that Congress cannot do what we propose given the sheer breadth of congressional power over federal elections.

The history of American politics tends to consist of extended periods of stasis punctuated by bursts of rapid change. Major voting reforms hence happened during the Progressive Era (e.g., direct election of senators, binding public primaries, referendums, and initiatives) and the civil rights era (voting rights laws). All were viewed as improbable even a few years prior to enactment. Political systems work like other complex systems: Pressures build up over time, but the existing status quo usually can absorb the pressure—until it can’t. Then big change happens.

At a more mundane level, there is a super-majority coalition for electoral reform hiding in plain sight: the pro-democracy, anti-authoritarian coalition. This includes almost all Democrats, who face an inhospitable redistricting cycle and the increasing realization that any system of single-member districts is stacked against the party of the cities, because the urban party inevitably “wastes” too many votes in lopsided safe seats. It also reaches that shrinking portion of Republicans still struggling to carve out a role in a party hijacked by its (growing) extreme illiberal and authoritarian wing, which is a clear majority within the party (probably around 60 percent at this point), but also a clear minority nationally (at best, about a third of the electorate, though it would likely be less if there were other parties on the political right that could offer competing conservative identities).

In 2020, Republicans from this shrinking “governing wing” of the party could spin a plausible (if improbable) story of how once Trump lost, things would return to “normal.” At this point, that story is delusional. The only path back to power and relevance for them anytime in the future runs through proportional multimember districts, which would allow them to form their own, potentially pivotal, party.

For Democrats, the pitch is straightforward. The current system not only puts Democrats at an obvious disadvantage. It has allowed an authoritarian wing of the Republican Party to take over the entire party, putting the entire country at risk of minority rule.

Most individual Democrats and individual Republicans would still be re-elected to Congress under the new rules—especially if a shift to multimember districts happens alongside an increase in the House’s size, as it ideally should. They could run under different party labels, making a clearer pitch for their principles, and likely playing a more important role in a slightly smaller party.

Clearly, the illiberal, authoritarian wing of the Republican Party will oppose these reforms. Their disproportionate power comes from being a well-placed minority able to control a national party despite their national status as a minority.

But conflict over our proposal in itself should be clarifying. As democracy becomes the central dividing issue of our partisan politics, this creates an opportunity. It elevates an issue that we have taken for granted, and makes this new pro-liberal democracy coalition possible. The danger of this conflict is obvious. But only the danger can clarify the stakes enough to force the realignment necessary to pass reform.

For liberal democracy to triumph today, reformers need to shift the conversation. Any litigation that points out that the rules are unfair and asks the Courts for a remedy is going up against a Court majority fully convinced that it’s not their place to decide whether the rules are fair; they didn’t set the rules.

The Court has told us over and over: It won’t referee the electoral process. There’s only one way forward: Change the political process so the Court can’t play the referee—and the people themselves get their voice back.
Read more about ConstitutionDemocracySupreme Court

Lee Drutman is a senior fellow at New America and the author of the book Breaking the Two-Party Doom Loop: The Case for Multiparty Democracy in America.
Also by this author

Aziz Huq teaches at the University of Chicago and is the author of the forthcoming book The Collapse of Constitutional Remedies.
Also by this author

Presidents Aren’t Kings. Remember That, Democrats.

Presidents Aren’t Kings. Remember That, Democrats.

Jonathan Bernstein | Bloomberg — Read time: 4 minutes


Democracy Dies in Darkness

Presidents Aren’t Kings. Remember That, Democrats.

Analysis by Jonathan Bernstein | Bloomberg

July 11, 2022 at 3:33 p.m. EDT

It’s all about politics. What else?

It’s all about politics. What else? (Photographer: Al Drago/Bloomberg)

This turned out to be a good weekend for thinking about the presidency, with three worthwhile pieces that helped explain what’s needed in the White House — and, probably more importantly, the limitations of the office.


Item One: Ben Dreyfuss has a highly entertaining blog post mocking a suggestion that the comedian Jon Stewart should run for president. In fact, he’s Fisking (an old timey blog-era word for rebutting somebody else’s article line by line) a Politico column urging the idea. I recommend it! But Dreyfuss focuses more on Stewart’s shortcomings than his key point that the White House is no place for an amateur, even if the amateur in question is smart and good at television. The presidency is a political job, and the best presidents have been experts in politics broadly conceived.


