Thursday, July 7, 2022

The case for a gas tax increase / Matthew Yglesias

The case for a gas tax increase / Matthew Yglesias


 — Read time: 9 minutes


The case for a gas tax increase

Yes, it's politically toxic — but it makes more sense than a gas tax holiday


The inaugural Slow Boring book club meets tomorrow! Join us at 8:30 p.m. Eastern on July 7 for a discussion with Princeton professor Leah Boustan about her new book Streets of Gold. Buy the book here, and sign up for the discussion here. This event is for paid subscribers.


Last week, Joe Biden got a good question about high energy prices and the war in Ukraine: how long does he expect the American people to make this sacrifice? The answer, though noble, is probably not what people want to hear.


Politics aside, it’s worth thinking this through as a question of policy.


We previously discussed the fact that negative shocks to energy supply are very economically damaging, which means this is not only a political problem for Biden but a substantive one as well. The shortfall of oil (and in Europe, gas) is causing real damage, which will only increase during the winter when inadequate supplies for home heat can create genuinely dangerous situations. Most Americans rely on natural gas for heat and are therefore semi-insulated from global market conditions by the fact that there is only so much liquified natural gas (LNG) export capacity. But Northern Europe is in for a world of pain, as is New England and parts of New York where oil is widely used for home heat.


At the same time, the policy objective of waging economic war on Russia has a very legitimate motivation. Countries commonly accept some economic sacrifice in pursuit of national security objectives, and that is essentially what we are doing here.


But while there is no wartime economy without sacrifice, prudent governments do try to modify their domestic economic policies in order to minimize economic pain and maximize the efficacy of the war effort itself. So far, though, we’re not really doing that. The Biden administration has made large releases from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, which is good, but Democrats’ other main idea has been to promote the idea of a gas tax holiday. This makes some sense as a political gimmick, but if you’re really serious about putting the squeeze on Russia, you’d do the opposite and raise the gas tax.


A gas tax hike hurts Russia and curbs inflation

While sanctions on Russia have been highly effective at crimping Russia’s imports, the high global price of oil means that Russia’s export earnings remain robust. Indeed, oil has gotten so expensive that Russia is earning more than ever, even though their production is down. So far this hasn’t actually helped Russia because sanctions are deterring exporters from selling Russian stuff. But over time, someone who has cash and wants to buy things is likely to find a way to do it.


So it would be good to drive down the global price of oil.


And one of the main ways to do that is to reduce domestic gasoline consumption.


Gas taxes are particularly valuable in this regard because they also free up crude oil for more economically important uses, like diesel for commercial vehicles and jet fuel for commercial air travel.


What’s more, while the country is suffering from high gasoline prices, it is also suffering from inflation outside the volatile food and energy sectors. The Federal Reserve is currently trying to address that by choking off overall demand with interest rate increases. This works and is broadly appropriate. But there is a key problem with rate hikes as the exclusive tool of anti-inflation policy: they reduce investment when in some sense, the optimal anti-inflation strategy is to have tons of investment and thus expanded production. So to the extent that you can directly curtail consumption and reduce the need for rate hikes, you leave the economy in better long-term shape.


A higher gas tax would cut gas consumption, of course, but since people have only limited ability to cut back on gas use in the short term, it would also cut back on all kinds of consumption. In “normal” economic times that might be bad, hurting growth. But with core inflation running above target and the Fed trying to slow the economy, this reduced general consumption is a pro, not a con; it would minimize the need for rate hikes and preserve the investment side of the economy.


An offsetting tax cut

You could just leave it at that — use the higher gas tax to reduce inflation and help the economy.


But I do think that would be viciously regressive in a troubling way.


In California, Gavin Newsom is reacting to his state’s revenue windfall by handing out inflation impact checks. You could do that with gas tax revenue, too. But the problem, of course, is that while stimulus checks were great stimulus back when the economy needed stimulus, right now we don’t need stimulus.


What I would do is try to funnel the money into an offsetting tax cut that is both progressive and pro-work in its structure, something like an enhancement to the Earned Income Tax Credit or a payroll tax cut. I don’t think anyone knows exactly why, but prime-age employment is still a bit below pre-pandemic levels, which in turn were below dot-com era levels.



At this point we can’t count on additional fiscal or monetary stimulus to pull more workers into the labor force. But we know the people are out there.


So a tax swap — higher taxes on consuming gasoline, lower taxes on working — would help to encourage work and minimize the economic damage of the war even while turning the screws on Russia.


Increasing domestic oil production

The other thing we can do, of course, is increase domestic oil production.


Here I think it is useful to look at the larger context, which is that global output crashed during the pandemic and has not yet recovered. It’s just very challenging to have a full economic recovery without a full recovery of oil production.



Now of course in theory you could say this is all good. Burning oil creates pollution, which is bad. What we want to do over time is encourage people to drive electric cars and then we wouldn’t be pumping all this oil and setting so much gasoline on fire.


But I really do encourage people who are worried about climate change to pay attention to what the constraints are here. Want to buy a new Tesla Model 3? Well, you can’t because they’re all sold out. But if you put in an order, they will get you one in the September-December range.



Annoyed by Elon Musk’s politics and heard that the hottest new thing in luxury EVs is the Lucid Air? Well, they are taking reservations with no guarantee of shipment dates. Nissan had to halt U.S. orders of their new Ariya electric crossover because they are struggling to meet the demand for domestic orders in Japan. Ford has halted orders on the Maverick. In other words, the EV demand problem that we long worried about has been solved. If you want to boost demand for electric vehicles, you need ideas to boost the production of batteries, which as I understand it goes back to regulatory bottlenecks in terms of mining for the minerals that go into batteries.


In a world where EV adoption is constrained by battery shortages, we need an oil production recovery to have an economic recovery. And compared to where we were right before the pandemic, OPEC has risen a ton. The fall in Russian output, while large relative to the Russian economy, is pretty small relative to the scale of the global oil market.



The biggest source of deficit is the USA.


Increasing domestic oil output is a win-win that both helps the American economy and also, by reducing global oil prices, hurts the Russian economy. What can be done? There is some stuff Republicans complain about on the permitting and regulatory front and for the sake of pure politics, I might just give them what they want. But the basic issue is economic — U.S. output is rising steadily, and investors worry that if they accelerate their pace of output, they’ll lose their shirts in a price crash. That happened three times in the past decade and now they’re scared.


The biggest thing the Biden administration could do is use the Strategic Petroleum Reserve and the Exchange Stabilization Fund to guarantee high future prices of oil, even if the global situation changes. That might end up costing the Treasury money. But by the same token, all the military assistance we are giving to Ukraine definitely costs money. The premise of our policy, though, is that money spent on helping Ukraine to beat Russia is money that is well spent. By the same token, money spent on bolstering U.S. production to crush the Russian economy and keep the American consumer afloat is money well spent.


The refinery bottleneck

There are also refinery issues that have been interesting to progressives lately. Compared to the depths of the pandemic, gasoline prices have risen by more than oil prices because refinery capacity has declined in recent years as companies have stopped investing in new facilities or in repairing ones that break. This isn’t a conspiracy; it’s a response to the perception that the long-term trajectory of demand is heading downward.


Part of the reason a higher gasoline tax might be useful is that given the refinery bottleneck, a large share of the incidence would fall on refiners. In other words, for every one cent per gallon that the tax goes up, consumer prices would rise by less than one cent — potentially a lot less, with the remainder coming out of refiners’ pockets.


Then either in addition to taxation or instead of it, we could subsidize additional refinery capacity with loan guarantees or outright state ownership. Democrats in other contexts are precisely the party that believes you can’t leave things up to an unconstrained market.


What are we doing here?

The consumption-constraining aspect of this is, of course, a pure fantasy given the politics.


Joe Biden isn’t going to raise gas taxes, and he’s not going to ask people to carpool for Ukrainian freedom. It also seems like he doesn’t want to engage in outside-the-box ideas to increase domestic production because that contradicts his environmental policy goals. But that has left Democrats trying to soothe domestic pain by subsidizing consumption, which is counterproductive from the standpoint of the original policy goal of punishing Russia and trying to help Ukraine.