A secondary point: Please, please, please do not base your choice of presidential candidate on who you think would do well in campaign debates. Campaigns are less important than people think, and debate performances are only minor portions of campaigns. Base your support on who you think is most electable, or as an effort to push the party in your direction on policy, or on which candidate you think has the skills to be effective in office. Not on who might get better press coverage for 24 hours during the campaign before everyone’s attention moves on to whatever is next.


Story continues below advertisement

Item Two: I strongly recommend a blog post on the limitations of the presidency from political scientist Steven Taylor. He’s exactly correct that most of the things that have made liberals upset with President Joe Biden are functions of the basic political context, not about Biden himself, or the White House staff, or Democratic leaders in Congress.


That’s not to say that they’re all doing everything perfectly, but just that any differences between what Biden is doing and what plausible Democratic alternatives would be are marginal. No White House strategy can change the composition of the Supreme Court or the narrow margin Democrats hold in the House of Representatives or break the Senate tie that forces Democrats to depend on West Virginia’s Joe Manchin to reach 50 votes. Biden has to work within that world — along with all the other normal constraints that presidents face, even when they have a more friendly Congress and a less antagonistic court.


Again, that hardly means that Biden has been perfect, or that people shouldn’t criticize him. Just don’t fall for the nonsense that presidents can do anything as long as they want it badly enough.


Story continues below advertisement

Item Three: A Sunday New York Times article raised the matter of Biden’s advanced age. There’s a lot of babble out there about this — a lot of false claims that he’s sharply declined cognitively — but putting that aside, there are two ways to look at the fact that he will turn 80 in November. One is that as long as Biden is unpopular, everything about him is going to be interpreted as a negative, including his age. If he was at 60% approval instead of falling a bit below 40%, the age story would be that he is defying it and thriving.


But yes, Biden is very old for the presidency, and even if it’s not affecting him in any serious way right now, there’s no guarantee that it won’t next month or next year. Let alone the four years that a second term would give him. And the truth is that not only was nominating Biden in 2020 a risk for Democrats, so was nominating Hillary Clinton in 2016 — she’ll turn 75 this fall, in what would have been the second year of her second term — just as it was a bad risk for Republicans to nominate Donald Trump, who just turned 76, in 2016 and 2020. Once those candidates are nominated, party voters have little choice but to vote for them, but the parties shouldn’t do it.


And while Biden as president has strong incentives to pretend that he’ll run for re-election at least up to the midterm elections this fall, soon after that he’ll have to either commit to running for a second term that would be even more risky for the nation, or announcing that he won’t run.


Story continues below advertisement

(Corrects year of Joe Biden’s and Donald Trump’s nominations to the presidency in second-to-last paragraph)


This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.


Jonathan Bernstein is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering politics and policy. A former professor of political science at the University of Texas at San Antonio and DePauw University, he wrote A Plain Blog About Politics.


More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com/opinion

Monday, July 11, 2022

We Have An Epidemic Of Child Marriages In The United States


miscellanycentral.blogspot.com
We Have An Epidemic Of Child Marriages In The United States. Seriously.
11 - 14 minutes

We Have An Epidemic Of Child Marriages In The United States. Seriously.

Read time: 9 minutes

Monday, July 11, 2022

We Have An Epidemic Of Child Marriages In The United States. Seriously. / By Deepti Govind

If you thought child marriage was a problem that only developing countries faced, think again. It is an equally real, and worrisome, problem in the U.S. too.

Read this: Nearly 300,000 minors, under age 18, were legally married in the U.S. between 2000 and 2018, a study by the organization Unchained At Last published this month found. Between 2000 and 2018, 232,474 children were married based on actual data, plus another 64,559 based on estimates. A few were as young as 10, though nearly all (around 96%) were age 16 or 17.

Most were girls wed to adult men an average of four years older, the study found. Whereas, when boys were married, the average spousal age difference was less than half of the age difference for girls, at 1.5 years. Some 60,000 marriages since 2000 occurred at an age or spousal age difference that should have been considered a sex crime.

Unlike in countries where child marriage is illegal but persists anyway, the problem in the U.S. is the laws themselves. Most U.S. states still allow marriage before 18, and the four states that banned it did so only in the last three years. Several states allow teenagers as young as 16 to marry with parental consent, according to an article on the Cornell Law School website. Some even allow children two years younger than that to marry.

Unchained was founded in 2011 by a forced marriage survivor, with a mission of providing free legal and social services to help individuals in the U.S. to escape forced marriages. When it was founded, child marriage was legal in all 50 states in the U.S. Ever since Unchained was created, the organization found that an increasing number of girls, under age 18, were reaching out to Unchained to plead for the same help that its own founder had needed as a child.

Alaska and North Carolina have the lowest minimum age for marriage set by statute, according to an article in WRAL.com: 14 years old. The article also talks of Sherry Johnson’s story. Johnson was married off by her mother when she was just 11 to her 20-year old rapist. She had been raped several times before her age even hit the double digits, and became pregnant at the age of 10 by a senior member of her church.

Lawyers cannot represent minors. But Johnson finally found an attorney who was willing to help her get her a divorce, which was finalized when she was only 17 years old, and had already given birth to six children. She is now an advocate for raising the age for child marriage with a focus on North Carolina, the WRAL.com article says.

Other anti-child marriage advocates in the U.S. have similar backgrounds that prompted them to take up for this cause. For instance, Dawn Tyree, who now works with organizations like Unchained, was also married when she was 13 and became pregnant. She was molested by a family friend, who became her husband after the pregnancy was discovered, according to an article in News Channel 10. By the time Tyree was 15, she was somehow raising herself and her two children. She also faced issues when it came to getting a divorce because she was only emancipated, and not a full adult.

Over the last five years, half of the states have enacted reforms to end or limit child marriage. North Carolina’s is being reconsidered now through House Bill 41 and Senate Bill 35 to raise the age to get married to 18. Researchers in North Carolina reviewed marriage license applications in 50 counties around the state over almost two decades, from 2000 to 2019. The researchers found more than 4,000 minors had applied to be married, the WRAL.com article adds.

Lawmakers in Kansas too are considering a proposal to raise the minimum age for marriage in the state to 18, according to an article by KSN in March 2021. The age of consent in the state is already 18, but a teenager can marry even at the age of 16 with parental consent. Children that are 15-years old can marry with judicial approval. Between the years 2000 and 2010, 2500 minors were married in the state.

While things appear to be improving, there are also cases that suggest a whole lot more has to be done. For example, a Brooklyn rabbi is under investigation for allegedly arranging marriages between children as young as 15 years old. This happened as recently as last month, according to a post on Jewish Exponent. In New York state, one must be 18 years old to marry, though a 17-year-old can marry with a court’s permission.

Rabbi Yoel Roth, and the school he runs, Yeshiva Tiferes Hatorah in Williamsburg, are now the subject of investigations by the New York Police Department and the Administration for Children’s Services, the Forward reported. Roth believes that boys should be married off at a young age to prevent them from masturbating, the article added. Former followers of Roth said he arranged marriages without permission from the parents of the bride and groom, and often does not allow parents to decide the date of the wedding, or even to know the age of their child’s future spouse.

Data Source: Unchained At Last’s April 2021 report on child marriage

Status Of Minimum Age For Marriage Globally

Of course, child marriage is not just an American problem.

Globally, around 21% of young women are married before their 18th birthday, the UNICEF says. A whopping 12 million girls under 18 are married off each year. If that’s not a shocking enough statistic, consider this: 650 million girls and women alive today were married as children, according to the UNICEF, based on data updated until March 2020. The practice is most prevalent in sub-Saharan Africa, where 37% of young women are married before the age of 18.

A 2016 study by the Pew Research Center found that at least 117 countries allow children to marry, based on analysis of data on 198 countries and territories from the U.S. State Department and United Nations. Most countries (153 of 198) require that people who want to marry be adults, i.e. 18 years or older. But many of these same nations also have some kind of exemption to this requirement, the Pew Research study says.

For instance, in Australia, if a person is at least 18, with judicial approval their spouse can be as young as 16, the study adds. And in many other countries, such as Iraq, Jamaica and Uruguay, children can marry with parental permission. Sudan has the largest gender gap: Girls can marry at 10 and boys can marry at 15 or puberty without parental or judicial permission. And six countries do not specify a minimum age for marriage: Equatorial Guinea, Gambia, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, South Sudan and Yemen. The Pew Research list of minimum age across countries from the study can be found here.