All in all, it seems to me like there should have been a big meeting at the White House before the vote on the oil embargo where Mitch McConnell, Kevin McCarthy, Janet Yellen, and Tony Blinken tried to hash out what exactly they think America’s policy response should be. I actually do think that at the moment of peak pro-Ukrainian fervor, a revenue-neutral Ukraine Solidarity Tax to finance a tax cut for working people might have stood some kind of chance of securing bipartisan support.


At a minimum, the State of the Union would have been a perfect opportunity for Biden to announce a pivot.


Back in 1943, FDR had a famous moment where he announced that he’d transformed himself from Dr. New Deal into Dr. Win The War. Not because the ideas of the New Deal were mistaken, but because the situation had changed. Biden could have specifically invoked this and said that Dr. Green New Deal was taking a break in favor of Dr. Beat Russia. Noting, of course, that the sanctions on Russia by crippling their ability to pump oil and gas are themselves reducing CO2 emissions. New pro-production measures in the United States would only partially offset the impact of the foreign policy measures already taken. If you paired that with a gas-for-work swap, it’s even better for the environment.


Now I’ll admit that on some level these ideas are bummers politically. But we started with Brian Deese breaking the bummer news that people may need to put up with economic disruptions for however long it takes for Ukraine to win the war. This is just to say that the decision to take a stand against Russia was a serious one, and I think it’s one Biden and his team believe in. But then you need to carry the logic of your own policy forward and really do everything possible to put it in a position to succeed.

Neil Gaiman’s Books Have Enchanted Millions. Finally, Hollywood Is on Board. / Elizabeth Evitts Dickinson

Neil Gaiman’s Books Have Enchanted Millions. Finally, Hollywood Is on Board.

Elizabeth Evitts Dickinson — Read time: 22 minutes


Author Neil Gaiman. (Guerin Blask for The Washington Post)

Author Neil Gaiman. (Guerin Blask for The Washington Post)

Neil Gaiman’s Books Have Enchanted Millions. Finally, Hollywood Is on Board.

‘The Sandman’ and other morally complicated Gaiman creations are finding their way to screens — just when we need them most

By Elizabeth Evitts Dickinson

July 6, 2022 at 9:55 a.m. EDT

It’s a spring evening, and the Miller Theater in Center City, Philadelphia, is bursting with an excited crowd. Patrons serpentine the lobby waiting to buy presigned books by the British author Neil Gaiman. Gaiman, whom Stephen King once heralded as a “treasure-house of story,” had to stop live signings because readers would queue several city blocks outside his events. During his final signing tour in 2013, as he inked his name and personal notes in thousands of books, Gaiman took to plunging his aching arm in a bucket of ice on the advice of a physical therapist.


Tonight’s event has been billed as “An Evening With Neil Gaiman,” and it’s a reschedule from 2020, after a plot twist worthy of one of his stories shuttered the world. Gaiman often writes about the macabre — the coming apocalypse, journeys to Hell, life in a graveyard, campfire-quality horror — and yet his work carries a compassionate generosity, a dark humor that revels in the exquisite muddle that is a human life. His characters are frequently normal people bumping up against the fantastical, where they must contend with witches and gods — or, as in the novel “Good Omens: The Nice and Accurate Prophecies of Agnes Nutter, Witch” (1990), which he co-wrote with the late British author Terry Pratchett, an angel and a demon who have followed humanity since the time of the poisoned apple and have forged an unlikely friendship and a love of us mortals.


“Neil breaks life down to the fundamentals of what it is that makes us human,” the actor Jon Hamm tells me. Hamm started reading Gaiman’s novels, including “Good Omens,” around the time he moved to Los Angeles to pursue acting, and now he plays a role in the Amazon Studios and BBC Studios series based on the book. (Amazon founder Jeff Bezos owns The Washington Post.) “It’s not about what makes us American, or what makes us Black or White or any of the labels that we’ve established for ourselves over the course of however many millennia we’ve been here, but what it is that connects us.”


Entire families, some three generations deep, are here to see Gaiman tonight, and what they buy reflects his genre-busting reach. There are board books for children; novels, like “American Gods” (2001), which showcases Gaiman’s capacity to blend fantasy, folklore and myth; and multiple collections of short stories and essays. And then there are the dictionary-size volumes of “The Sandman,” the series that arguably put Gaiman on the map. Published by DC Comics between 1989 and 1996, the 76 issues of “The Sandman,” which many critics agree helped usher in the golden age of the contemporary graphic novel, tell the story of Morpheus, King of the Dreaming, and his godlike siblings who include Death and Destiny. In the sprawling tale, Morpheus struggles to regain control of his Dream world after being captured by humans dabbling in the occult.


“The Sandman” was a revelation when it came out, according to the comedian and actor Patton Oswalt, who met Gaiman in the 1990s when he was one of the many fans waiting in a long signing line. Oswalt had first read “The Sandman” in college. “I could not believe how amazing it was,” he says, because “it contained universes. I had never seen that done in a comic so perfectly.”


And yet, for the better part of Gaiman’s career, only a few of his novels and short stories made it to screens, notably “Stardust” and “Coraline.” Many of his most formative books and graphic novels proved difficult to translate. Gaiman used, as his storytelling framework for “The Sandman,” the entirety of history, bringing in figures from Norse gods and Lucifer to Shakespeare and Mark Twain. He also creates characters that are rarely simple binaries of good or evil, reflecting the baffling complexity of human nature.


Story continues below advertisement

“All of the things that made ‘Sandman’ wonderful were the same things that made it almost impossible to adapt for film and television for 30 years,” says David S. Goyer, a filmmaker and producer who was a co-writer on the “Dark Knight” Batman trilogy. “All of the features that we love about ‘Sandman’ — that it is, in essence, a story about stories — are the bugs that stymied Hollywood.”


Today that is no longer the case. Quietly and steadily over the past six years, Gaiman has matched some of the most prolific creators in Hollywood. And after 32 years trapped in the purgatory of Hollywood development, a 10-episode series based on “The Sandman” will premiere on Netflix on Aug. 5. Developed by Gaiman, Goyer and writer Allan Heinberg, it represents one of the streaming service’s biggest-budget original productions. Meanwhile, Gaiman’s 2005 novel “Anansi Boys,” a modern twist on the ancient stories of the West African trickster god Anansi, is now an Amazon Studios series in postproduction, and “Good Omens” recently wrapped filming its second season. These follow on the heels of the series “American Gods,” which premiered in 2017 on Starz — earning two Emmy nominations for its first season — and aired its third season last year.


In total, Gaiman has seven shows that he has developed or that are based on his writing, with more in the works. He has become the great adapter, pulling from the store of fable and myth for his books, and transmogrifying his written work into radio and stage plays, audiobooks and movies. And now television.


Gaiman’s books “couldn’t get made in a three-network landscape,” Hamm says, owing to their complexity. As television has matured, though, so too have the opportunities to tell more-nuanced stories. Shows like “The Wire,” “The Sopranos,” “Breaking Bad” and “Game of Thrones” have seasoned audiences with their myriad storylines and morally ambiguous characters, while the maturation of streaming services has allowed more niche stories to exist. This confluence of online viewing and marketplace readiness has led to a watershed moment for the adaptation of Gaiman’s work. And the timing is ripe: In an era when public discourse so rarely reflects the complicated truth of our existence — when politics and punditry seem hellbent on reductionism and division — Neil Gaiman’s intricacies may be exactly what we need.


Gaiman, who was born in 1960 in Portchester, England, can credit his career, in some measure, to the British new wave band Duran Duran. He was 23 years old, a young father and freelance journalist who had skipped college to begin writing. A U.K. publisher asked if he’d like to pen a music biography. “I was offered three to choose from: Barry Manilow, Def Leppard or Duran Duran,” Gaiman tells me over Zoom one evening — he in Scotland, I in Maryland. “And I thought: Barry Manilow has done a lot of albums and I don’t want to listen to many of them. I don’t really know anything about Def Leppard. So, I’ll take Duran Duran.”


He did the math: The advance would pay his rent for six months and allow him to buy an electric typewriter. He also calculated precisely how many books he would need to sell to begin earning royalties. The Duran Duran book was published in 1984 and quickly sold out. It was heading into a second printing, and to the promise of earning royalties, when the publisher declared bankruptcy. “I spent months of my life writing a book I wouldn’t have wanted to read and I did it for the money — I only did it for the money — and now there is no more money,” Gaiman says. “Had that book been successful, I probably would have written more books that I wouldn’t have wanted to read.”