Another important statistic to be noted is that for about one-in-five countries, there are different minimum age requirements for men and women. In 37 of these 38 countries, the minimum for girls is the lower of the two. Then there are religion-based differences in terms of minimum age requirement, the Pew Research study found. For example, in the Philippines, couples must be 21 to marry without permission, unless they are Muslim; Muslim boys can marry at 15 and Muslim girls can marry at puberty. And in Tanzania, Muslim and Hindu girls can marry at 12 as long as the marriage is not consummated until the girl reaches the age of 15.

Of the over two dozen countries that require one or both spouses be older than 18, roughly half of these nations (14 of 27) are in the Asia-Pacific region. For instance, China requires men to be 22 and women to be 20 and, in Singapore, couples under the age of 21 must have special permission to wed. In India, Prime Minister Narendra Modi created a task force last year to examine a proposal to increase the age of marriage of women from 18 to 21, which would make it the same legal age for women to marry as it is currently for men.

Impact Of The Pandemic On Child Marriage

Before the COVID-19 pandemic, more than 100 million girls were expected to marry before their eighteenth birthday in the next decade. Now, up to 10 million more girls will be at risk of becoming child brides as a result of the pandemic, according to the UNICEF.

School closures, economic stress, service disruptions, pregnancy, and parental deaths due to the pandemic are putting the most vulnerable girls at increased risk of child marriage, the organization said. In the last ten years, the proportion of young women globally who were married as children had decreased by 15%, from nearly one-in-four to one-in-five, the equivalent of some 25 million marriages averted, a gain that is now under threat, the UNICEF added in another press release.

Girls who marry in childhood face immediate and lifelong consequences, the release adds. They are more likely to experience domestic violence and less likely to remain in school. Child marriage increases the risk of early and unplanned pregnancy, in turn, increasing the risk of maternal complications and mortality. The practice can also isolate girls from family and friends and exclude them from participating in their communities, taking a heavy toll on their mental health and well-being.

“Pandemic-related travel restrictions and physical distancing make it difficult for girls to access the health care, social services and community support that protect them from child marriage, unwanted pregnancy and gender-based violence. As schools remain closed, girls are more likely to drop out of education and not return. Job losses and increased economic insecurity may also force families to marry their daughters to ease financial burdens,” the UNICEF said.

In East Africa’s Malawi, for instance, child marriage rates have almost doubled during the pandemic, according to a Telegraph report. From April to June this year, the national youth helpline recorded 669 child marriages, up by 83% on last year, according to its director, MacBain Mkandawire. His organization, Yoneco, runs the helpline on behalf of the government, Telegraph said.

Nepal has it extremely difficult too, at the moment, according to a New York Times report. Interlocking problems particular to the country make it tough for many young women to avoid early marriage, even though the legal marriage age is 20. Its economy relies on remittances and tourism, both of which the pandemic has devastated. In India also the pandemic led to a more than 33% increase in the number of child marriages between the months of June and October 2020 as compared with 2019, an RTI application to the Union Ministry of Women and Child Development showed, according to an article in The Wire.

Policymakers should be deeply concerned about child marriage – including at age 16 or 17 – for three main reasons, says the Unchained report from this month. The reasons are: Child marriage can easily be forced marriage, and doesn’t give the children getting married any legal rights they need to navigate through the contract of marriage. It is also a human rights abuse that destroys the lives of many American girls. Although, the study points out here that there’s much less known about the impact of child marriage on boys since most of the children who marry in the U.S. are girls, and the research is also focused on girls. Finally, the third reason to do away with child marriage according to the Unchained study is that it really undermines statutory rape laws. Sex with a child, which would be considered rape otherwise, becomes legal within the realms of child marriage in most states and under federal law.

We Have An Epidemic Of Child Marriages In The United States. Seriously.

We Have An Epidemic Of Child Marriages In The United States. Seriously.

Read time: 9 minutes


Monday, July 11, 2022

We Have An Epidemic Of Child Marriages In The United States. Seriously. / By Deepti Govind


If you thought child marriage was a problem that only developing countries faced, think again. It is an equally real, and worrisome, problem in the U.S. too.


Read this: Nearly 300,000 minors, under age 18, were legally married in the U.S. between 2000 and 2018, a study by the organization Unchained At Last published this month found. Between 2000 and 2018, 232,474 children were married based on actual data, plus another 64,559 based on estimates. A few were as young as 10, though nearly all (around 96%) were age 16 or 17.


Most were girls wed to adult men an average of four years older, the study found. Whereas, when boys were married, the average spousal age difference was less than half of the age difference for girls, at 1.5 years. Some 60,000 marriages since 2000 occurred at an age or spousal age difference that should have been considered a sex crime.