Gaiman made himself a promise. “I wouldn’t do anything just for the money, because if you don’t get the money, you haven’t got anything,” he says. “But if I made something that I cared about and I never got the money, at least I had this thing I loved and could be proud of. Over the years, this philosophy has looked after me. When I stray from it, I get kicked in the teeth and am reminded that I should not have strayed.”


He often credits his prolific career to a childhood spent in public libraries. He read Charles Dickens and many of the science fiction and fantasy greats, like Ray Bradbury, Madeleine L’Engle and G.K. Chesterton, who is one of Gaiman’s many literary heroes. Reading so much as a kid was Gaiman’s way of learning about both the world and the act of world building. “I was developing empathy, realizing and understanding that all the different incarnations of ‘I’ in stories, who were not me, were real, and passing on their wisdom and experience, allowing me to learn from their mistakes,” he recounted during a 2012 lecture. “And I knew then, as I know now, that things need not have happened to be true.”


Story continues below advertisement

Growing up in fictional landscapes — Narnia, Middle-earth, Asgard with the Norse gods, the woods of Grimm, the mythological worlds captured by writer Roger Lancelyn Green — led Gaiman to see “the sheer rightness” of these stories, he has said. He was also an ethnically Jewish kid who was raised by Scientologist parents and attended High Church of England schools. (Gaiman is not a Scientologist; rather, he says, he is “the kind of Jew who mostly just feels guilty for working through” the high holy days.) All those books, all those religions, blended into this “huge moldering sludge of loving ideas and all of the things people believe,” Gaiman explained in 2020 on the podcast of actor David Tennant, who co-stars in “Good Omens.” “I love the fact that humans are believing machines.”


Gaiman is the “epitome of the storyteller,” actor Tom Sturridge tells me, “and he does it in every form imaginable.” Sturridge stars in the lead role of Morpheus in the Netflix series, with Patton Oswalt voicing Matthew the Raven, his trusted emissary.


“The Sandman” comic book series came about after Gaiman had published his first comic in 1986. Karen Berger, then an editor at DC Comics, asked him if there might be a character in DC’s catalogue that he’d want to revive. Gaiman chose Sandman — a creation that had first appeared in the 1930s in the form of millionaire Wesley Dodds, a vigilante who donned a gas mask and sedated criminals at night for the police to find. The character of Sandman reappeared over time, including in a 1970s version where he lived in “the Dream Dome.” Gaiman carried over some general ideas from previous iterations, even as he embarked on a reinvention — abandoning Dodds and the entire superhero concept, and instead creating Morpheus, also known as Dream, a Sandman character capable of containing the vastness of human imagination.


Gaiman enjoyed the creative collaboration of comics, where writer, artist and letterer work in tandem to realize a story. He would call the artists before he began writing that month’s installment of “The Sandman” to ask what it was that they loved to draw, or always wanted to draw but were never given the chance to.


Neil Gaiman has become the great adapter, pulling from the store of fable and myth for his books, and transmogrifying his written work into radio and stage plays, audiobooks and movies. And now television.

It is this spirit that likely helped prepare him for his later years working on television production sets. He is “quite generous” as he watches actors inhabit the characters he’s written, according to Michael Sheen, who plays the angel Aziraphale in “Good Omens” opposite David Tennant’s demon, Crowley. “The fact that I didn’t ever have to think about what was in Neil’s book while acting is a testament to Neil, because he never came up and said, ‘Actually, what I wrote was this,’ ” Sheen says. “Neil would be delighted, sitting there at the monitor watching me and David or whoever it was, doing something that wasn’t in the book. He’d be absolutely delighted, and if it didn’t work for the world he was building, he’d tell us.”


Gaiman’s literary choices weren’t always appreciated, though, and he was sometimes marginalized. In 1999, he was invited to give a lecture at a university — he had three novels published by then — and “on the way to the talk, a member of the art department casually mentioned that there wouldn’t be anybody at my talk from the English department,” he recalls. “They were boycotting it since I wrote comics.”


While academia may have taken its time in embracing Gaiman’s work, his readers never did. “The Sandman” became one of DC’s most popular and profitable titles. With its success, Gaiman could have comfortably made a living within the world of comics — yet he had wider interests. Merrilee Heifetz, of the New York-based literary agency Writers House, has been Gaiman’s agent since 1987 and is his manager. She remembers him telling her during their first meeting in New York: “I’m going to write novels. I’m going to write movies. I have lots and lots of plans for my stories.” The conversation turned out to be the literary equivalent of Babe Ruth pointing to the outfield and then hitting a home run precisely in that spot. “He did everything that he said he was going to do,” Heifetz says.


More so than many authors, Gaiman has developed a relationship with his fans. He attended Comic-Con and sci-fi and fantasy conventions starting in the 1980s, and began blogging in 2001. He has a Twitter following of 2.9 million and a Tumblr account where he answers fans’ questions. This direct line to his readership has afforded him a “critic-proof career,” as he told the New Yorker in a 2010 profile, and it is why, even today, he doesn’t bother with a publicist.


Now, the academics who once spurned him put his books on their syllabi. And Gaiman has returned the sentiment. “I’ve always had a healthy respect for academia,” he wrote in 2006 in the introduction to “The Sandman Papers: An Exploration of The Sandman Mythology,” one of the many academic books that parse his work. “Even when puzzled by it, it treats art as if it matters. And for those of us who make art, that’s a fine thing to experience.”


Making art in the sausage factory that is Hollywood can be a daunting endeavor. There’s a short story — collected in Gaiman’s 1998 anthology of short fiction, “Smoke and Mirrors” — that’s loosely based on Gaiman’s first experience in Los Angeles. In it, a British author has optioned his novel to a movie studio in Hollywood and is flown first class to help adapt the book into a film. The fictional writer quickly learns that everyone from the taxi driver to the bellhop has a script they’re peddling, and the land of sunshine and silicone has a surface-level sheen that belies a dark vapidity.


Our protagonist is shuttled to a series of meetings where “I didn’t quite catch anybody’s name” and “the men had beards or baseball caps or both; the women were astoundingly attractive, in a sanitary sort of way.” Everyone tells him how much they love the book, and also why it needs to be drastically overhauled.


The story is, partly, about that dizzying feeling of being an outsider in a world that appears to be running via inscrutable inner machinations. It is, like many Gaiman stories, about a character on the margins of the mainstream. “I can feel like a fraud,” Gaiman tells me. “You know, the impostor syndrome thing is very real.


But if Gaiman has struggled at times with how he fits in, he has still pursued control over how his stories could be imagined for TV and film. He created the Blank Corp. decades ago as a way to manage his screenwriting projects (he’s written for shows like the BBC’s “Doctor Who”) and the optioning of his novels. By 2016, with so much interest in his work, Gaiman formally launched it as a production company. Soon after, he was helping to adapt what others had spent decades struggling with: his own work.


Story continues below advertisement

“I think Neil was nervous about entering this space,” Hamm says. “It’s an endeavor that can be very intimidating, you know, when you’re so good at one thing and then you’re asked to do another thing. It can be a gut-check moment.” Hamm and Gaiman got to know each other several years ago at an event; there Hamm told him how much he loved “Good Omens.” For the series, Gaiman created a new character, the archangel Gabriel, and he emailed Hamm to ask him to play the part. Hamm replied with one word — “YES” — without ever having read the scripts. “I knew I was in very good hands,” the actor says.


If Gaiman were to write a character to play the role of his partner in crime in Hollywood, it would be Cat Mihos, vice president of the Blank Corp. With a veritable mane of thick black hair and half sleeves of tattoos on her arms, Mihos looks like she could have walked off the pages of one of her boss’s books. Like many of Gaiman’s collaborators, Mihos, who grew up in the suburbs outside D.C., started off as a fan. (I first met Mihos in Baltimore in the 1990s, and the two of us worked for many years as “roadies” for the same music tour production company.)