Unlike in countries where child marriage is illegal but persists anyway, the problem in the U.S. is the laws themselves. Most U.S. states still allow marriage before 18, and the four states that banned it did so only in the last three years. Several states allow teenagers as young as 16 to marry with parental consent, according to an article on the Cornell Law School website. Some even allow children two years younger than that to marry.


Unchained was founded in 2011 by a forced marriage survivor, with a mission of providing free legal and social services to help individuals in the U.S. to escape forced marriages. When it was founded, child marriage was legal in all 50 states in the U.S. Ever since Unchained was created, the organization found that an increasing number of girls, under age 18, were reaching out to Unchained to plead for the same help that its own founder had needed as a child.


Alaska and North Carolina have the lowest minimum age for marriage set by statute, according to an article in WRAL.com: 14 years old. The article also talks of Sherry Johnson’s story. Johnson was married off by her mother when she was just 11 to her 20-year old rapist. She had been raped several times before her age even hit the double digits, and became pregnant at the age of 10 by a senior member of her church.


Lawyers cannot represent minors. But Johnson finally found an attorney who was willing to help her get her a divorce, which was finalized when she was only 17 years old, and had already given birth to six children. She is now an advocate for raising the age for child marriage with a focus on North Carolina, the WRAL.com article says.


Other anti-child marriage advocates in the U.S. have similar backgrounds that prompted them to take up for this cause. For instance, Dawn Tyree, who now works with organizations like Unchained, was also married when she was 13 and became pregnant. She was molested by a family friend, who became her husband after the pregnancy was discovered, according to an article in News Channel 10. By the time Tyree was 15, she was somehow raising herself and her two children. She also faced issues when it came to getting a divorce because she was only emancipated, and not a full adult.


Over the last five years, half of the states have enacted reforms to end or limit child marriage. North Carolina’s is being reconsidered now through House Bill 41 and Senate Bill 35 to raise the age to get married to 18. Researchers in North Carolina reviewed marriage license applications in 50 counties around the state over almost two decades, from 2000 to 2019. The researchers found more than 4,000 minors had applied to be married, the WRAL.com article adds.


Lawmakers in Kansas too are considering a proposal to raise the minimum age for marriage in the state to 18, according to an article by KSN in March 2021. The age of consent in the state is already 18, but a teenager can marry even at the age of 16 with parental consent. Children that are 15-years old can marry with judicial approval. Between the years 2000 and 2010, 2500 minors were married in the state.


While things appear to be improving, there are also cases that suggest a whole lot more has to be done. For example, a Brooklyn rabbi is under investigation for allegedly arranging marriages between children as young as 15 years old. This happened as recently as last month, according to a post on Jewish Exponent. In New York state, one must be 18 years old to marry, though a 17-year-old can marry with a court’s permission.


Rabbi Yoel Roth, and the school he runs, Yeshiva Tiferes Hatorah in Williamsburg, are now the subject of investigations by the New York Police Department and the Administration for Children’s Services, the Forward reported. Roth believes that boys should be married off at a young age to prevent them from masturbating, the article added. Former followers of Roth said he arranged marriages without permission from the parents of the bride and groom, and often does not allow parents to decide the date of the wedding, or even to know the age of their child’s future spouse.


Data Source: Unchained At Last’s April 2021 report on child marriage


Status Of Minimum Age For Marriage Globally


Of course, child marriage is not just an American problem.


Globally, around 21% of young women are married before their 18th birthday, the UNICEF says. A whopping 12 million girls under 18 are married off each year. If that’s not a shocking enough statistic, consider this: 650 million girls and women alive today were married as children, according to the UNICEF, based on data updated until March 2020. The practice is most prevalent in sub-Saharan Africa, where 37% of young women are married before the age of 18.


A 2016 study by the Pew Research Center found that at least 117 countries allow children to marry, based on analysis of data on 198 countries and territories from the U.S. State Department and United Nations. Most countries (153 of 198) require that people who want to marry be adults, i.e. 18 years or older. But many of these same nations also have some kind of exemption to this requirement, the Pew Research study says.