She later met Gaiman while working on tour for the musician Tori Amos, one of Gaiman’s close friends, and by 2006, Mihos was helping Gaiman in Los Angeles as he met with studio executives and as she established a merchandise line for his fans. There was a desire by some, as Gaiman’s star began to rise, to commodify him, but “he never wanted to be a brand,” Mihos says. To this day, much of his merchandise, like broadsides of poems, are used as fundraisers for literacy causes or for his work with the U.N. Refugee Agency (Gaiman’s Jewish cousins escaped the Nazis thanks to the help of the resistance).


Mihos, like Gaiman, is a Hollywood outsider — someone who wasn’t reared within the studio system — and together, they’ve helmed or participated in adaptations of “The Sandman,” “American Gods,” “Good Omens” and “Anansi Boys,” among others. Gaiman has had overall deals with Fremantle and Amazon Studios to develop and create movies and shows — some based on his published writing and some that he is developing with different writers.


Unlike his other work, where Gaiman has strategically optioned or retained the rights for development, the character of Sandman was always a property of DC Comics. Warner Bros. started considering an adaptation of “The Sandman” as early as 1990. Lisa Henson, daughter of Muppets creator Jim Henson, was a Warner Bros. executive at the time, and the two met on one of his early trips to L.A. Henson told him that there was a lot of interest in making “The Sandman” into a movie and he remembers her asking, “What do you think?” Gaiman asked her to please hold off. The comic was “just getting going and a movie would be a huge distraction,” he says. Henson told Gaiman that he was the first writer ever to come into her office and ask her not to make a movie. (The two became friends, and Gaiman’s production company is now housed on the Jim Henson Co. lot in Hollywood.)


It wasn’t long, though, before Warner Bros. tried again, and “The Sandman” spent years toggling between different producers, directors and writers who would on occasion consult with the story’s creator about their plans. Gaiman often said that he would rather not see a “Sandman” movie or show ever get made than witness a poor one be greenlit.


People were “banging their heads against walls, I think, trying to find a way to make a single story work and still be able to tell the multiple stories that Gaiman composed in ‘Sandman,’ ” Michael Sheen tells me. “I think the only way you can make it work, really, is by telling it as a multi-episode story with multilayered characters. And, you know, that time has come.”


It wasn’t until David Goyer became attached to the project in 2013 and insisted that Gaiman be involved as an executive producer that the author had an official role. “I can’t believe I was the first person to suggest it, but no one had ever courted Neil,” Goyer says. By 2016, after yet another writer quit — saying, according to Gaiman, that “it was impossible to squeeze ‘Sandman’ into a movie” — Warner Bros. agreed to make it a TV show. Goyer called Gaiman with the news, as Gaiman was on set filming the first season of “Good Omens.”


“Neil’s concerns are so profoundly intimate and loving, primarily, and I believe that’s why he’s so beloved and why his work continues to inspire people,” writer Allan Heinberg says.

“Warner Brothers says we can make it as a series.”


Gaiman could hear there was more. “What’s the rub?”


“I want you to write it with me,” Goyer said.


It would be 2½ more years before their schedules aligned. Goyer also brought in Allan Heinberg as a writer and a showrunner because he was “someone who loved ‘Sandman’ as much as I did,” Goyer says. Goyer and Heinberg both tell me that they had read Gaiman for years, and they each have original ‘Sandman’ art that they acquired in their 20s. “There are all these executives and creatives in Hollywood today who grew up reading Neil, and now they are in a position to make his work,” Mihos says.


It can be challenging to adapt Gaiman, not just as a fan, but because “he’s so smart and because his reach and the amount that he’s read and absorbed is so vast,” says Heinberg, who is no stranger to adapting a cherished character — he was the screenwriter for the 2017 “Wonder Woman” movie. “Neil’s concerns are so profoundly intimate and loving, primarily, and I believe that’s why he’s so beloved and why his work continues to inspire people,” Heinberg tells me. “His writing is very intimate, and it’s very epic at the same time.”


The Friday before they were to pitch “The Sandman” as a series to streaming channels in June 2019, Goyer, Gaiman and Heinberg met for dinner in L.A. They made a pact. When they met with the streamers, they would, according to Goyer, act as a united front protecting the essence of “The Sandman.” They would take “all of the things that studios historically felt were bugs — things that were difficult to adapt — and we would present them as features,” he says.


One of the “bugs,” Mihos explains, is that there is no main villain. It took three decades for “The Sandman” to be adapted in part because people kept trying to fit a multilayered story into the superhero feature film trope. “They couldn’t understand that there wasn’t one single villain,” Mihos says.


Story continues below advertisement

In “The Sandman,” as in most of Gaiman’s stories, characters contain myriad, often contradictory truths. This is explained best perhaps in one of Gaiman’s novels, “The Ocean at the End of the Lane,” where one of the main characters tells the young protagonist that “nobody actually looks like what they really are on the inside. … People are much more complicated than that.”


Now, in much the same way that Gaiman reimagined what a comic could be while writing “The Sandman,” he’s reworking the scope and aesthetic of the typical television series. The teaser trailer, released in June, features Sturridge, thin and pale and remarkably accurate to the Morpheus/Dream character depicted in the comics, after he’s been captured by humans. Over the 10-episode arc, viewers will be taken on a journey that spans thousands of years. “The tone varies wildly from episode to episode, just as the tone of ‘Sandman’ did, which is something that you don’t normally do in television,” Gaiman says. Episodes of television “are meant to feel and taste alike,” he explains, so that if you slice out one episode from a season, it still very much resembles the rest of the series. “But we’re doing it differently with ‘Sandman.’ ”


As “The Sandman” was wrapping filming in London, “Anansi Boys” was being filmed on a soundstage in Scotland. Hanelle M. Culpepper directed two episodes of “Anansi Boys,” including the pilot, which was written by Gaiman. Moving from the vastness of a Gaiman novel to the contained realities of filming on a soundstage was one of Culpepper’s challenges. “There are some times when you just cannot do what’s in the book for whatever reason — logistics, budget — and you have to come up with a different way of visually showing it,” Culpepper tells me. She has also directed episodes of “Picard” for the Star Trek franchise and grew up loving sci-fi and fantasy. She says the key to adapting a beloved text like “Anansi Boys” is to “always make sure that it’s fair to the essence of the book and is equally emotionally satisfying as it was for you when you first read it.”


Hamm says that when you see how different “Good Omens,” “Anansi Boys” and “The Sandman” are, “just in their radically different paths down which they take you, it’s really bold. And the fun thing here is that filmmaking has caught up to our ability to tell tremendously fantastical stories like these. And the marketplace has, too.”


As I talked with colleagues and collaborators about Gaiman, many remarked at the serendipity of these stories finally arriving to us in 2022. “Sandman,” Heinberg says, is “profoundly timely” given how “universal all of our human concerns are, particularly at a time when our nation and our world are so divisive. We’re in all of these separate camps, usually demarcated by our religious affiliations and beliefs. But what you learn through this story is that no matter which religion you are, no matter which mythology you mine, all the human concerns are the same. And because dreams belong to all pantheons and all citizens, Neil is telling a story that transcends these divisions that we have built up in our cultures. ‘Sandman’ is really about how we are loving citizens of the world — and of the universe of which our world is a part. What Neil does so expertly is he doesn’t pretend that boundaries don’t exist, that those cultures don’t exist. He honors them, embraces all of them in a very loving way.”


Oswalt, one of the first actors to be attached to the “Sandman” series, believes the story is even more relevant 30 years on. “We’re living in a time where it feels like we’re in beta testing for how completely our reality can be manipulated,” he says. “Everyone has a camera in their pocket, everything is being documented. There are certain leaders who are saying that the thing that you just saw and heard is not what you saw and heard, and they’re seeing how far they can push that. There is a really dangerous, dark experiment going on right in front of us, and it’s fascinating to watch, but it’s terrible to live through.”


As the real world has become so manipulated, as it has become more and more difficult to discern real from false, it may be that our greatest truth tellers at present are the storytellers — the writers who remind us of the universal thread of narrative that’s been with us since the beginning. A return to the origin stories, the birth myths, feels like a salve. In his epigraph to “Coraline,” Gaiman sums up how he feels about stories like these with a quote that he adapted from G.K. Chesterton: “Fairy tales are more than true: not because they tell us that dragons exist, but because they tell us that dragons can be beaten.” To go back to these stories is to remember that we are always and forever fighting the same dragons.


Story continues below advertisement

But perhaps nothing makes Gaiman’s work more relevant in 2022 than his approach to questions of good, evil and moral ambiguity. “Neil’s work generally has a thrilling balance of a universe that is full of malevolence and sinister elements and is truly terrifying, as well as a deep commitment and investment to goodness and compassion and empathy and kindness,” Sheen says. “He writes with real warmth and respect about human fallibility.”


I recently re-watched the first season of “Good Omens,” a show premised on an angel and a devil creating an unlikely alliance and friendship, and I couldn’t help but think about America’s broken bipartisanship and the global politics of binaries. Here, Heaven and Hell are intent on starting the apocalypse, on burning it all down. The powers that be seem to revel in bureaucratic stalemates and are, in fact, quite eager to get on with this Earth-destructing final battle, while a handful of celestial and human beings clamber to find some measure of stability and salvage our world.


Gaiman’s stories are populated with complex characters, in situations that avoid stark notions of right and wrong. They manage to be deeply hopeful while reminding us that life is, well, messy and oftentimes inexplicable. There is no one truth. And this is what his collective work does so well: illuminate the reality of our shared experience, while encouraging us to embrace the curious mystery that is human life.


Elizabeth Evitts Dickinson is a writer in Baltimore.

Wednesday, July 6, 2022

Democrats Are Headed for a Disaster With Unfilled Judicial Vacancies / Christopher Kang

Democrats Are Headed for a Disaster With Unfilled Judicial Vacancies / Christopher Kang


 — Read time: 8 minutes


Skip to the content

Jurisprudence

Democrats Are Headed for a Disaster With Unfilled Judicial Vacancies

There’s only one way to fix it.

Chuck Schumer holds his hand to his head.

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer at the U.S. Capitol on March 1. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

At the end of his first year in office, President Joe Biden’s staff rightly trumpeted the fact that he had nominated and confirmed a historic number of judges at the start of his first term in office. After decades of Republicans outpacing Democrats in focus on the courts, it was welcome news. But today, as terrible decisions from the Supreme Court offer a stark reminder of the importance of the judiciary, we face a tough reality: even an historic pace has not been enough to keep up with the rate of judicial retirements, and President Biden and Senate Democrats are on track to leave more than 60 judicial vacancies open at the end of this year. With the possibility looming that Republicans may retake the Senate, we know that leaving any vacancy open in January could well mean letting a newly empowered Mitch McConnell blockade them, just as he did President Barack Obama’s picks, from Merrick Garland’s Supreme Court nomination to dozens of lower court nominees.


It’s time for Senate Democrats and the Biden White House to push beyond their current practices in order to fill all of the judicial vacancies by the end of this Congress. As someone who worked on judicial nominations in the Senate and the Obama White House, I know how hard it can be for Democrats to challenge norms, but we have seen Republicans stop at nothing in their relentless push to take and retain control of the federal judiciary to impose their extreme, partisan agenda on a majority of Americans who oppose it. Our federal courts are so far out of balance that we need the president and the Senate to do everything in their power to ensure justice and equality. That means filling every vacancy, even if it means breaking with the few remaining judicial confirmation process norms left in McConnell’s wake or standing up to Republican senators. Beginning to bring balance to our judiciary is more important than respecting Senate traditions.


A more aggressive approach to judicial confirmations starts at the White House. Today, there are more than 80 judicial vacancies without nominees, out of 119 announced vacancies. One of the driving causes for this is too much White House deference to senators—both Democratic and Republican. The Biden administration needs to take a more assertive approach and show it is willing to bypass Senate tradition if senators are not proving good partners.


Sign Up for the Surge

The most important political nonsense of the week, delivered to your inbox every Saturday.


In states with Democratic senators, the White House is honoring a longstanding tradition that allows senators of the president’s party to recommend district court candidates to the White House. This is fine, but the White House needs to be firmer in enforcing its own deadlines in states where senators are moving too slowly. Even before Biden’s inauguration, White House Counsel Dana Remus told Democratic senators to submit recommendations within 45 days of a vacancy being announced, but it is clear from the number of long pending vacancies without nominees that many senators are ignoring this timeline. In California alone, there are nine district court vacancies without nominees—five of which were announced more than a year ago. Time is running out, and the White House needs to start enforcing its request by bypassing senators where necessary.


To move forward with nominations in states with Republican senators, the White House and Senate Judiciary Chair Dick Durbin must be willing to bypass a Senate tradition known as blue slips, which allow any senator to functionally veto district court nominees in his or her own state. This tradition was weaponized by segregationist senators to stop pro-civil rights judges nominated in their home states, and during the Obama administration, it persisted as an enormous obstacle to diversifying the judiciary. Anyone who thinks the White House can work with Senate Republicans on judicial nominations should look at Wisconsin, where Sen. Ron Johnson recommended a qualified district court candidate, only to abruptly pull his support after the nomination was actually announced. It’s worth noting that when Republicans controlled the Senate under Donald Trump, they ignored blue slips from Democratic Senators on circuit court nominees, effectively dismantling that deference for Democrats when they are out of power. Abolishing the blue slip custom once and for all will require cooperation from the Senate, but the White House should force the issue and expose the absurdity of the system by nominating qualified, professionally diverse nominees in these states and daring the Senate to block them.


The White House increasing nominations will be of little use, though, if the Senate Judiciary Committee ends up serving as a bottleneck. Before being confirmed, each judicial nominee must appear before the committee for a hearing. As a result, the number of hearings scheduled and the number of nominees who can appear at each hearing are probably the most important factors in determining how many nominees will be confirmed before the end of this Congress. Right now, committee Democrats are following norms and recent practices, but this is simply not sufficient to fill every judicial vacancy—and indeed, sets a path that would leave more than 60 seats open.


The norm is for the committee to hold a nomination hearing every two weeks that the Senate is in session. At that pace, it will hold only six more hearings with enough time for committee votes this year. The current practice—which was set when Republicans expanded it to process Trump judges more quickly—calls for two circuit and three district nominees per hearing. So this schedule would allow for hearings for only 30 judicial vacancies, while 65 receive no committee consideration at all—and that assumes that every hearing slot is used for lifetime judicial nominees, even though just last week, the committee gave a slot to a Department of Justice nominee.


Despite this stark reality, a judiciary committee aide recently told Bloomberg News, “I don’t think there’s any reason for us to change the way we’re operating.” That’s simply wrong. The judiciary committee must take a page out of the playbook Senate Republicans used during the Trump administration and schedule additional hearings and add to the number of nominees who can be considered at each hearing. Holding more hearings may be less convenient for those involved, but with so much at stake, it’s essential the committee follow the Republican model set during the Trump administration, which included holding hearings in consecutive weeks and even while the Senate was in recess.


Once nominees receive committee hearings and votes, they will need time on the Senate floor to be confirmed. Republicans are doing everything they can to slow down Biden nominees, and if President Biden and the judiciary committee ramp up the speed of nominations, Senate Democrats will need to match Republicans’ fortitude, skipping or delaying recesses and staying in Washington over weekends to vote if necessary.


None of these steps should require the Biden administration to compromise on the quality of judges it is putting forward. One of President Biden’s most impressive judicial legacies in his first year in office was the record-breaking number of public defenders and civil rights lawyers he nominated, a sharp departure from the old paradigm of Democrats primarily drawing from the ranks of prosecutors and corporate lawyers. The White House must not undermine its well-earned legacy on the courts by curbing its focus on professional diversity or accepting deals that would include conservative extremists. Instead, it must rally Democrats together—at every stage of the nomination and confirmation process—to fill every vacancy with judges dedicated to justice and equality. More than 30 national organizations already agree. Now more than ever, our courts—and our country—demand nothing less.


Tuesday, July 5, 2022

Happy Independence Day / Matthew Yglesias

Happy Independence Day

Matthew Yglesias — Read time: 3 minutes


Happy Independence Day

Fireworks are fun


The inaugural Slow Boring book club meets next week! Join us at 8:30 p.m. Eastern on July 7 for a discussion with Princeton professor Leah Boustan about her new book Streets of Gold. Buy the book here, and sign up for the discussion here. This event is for paid subscribers.