For instance, in Australia, if a person is at least 18, with judicial approval their spouse can be as young as 16, the study adds. And in many other countries, such as Iraq, Jamaica and Uruguay, children can marry with parental permission. Sudan has the largest gender gap: Girls can marry at 10 and boys can marry at 15 or puberty without parental or judicial permission. And six countries do not specify a minimum age for marriage: Equatorial Guinea, Gambia, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, South Sudan and Yemen. The Pew Research list of minimum age across countries from the study can be found here.


Another important statistic to be noted is that for about one-in-five countries, there are different minimum age requirements for men and women. In 37 of these 38 countries, the minimum for girls is the lower of the two. Then there are religion-based differences in terms of minimum age requirement, the Pew Research study found. For example, in the Philippines, couples must be 21 to marry without permission, unless they are Muslim; Muslim boys can marry at 15 and Muslim girls can marry at puberty. And in Tanzania, Muslim and Hindu girls can marry at 12 as long as the marriage is not consummated until the girl reaches the age of 15.


Of the over two dozen countries that require one or both spouses be older than 18, roughly half of these nations (14 of 27) are in the Asia-Pacific region. For instance, China requires men to be 22 and women to be 20 and, in Singapore, couples under the age of 21 must have special permission to wed. In India, Prime Minister Narendra Modi created a task force last year to examine a proposal to increase the age of marriage of women from 18 to 21, which would make it the same legal age for women to marry as it is currently for men.


Impact Of The Pandemic On Child Marriage


Before the COVID-19 pandemic, more than 100 million girls were expected to marry before their eighteenth birthday in the next decade. Now, up to 10 million more girls will be at risk of becoming child brides as a result of the pandemic, according to the UNICEF.


School closures, economic stress, service disruptions, pregnancy, and parental deaths due to the pandemic are putting the most vulnerable girls at increased risk of child marriage, the organization said. In the last ten years, the proportion of young women globally who were married as children had decreased by 15%, from nearly one-in-four to one-in-five, the equivalent of some 25 million marriages averted, a gain that is now under threat, the UNICEF added in another press release.


Girls who marry in childhood face immediate and lifelong consequences, the release adds. They are more likely to experience domestic violence and less likely to remain in school. Child marriage increases the risk of early and unplanned pregnancy, in turn, increasing the risk of maternal complications and mortality. The practice can also isolate girls from family and friends and exclude them from participating in their communities, taking a heavy toll on their mental health and well-being.


“Pandemic-related travel restrictions and physical distancing make it difficult for girls to access the health care, social services and community support that protect them from child marriage, unwanted pregnancy and gender-based violence. As schools remain closed, girls are more likely to drop out of education and not return. Job losses and increased economic insecurity may also force families to marry their daughters to ease financial burdens,” the UNICEF said.


In East Africa’s Malawi, for instance, child marriage rates have almost doubled during the pandemic, according to a Telegraph report. From April to June this year, the national youth helpline recorded 669 child marriages, up by 83% on last year, according to its director, MacBain Mkandawire. His organization, Yoneco, runs the helpline on behalf of the government, Telegraph said.


Nepal has it extremely difficult too, at the moment, according to a New York Times report. Interlocking problems particular to the country make it tough for many young women to avoid early marriage, even though the legal marriage age is 20. Its economy relies on remittances and tourism, both of which the pandemic has devastated. In India also the pandemic led to a more than 33% increase in the number of child marriages between the months of June and October 2020 as compared with 2019, an RTI application to the Union Ministry of Women and Child Development showed, according to an article in The Wire.


Policymakers should be deeply concerned about child marriage – including at age 16 or 17 – for three main reasons, says the Unchained report from this month. The reasons are: Child marriage can easily be forced marriage, and doesn’t give the children getting married any legal rights they need to navigate through the contract of marriage. It is also a human rights abuse that destroys the lives of many American girls. Although, the study points out here that there’s much less known about the impact of child marriage on boys since most of the children who marry in the U.S. are girls, and the research is also focused on girls. Finally, the third reason to do away with child marriage according to the Unchained study is that it really undermines statutory rape laws. Sex with a child, which would be considered rape otherwise, becomes legal within the realms of child marriage in most states and under federal law.

Queers Don't Sexualize Kids, Evangelicals Do / Kristin Rawls

Queers Don't Sexualize Kids, Evangelicals Do / Kristin Rawls

By Kristin Rawls

Part I.