Happy Independence Day!


July 4 is first and foremost a time for grilling and fireworks, two things that I really unironically enjoy. But it’s probably also a good time to Say Something About America, so I wanted to recommend an oldish book by Bernard Bailyn called “The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution.”


What he does for the book is really dig into the pamphlets and such that were being published and widely read during the revolutionary period. Not just the handful of really stellar ones that stand out centuries later as quality work, but lots of run-of-the-mill stuff that was influential at the time and then just kind of faded away. It’s an inherently interesting exercise for someone in my line of work. You’ve got to figure that something like 99.999 percent of the commentary published during the Trump years is going to be washed away and forgotten. The handful of stuff that persists will be the things that future people find insightful. But if future people want to properly understand what was happening at the time, they are going to need to understand a lot of not-very-insightful commentary that was nonetheless reflective of various widely held sentiments.


So Bailyn, in that spirit, is really spelunking in the replacement-level political commentary of late-18th century America.


And what he finds (this is my editorial spin on it, not his) is that while the revolutionaries have a lot of very legitimate beef with the government in London that inspires the Revolution, they also have a lot of very odd ideas about the internal operation of the British government. They are really hung up on a fairly paranoid interpretation of 18th-century British politics in which the king is supposedly deploying massive corruption to subvert the power of parliament and re-enslave the British people.


As far as I can tell, this is just wrong. Britain was not democratic in the 1770s, but it was part of the way down the road of a long-term process of gradual democratization of British politics. The dispute between England and America was that England wanted to arrange colonial policy for the benefit of English people, whereas Americans wanted it arranged for the benefit of themselves. That was a genuine clash of interests and a perfectly good reason to seek independence, but the revolutionaries had this larger lurking background conception of what was going on.


And I think (again, this is me editorializing about Bailyn, not Bailyn himself) this is reflected in some of the oddities of American constitutional design. We with the benefit of hindsight know that the story of British democracy was the story of expanding the franchise for the House of Commons and establishing the supremacy of the Commons over the King and the House of Lords. But the revolutionaries strongly identified executive authority (which is to say the prime minister and his cabinet) with the king and saw a politically active prime minister as a form of corrupt royal subversion of parliamentary authority that was putting England on a slippery slope to tyranny.


So when they set up a new government for themselves, they didn’t just think “hey this is great, we’re self-governing now and we’ve solved the problem!” — they also tried to solve this other alleged problem where the executive was too involved with legislating. This concept of separating the functions does not seem to me to be something that has stood the test of time. And the view that the British system was on the road to tyranny is clearly just false. The actual issue in the American War of Independence was, well, independence. We’re over here, trying to create a new nation conceived in liberty and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal. It remains a great idea, but it would be better if we could keep our focus on that and sideline some of these misreadings of the English political situation.

Monday, July 4, 2022

Nordic alliance mailbag by Matthew Yglesias

Nordic alliance mailbag

Matthew Yglesias — Read time: 16 minutes


Nordic alliance mailbag

Norwegian film, "The Snow Man," and Puerto Rican statehood


The inaugural Slow Boring book club meets next week! Join us at 8:30 p.m. Eastern for a discussion with Princeton professor Leah Boustan about her new book Streets of Gold. Buy the book here, and sign up for the discussion here. This event is for paid subscribers.


Finland and Sweden have worked things out with Turkey and are now set to join NATO. I don’t really have an article’s worth of thoughts on this, but I am a fan of both countries so I did want to acknowledge it. Finland is so great I even had fun visiting Helsinki in the dead of winter when it was practically never daylight and everything was insanely cold.


Andrew: What's up with the Snow Man poem? Obviously I understand what it means and the point you're trying to get across when you post/reference it, but it would probably be helpful for OTHER readers if you explained.


This is a Wallace Stevens poem that I like a lot.


I’m not actually really sure that there is that much point in trying to explain it, because obviously it’s a poem and doesn’t have the logical structure of a persuasive argument. Either reading the words Stevens wrote moves you to ponder them or it doesn’t. But I’ve been thinking about this poem on and off since I was in high school. And while it used to signify to me a kind of defiant modernist atheism (as in several of his other poems like “Sunday Morning” and “The Emperor of Ice Cream”), I now see it as more about the subjectivity of the human experience. But while Stevens focuses on the inevitability of reality being refracted in peculiar ways by the human mind in “The Man With the Blue Guitar,” in “The Snow Man,” he’s speaking aspirationally about at least approaching a rational assessment as a regulative ideal.


Sometimes I will express a view on the internet that other people regard as insufficiently emotional, at which point they start lashing out and calling me a ghoul or a sociopath. But Stevens writes here about the “mind of winter,” which is more how I like to think about it. It is sometimes hard to look at the world and see “nothing that is not there and the nothing that is,” but it’s worth trying.


Chet: What is your favorite airline to fly and why (domestic and international)?


I wouldn’t say I have a “favorite” airline.


If you want to fly internationally from the D.C. area, the best option is to fly on United out of Dulles. As a result, I try to concentrate all my flying on United out of Dulles so that work-related frequent flier miles can be expended on family vacations. This is a bit less convenient than flying on American out of DCA, but I think it works all things considered. One bonus is that United has direct flights to both San Antonio and Bangor, which are our two regular domestic destinations.


Hilary: In the last week, I've twice been the only identifiably-female commenter in Slow Boring threads about topics that primarily affect women. One was about trans women in sports, and the other was about abortion. I happen to have significant personal experience with both of these issues, though only in one case did I feel comfortable sharing that here. 


Obviously, as someone who pays money to read Matt's thoughts every weekday, I would never claim that men shouldn't have or express their opinions on any topic they like. But I'm finding that the discussions get very abstract very quickly in the absence of lived experience. I can't help but think that the quality of discussion on these (and probably also other) issues would be higher if women's perspectives were better represented. 


Do you agree? If so, do you have any ideas for how to increase women's participation? And to what do you attribute the relative paucity of identifiable women in the Slow Boring comments?


I’m of two minds about this, since I think the basic reality is that the vast majority of people of either gender aren’t spending much time in comment threads and I sympathize a lot with that choice. Slow Boring also seems to have a male-skewing audience overall, and I think “arguing on the internet” is a male-skewing activity, so you end up with a very male-skewed space, which probably further turns women off.


That’s not ideal but also not generally the end of the world. But when the topics are ones where women’s experiences are particularly relevant, it doesn’t make for an ideal discussion — I’m open to suggestions but I’m not sure I have a great idea.


[Editor’s note: Thanks, Hilary, for the feedback! This comment was really helpful and led to a long Slow Boring staff discussion. We’re not sure that we have *great* ideas for how to address this, but we do have *some* ideas and will start to implement them this summer. Commenters who’d like to share their experiences, give us feedback, or offer suggestions are welcome to reach out to me directly at kate at slowboring dot com]


Mesfin Teklu: Just watched Avatar, The Martian, and Dune this weekend with my Gf, she’s finally letting me indoctrinate her into the Sci-Fi canon.


What are some of the other greatest sci-do movies that would appeal to people who aren’t totally sci-fi nerds?


See, it seems quite predictable that we have this question in the mailbag rather than a woman asking which rom coms to make her boyfriend watch. Personally, my absolute favorite movie is “Blade Runner,” but my sincere advice to the young men of the world is to not try to push this stuff on the people you go out with. Maybe try asking what they are interested in and getting them to share their favorite content with you?


Marc Robbins: On Matt's recommendation, I just watched "The Worst Person in the World." Apart from its luminous star, my reaction to it was . . . meh. The basic reason was because it so abysmally failed the Bechdel test. After briefly chortling at the heroine's "search" for a career in the first couple minutes, the entire movie was spent totally defining her in terms of her romantic interests -- and the two guys had far deeper lives than she did. I thought we were way beyond that kind of retro stuff; it's not the kind of message I'd like to see passed on to my two daughters of roughly Julie's age. (If you want to see a movie that wonderfully integrates a woman's romantic interests, career ambitions, and pursuit of her higher ideals, go see the far superior "Broadcast News.")


So, Matt, why is this your favorite film of 2022?


I mean, what can I say — I’m a middle-aged man! But in my defense, see rave reviews from Alissa Wilkinson, Clarisse Loughrey, Ella Kemp, Ann Hornaday, Stephanie Zacharek, and Lindsey Bahr — all female film critics. Indeed, the review I’ve read whose take was most similar to yours came from Richard Brody, A Man, in The New Yorker.


I think that there is a slightly tedious mode of thinking about art that has developed on the internet, where we have learned that there is “a trope” called “the manic pixie dream girl” and that this trope is bad, and Julie arguably is a manic pixie dream girl and therefore the movie is bad. But is the movie bad? The star is luminous. The comic stuff is funny. The sad stuff is sad. The characters have meaningful conflicts with each other in which everyone’s point of view seems plausible. That’s good drama! Is the movie excessively centered on Julie’s romantic entanglements or is part of the point of the end that Julie was excessively centered on this?


Benjamin, J: The potential statehood for Puerto Rico receives enormous amount of political attention, but what should the US be doing about its smaller territories? The Virgin Islands, Guam, American Samoa & the Northern Mariana Islands are all territories of the US, which lack federal representation. What strategy should the federal government take to provide more rights to these territories, or should they seek to jettison them to grant them independence?


Holding binding statehood referenda in all the territories and letting each one become a state if they want to actually polls quite well. By contrast, D.C. statehood, which is the cause that is most embraced by Democratic Party elites, is unpopular.


The real shame of this is that Puerto Rican statehood, which polls well and has a little bit of GOP support in Congress, was sabotaged because of dumb leftist concerns that it’s imperialism. Obviously Puerto Rico should be allowed to opt for independence if it wants that. But there’s no sign that it does, and good reason to believe it would choose statehood in a binding referendum were one to be held. We should do that and should have similar referenda in the other territories (and D.C., too).


Eric Kumbier: Progressives often tout that social spending has a much higher multiplier than tax cuts because it goes directly into the hands of the poor, who spend the money instead of investing or saving it. Does that mean social spending is more inflationary vis a vis tax cuts?


Yes, redistribution is stimulative. If you implemented the original Build Back Better concept of raising taxes on a narrow base of rich people in order to provide major new social benefits, that would be inflationary. The better way to do this would be to create the benefits during an economic downturn, and then pay for them later with broader-based tax increases.


Matt L: You tweeted after Bowser’s win in the Dem primary last week based on broad support from high SES whites that DC politics seem to be reorganizing around ideological lines in a way that haven’t been in the past. Can you expand on that? Is this playing out in a similar way in other big cities?


Let me try to be a little clearer about this. If you look at D.C.’s 2010 primary, you see a stark racial divide in the voting patterns where the incumbent Adrian Fenty is the “white” candidate and Vince Gray is the Black candidate even though both men are African American. Then in 2014, you see the exact same pattern of Gray winning Black neighborhoods and Muriel Bowser winning white ones, but Bowser just does a bit better in some of the upscale Black neighborhoods in Ward 4 and wins.


In 2018 there was no primary. But in 2022 we got a whole new pattern — Bowser won the whitest neighborhoods but she also won the Blackest ones. Robert White’s stronghold, meanwhile, is in the gentrification frontier neighborhoods in the center of the city.



To me this reflects a more ideological organization of politics. White clearly positioned himself as the progressive alternative to Bowser, and he won the votes of a racially diverse group of mostly younger people. Bowser, meanwhile, had something like a Joe Biden coalition of moderate older people of all races. This seems like a healthier way to run city politics.


Casey Adams: Somewhere in the multiverse, Matt is a White House press correspondent. What should boring Matt have asked Trump?


If I could sit down and interview Trump, I’d like to really just do an extremely earnest policy discussion and make him really explain his ideas on Medicaid or whatever.


Hugo Bromley: Thoughts on biofuel? I've never been convinced of its merits on environmental grounds, and with current food prices the UK/Germany push at the G7 for waivers on biofuel mandates seems to make sense to me.


I am very skeptical about biofuels. I think we know that electricity is the vehicle fuel of the future, and the future of electricity is either some kind of massive overbuilding of renewables or else has a hefty element of next-generation nuclear or geothermal power. Biofuels originate, politically, because agricultural interests have a lot of clout and it’s essentially a giveaway to farmers, not a real environmental or energy policy.


Alistair: How do you organize your daily/weekly routine to manage the ordinary responsibilities of parenting (grocery shopping, cooking, wakeup, bedtime, etc.)?


Conveniently, my editor is also my wife, so we have a lot of flexibility to communicate and address these things. My core parenting jobs are bath time, weekend wake-ups, and school drop-offs while Kate does bedtime, weekday wake-ups, most things related to school, and school pickups and after-school childcare. She cleans (we also have weekly help cleaning) and usually but not always cooks, and I do major weekend grocery runs, while we split day-to-day errands. We don’t have regular childcare help outside of core 8:15-3:15 school hours. I work more hours, and Kate spends more time on childcare, an arrangement that we’re both happy with.


In general, I would say the Substack lifestyle is pretty parent-friendly just because it’s work that can be done at pretty much any time of day rather than requiring my presence at any particular moment in time.


TF: You recently said: “Objectively, (Jurassic Park is) probably not even one of Steven Spielberg’s top-five films and arguably doesn’t even belong in the top 10.” Do you believe there are right and wrong answers to questions of art quality? Can you prove that Clue isn't the best movie ever made, and Thomas Kinkade isn't the greatest painter to ever live?


If you read my AI sentience post, you’ll see my argument there is that the really hard question is the superficially easy one — are people sentient?


And that’s the general model for how I think about a lot of philosophical problems. Can I “prove” the truth or falsity of claims about aesthetics? In some sense, no. But can I prove the truth or falsity of any other kind of claim? Not really. I can never remember what Robert Nozick actually wrote down versus just said in class, but one of his points is that we often seem to have an image in our head of some kind of argument being so good that it somehow coerces other people into agreeing with us — rationality compels you! But nothing actually works like that, not about aesthetics and not about ethics and not about anything else.


What I think is clearly true is that as human beings, we can look at things that we like and form judgments about them that involve some self-awareness. I saw “Jurassic Park” when I was 12. My dad took me on opening day. I was very excited about the movie and it hit expectations. That gives me a kind of a relationship to the movie that I don’t have with “Jaws” or “Raiders of the Lost Ark,” both of which I saw on VHS long after they first came out. So “Jurassic Park” means more to me than “Raiders.” But I can also try to ask myself, how would this look if I try to subtract the happenstance from it? And in that sense, I think “Raiders” is objectively better.


Doug B: With the country being slowly torn asunder, what are your thoughts on instituting a mandatory national service program as a way to provide needed services while simultaneously nation building. After high school, every able bodied student spends one year in the military, in National community service or a small foreign service a la the Peace Corps. I think more good will come out of forced mixing of kids from diverse backgrounds then from any other program I can think of. Put a rural kid from Tennessee, a rich kid from Charlotte, a trans kid from Columbus and a kid from the inner city in a dorm or barrack together with a common goal and I think we will see a far more empathetic nation with a common mission. Plus, we may gain a little bit more mobility and willingness of people to move around the country, benefiting themselves and the country overall.


I totally get where people are coming from on this. In World War II there was this huge existential threat to the country that required the mass mobilization of all kinds of people from all walks of life to cooperate with each other for the common good in defense of commonly held values. And while the war itself was terrible, that spirit of cooperation seems to have had benefits. So it always seems like it would be good to get those benefits — national service! — without the destruction of war.


My sense, though, is you can’t actually fake your way into national unity like that. The war was a unifying experience because the threat was real. You can’t just be like “well what if we all decided that cleaning up litter was as important as beating Hitler, wouldn’t that be good?” I think it would be good. But why would we decide that? It’s not true!


I do think we should try to encourage more fancy college students to volunteer for military service and become the next Mayor Pete or Tom Cotton. I think the Teach for America program did a lot of good over the years, and the country would benefit from a similarly designed Police for America program that challenged elite students to roll up their sleeves and do an important job in a way that is more consistent with their values.


City of Trees: In the spirit of Monday's thread, what are the ten points that you would craft for the Democrats to run on?