2015 NYC Pride by Vaughn88, Wikimedia Commons Share-Alike 4.0 International License

2015 NYC Pride by Vaughn88, Wikimedia Commons Share-Alike 4.0 International License

Pride was heavy this year. Amid escalating legislative attacks against transgender Americans, flamethrower Chaya Raichik used her massive twitter presence as Libs of Tik Tok to highlight family-friendly drag queen story hours at libraries throughout the United States and target them for hate. Right on call, groups of Proud Boys mobilized to shout down the events she publicized, frighten the children in attendance and keep queer people hidden from public life.

The outcry centered around the false claim that drag queen story hours sexualize children and groom them for abuse. They do not. At library story hours for children, drag queens use bright colors and hyperfeminine performance to engage children in stories about acceptance and diversity. These events are age-appropriate even as Christofascists insist they are tantamount to child sexual abuse.

The claim by Christian fascists is outrageous and insulting partly because it’s so far removed from what really goes on at events like these, which exist to provide queer parents with outlets for community and teach children innocuous lessons about human diversity and pluralism. This is what fascist evangelicals now call “grooming.”

The truth is that queer people are not using these events to groom children at all, and the people who accuse them are engaging in a sinister game of projection. That is to say, no one sexualizes children as zealously or as systematically as Christian fascists do.

Though it currently appears in rightwing propaganda smearing queer people, grooming is a real technique in which child abusers seek out access to potential victims, gain their trust and desensitize them for future abuse. But queer people are not the culprits here, and it cheapens victim advocacy to claim that they are. Rightwing evangelicals and Christofascists, however, see it as their task to raise children for rigid, specific gender roles, which requires preparing them for early marriage from a very young age.

Fundamentalist Children and Marriage Prep

Fundamentalist Christians have long encouraged parents to raise young adolescents as mini-adults, focusing on preparation for marriage and family life. Popular dogma suggests that teenagers don’t even exist; there are only small children and fledgling adults.

Families begin praying about future marriages early, and children are raised understanding that marriage and family are the primary purpose of life. In her how-to manual on the Quiverfull lifestyle called “All the Way Home,” Mary Pride articulates a common refrain in evangelical circles – the idea that teens aren’t really children at all. She writes:

Here we have someone with the body of a man or a woman who is given absolutely no responsibility. This bothered me when I was a teen, and it bothers me today. No other culture enforces childhood as long as ours… [Today’s teen] is bombarded with unheard-of social pressure to use drugs and fornicate…

[A]ll today’s teens really need can be summed up in two words: meaningful work… They need a chance to practice adult virtues (after all, they are already tempted with adult vices).

To Pride, it’s very simple; teens appear to her like small adults, and so they should be treated as one would treat adults. In addition to ensuring that teens stay busy with work, Pride says, parents should do what they can to prepare teens for marriage. She explains:

Once a young man or woman is well-trained, and the young man is capable of supporting a family (which can be sooner than we expect if he has incentive and some help), it’s time to start matchmaking. Help the poor kids out by locating likely marriage prospects and providing supervised social situations where they can meet each other. Now is the time to start training your fledgling in motherhood and fatherhood.

This is not an uncommon refrain in evangelical circles. Young Christian homeschoolers often begin discussing marriage with their parents by middle school if not earlier. They are encouraged to pray diligently for their future spouses in idealized heterosexual marriage, and to compose lists of qualities they hope to find in a future mate.

And just as Pride suggests, parents do seek out potential mates for their children, heavily involving themselves in the “matchmaking process.” Because these children are taught to submit unconditionally to the will of their parents, this practice often becomes coercive and make it difficult for children to say “no.”

Evangelists Michael and Debi Pearl are best known for their book “To Train Up a Child,” which sold more than 800,000 copies to evangelicals by 2013. The book is most infamous for training parents in physical abuse techniques which were used in the murders of children Lydia Shatz and Hana Grace-Rose Williams. It is particularly popular within the Christian homeschooling movement.

And like any other evangelical child-rearing book, it too has a preoccupation with marriage preparation. The Pearls write that:

A mother should always keep in mind that she is molding her daughters into future wives and mothers. Challenge them with sewing, cooking, cleaning and learning about every aspect of household management… Fathers, by the time the boys can follow you around, they should be ‘helping’ you work… Gender role distinction is demeaned in modern education. Don’t let a coven of Sodomites and socialists…reprogram your natural understandings of male and female distinctiveness.

Although boys and girls are raised to prioritize marriage in their adolescence, girls in particular must look toward marriage for any hope of a life outside the immediate family. They are encouraged to look toward motherhood as their future, not higher education or a career.

Homeschooling allows parents to raise their children with rigid gender roles in place. Echoing the contemporary moral panic targeting transgender Americans, the Pearls appeal to parents’ traditionalism or, as they see it, “natural understandings of male and female distinctiveness.” This must be done consistently, and the supposed “weaknesses” of each sex must be heavily policed.

Young girls, according to the Pearls, can be preternaturally attention-seeking and emotional, and the advice given for reigning in these aspects of girls’ “natural distinctiveness” gets particularly cruel. They write with reckless callousness on signs of mental illness like self-injury, a symptom frequently linked to experiences of child sexual abuse. They suggest that such symptoms can be tamped down and hidden, and that this is a crucial aspect of a girl’s training for marriage:

[We] know an adult who hurts herself every time she gets emotionally disturbed. If, in your family, these extremes never occur, be grateful. It is, nonetheless, far more pleasant to live with a child or teenager who is not a ‘crybaby.’ Also, your daughter’s future husband will appreciate you having trained her.

That is to say, girls who self-injure are not experiencing intense psychological pain; they’re just “crybabies” who annoy their parents. Teaching girls to hide their pain is considered a crucial element of preparing them for married life and motherhood. After all, say the Pearls, a daughter’s “future husband will appreciate you having trained her,” ostensibly so he won’t have to do it himself.

The Pearls may be famous for writing the book on breaking a child’s will, but their influence is widespread. A child’s unquestioning submission to the will of the parents is considered the gold standard in evangelical childhood behavior. Homeschool parents love to regale others with stories about strangers complimenting their children’s “good” – read, submissive – behavior. Obedience is prized, never self-actualization. So it’s no surprise that the concept of consent never enters into the evangelical framework.

Evangelicalism and the Concept of Consent

A common refrain in conservative Christianity is, “Your body is not your own.” In her book, “Quiverfull: Inside the Christian Patriarchy Movement,” Kathryn Joyce quotes Christian nationalist homeschooling leader Michael Farris echoing this sentiment: “If we choose to become bondservants to our Lord (and we do have a choice), then our bodies are no longer our own.”

Calvinist writer Jon Bloom uses Bible verses here to explain the evangelical view that God, not the human, owns the body:

“The body is not meant for sexual immorality, but for the Lord, and the Lord for the body” (1 Corinthians 6:13). When we become Christians, our bodies become members or appendages of Christ’s body (1 Corinthians 6:15–17). And the very Spirit of Christ dwells in our bodies as the Spirit used to dwell in Jerusalem’s temple (1 Corinthians 6:19). Implication: every sexually immoral behavior a Christian engages in drags the Lord Jesus Christ into that engagement.

A culture in which the body does not belong to its earthly inhabitant has no room for robust conceptualizations of consent or bodily autonomy. Parents are intimately involved in every step of the marriage process, from childhood prayers to chaperoned dating, or courtship, to actual marriage. Once a marriage takes place, children are told they must treat their spouse’s body as an extension of their own. There is no sense whatsoever that a person has ownership or agency when it comes to the things that happen to her body, sexual or otherwise.

It’s time to call this what it is: grooming for future abuse. A person who is never taught that it’s okay to say "no” enters into the world with extreme vulnerability. And of course, the consequences of these beliefs come down very hard on girls in a patriarchal system.

Girls are sometimes taught that in marriage they must be “joyfully available” for their husbands’ sexual satisfaction at all times, that saying “no” constitutes a failure to live out Biblical mandates for the family, and that marital rape doesn’t exist. As we will see next week, these beliefs help funnel children into very young marriages – including child marriages – and are fueling the child marriage epidemic in the United States.

Coming Up in Illuminations

Next week’s piece continues the argument begun here – that evangelical Christians are systematically grooming children. Part 1 considers the ways in which conservative evangelicals grooms children for abuse and early marriage. Part 2 focuses on the epidemic of child marriage among evangelicals in the United States and on evangelicals’ fierce opposition to legal bans on the practice. Part 3, coming in two weeks, focuses specifically on the epidemic of child sexual abuse within evangelical communities.

This series is not exhaustive. I could write an entire book on this subject. For every quote I used here, there are thousands of others I might have chosen. My goal is to begin a real conversation about grooming and abuse in evangelicalism – and to make it abundantly clear that the people currently throwing stones have rods in their own eyes.