The reason I wrote that article is that I think the fact that it was Perry Bacon who wrote the ten points is significant — it’s much better and more credible to let leftist-minded people who find people like me annoying write the list. The role of annoying people like me is to challenge them to set priorities and write down a reasonably brief list of agenda items and then let people be flexible elsewhere.


But if it were me:


A national ban on gerrymandering.


Age limits for members of Congress.


Medicare negotiation of prescription drug prices.


An “all of the above” strategy for national energy dominance.


A federal cap on credit card interest rates.


Free school lunch for everyone.


A federal abortion rights floor; no first trimester bans, there must be meaningful health/life of the mother protections for after that.


A federal crackdown on interstate gun smuggling.


Something like Val Demings’ national initiative to solve more murders.


Enact meaningful barriers to underage kids’ ability to access internet porn — if porn sites cannot logistically come up with a way to do age real verification then they going to be shut down.


Doug Orleans: The two pundits I find myself disagreeing with the least are probably you and Paul Krugman. Do you read his columns and posts regularly? Are there things you disagree with Krugman about?


For any of the strong columnists out there, it is really rare for me to read one and be like, “Aha! That claim is definitely wrong!”


What does happen is that at different points in time there are people whose points of emphasis I tend to find more or less compelling. I tend to think that in the 1990s, Krugman was maybe a little excessively concerned with intellectual boundary-policing on the left, and now in the 2020s he’s maybe a little under-concerned with this, just given that leftist politics is stronger and more influential today than it was 25 years ago.


Shane: Ever considered writing fiction?


Many times since I have so many fiction writers in my family!


Here’s one idea. We are in the alternate reality where World War I doesn’t happen and the Habsburg Empire persists while the United States has slower progress on different forms of social inclusion due to the lack of wartime mobilizations. It’s the 1990s, and America has its first Catholic president, Joseph Biden. The heir to the Habsburg throne and his new wife are coming to visit the United States as part of a diplomatic reversal that will see the U.S. ally with Austria and Germany instead of Britain and Russia. The Biden administration is also making a big push to give up on 30 years of effort to make “separate but equal” a reality and declare that separate is inherently unequal. Russia-backed white supremacists are plotting to assassinate the Archduke, scuttle the alliance, neutralize the Jewish influence over the White House, and Make America Great Again. Our heroes need to foil the assassination plot before it plunges the world into war.


Nicholas Lilovitch: A few weeks ago Matt wrote the following: "People sometimes say that inflation is regressive, which I think is probably not true... " The people I've learned from (mostly at UChicago) mostly thought it was quite regressive. In particular, they'd argue that wealth in the form of assets was generally "inflation adjusted" while income has a lag (not to mention, inflation is often highest in food/fuel). Why do you think inflation isn't regressive?


Because it’s been so long since inflation was a serious concern, a lot of broad ideas about inflation are handed down to us based on features of the economy in the 1960s and 1970s that no longer apply today.


One key is that these days Social Security, SNAP, and other social assistance benefits are indexed to inflation. So while my income has fallen quite a bit over the past 12 months in inflation-adjusted terms, a low-income retiree “living on a fixed-income” is guaranteed against the erosion of benefits. We’ve also seen nominal wages rise fastest at the low end, and (equally important) as a result of the tremendous demand for labor, it is now easier for employed people to get as many hours as they’d like to work, which has not been the case for most of the 21st century. What is true is that scarcity of food and energy hit the poor very hard, so I don’t want to overturn the conventional wisdom there. But I think that in terms of core inflation, the inflationary environment probably hurts the poor relatively less now than it did in the 60s and 70s.

Saturday, July 2, 2022

The Cost of Call-Out Culture

Cover photo
The Cost of Call-Out Culture
We cannot afford to lose more voices
Andrea Gibson
Jun 30
Over the last decade I’ve met countless poets, writers, activists, and artists who are muting their own voices and removing themselves from vital political movements because of the constant influx of public commentary on what they might be doing wrong. I am a poet and author who has been speaking on social justice issues for the past two decades. Since social media became a thing, messing up and accounting for my mess-ups publicly is a part of my daily life, and I am intimate with the ways non-stop public criticism can erode any individual's wellness. Below are ten of my personal perspectives that support me when navigating call-out culture. My hope is that this will reach people whose feedback tactics are detrimental to the wellbeing of others, as well as those who have grown so afraid of making a mistake they have decided to make nothing instead. We cannot afford to lose more voices in the fight against facisim. To take down systems of oppression, we must stop taking down each other––so let’s chat this through.

1. Be wary of a pressure to homogenize your thinking. I’m not quite sure what the left means anymore but one of the scariest things I witness from us on the left is a demand to think what everyone else thinks. As our planet is literally dying for fresh perspectives, my wish is for all of us to engage the world like inventors. Becoming a product of a thought-assembly-line will never quicken our dreams of creating a more caring society. The answers we need are very often found in discussions that welcome wonder, curiosity, and respectful disagreement. Whenever I veer out of the lane of what everyone else is thinking, the road rage begins––but my spirit would be far more enraged if I decided to spend my life a replica of someone else. The key, for me, is to be guided by a deep reverence for others, and to never ever assume I know more about any group of people of which I am not a part than they know about themselves.

2. Having a marginalized identity does not inherently make anyone a ‘good’ person. (I’m not someone who resonates with the concept of good and bad people but since others do I’m including this sentiment.) I’m queer and nonbinary and have spent most of my adult life chronically ill and that doesn’t innately make me kinder or more committed to change than the ablebodied cis straight white man standing behind me in the grocery store. Dude could be a saint for all I know. I have very clear evidence that I am not a saint. Likewise, great politics don’t necessarily equate to compassionate people. I’ve encountered a number of politically progressive humans who act enthusiastically cruel. I’ve also known a ton of wonderful people who had terrible politics simply because they hadn’t yet been exposed to new ways of thinking.

3. Recognize when classism is mingling with your desire to call someone out. Who is and isn’t welcome in social justice movements? I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about this as I have formerly incarcerated people in my life who are smarter than I am in countless ways, but who did not have access to the kind of education I did. Because of that, when I hear anyone referring to themselves as a ‘prison abolitionist’ while simultaneously viciously attacking people for microaggressions they simply hadn’t had the specific education to unlearn––it irks me. I have been actively reading and learning about the social justice issues I speak about for the last twenty-five years and I still mess up constantly. Imagine how painful it would be to know your voice is unwelcome in a movement where your voice would be the most vital. I’m not suggesting anyone should remain silent about microaggressions as there is commonly no micro-ness to the pain they cause. I’m saying we will have more necessary voices in our movements if we begin interacting with people with more understanding.

4. Make sure your reasons for calling someone out are pure of heart. Here are some questions one might use to gauge such a thing: Would you choose this method of accountability if your best friend made this same mistake or judgment error? Is your desire to publicly point out another’s poor choice fueled in any way by an unwillingness to address and account for your own behaviors? Do you feel pleasure or excitement when your community piles on to further shame the person? Are you in any way overstating harm? Is toxic individualism impacting your capacity to root for and believe in the growth of others? Do you have a keen eye on the fact that particular brands of public call outs for even small judgment errors in today’s world can mean the end of a person’s employment which commonly means the end of their health benefits and housing? Such questions are important because I’m not writing this essay about the alt-right. I’m speaking about community members who are committed to bettering the world, and are, like everyone, making mistakes on that journey.

5. Know the difference between ‘tone-policing’ and saying no to abusive interactions. There is a thin line here that I still don’t always get right, but I’ll share an example from my life to illustrate how one might navigate this. “What the hell were you thinking writing that racist/biphobic/ableist garbage? How on earth is it possible you don’t know this shit?” Ok, this may not be how I’d say something if I were consciously trying to reach someone, but it’s certainly how I’ve said things when triggered. If I shut down this conversation, that would be tone-policing. If similar feedback came my way with, for example, the addition of an attack on my appearance, I would not engage the person––but I would still spend time with the feedback part of the sentiment to see if it resonated as a learning I should do. Never let another person’s unkindness stand in the way of your own growth. And, as I’ve been unkind in my own life many times, I know that most people are typically unkind when they are terrified, grieving or both. There are an infinite number of reasons why marginalized people would be terrified or grieving in our world right now.

6. Being happy doesn't mean you don’t care about the world. I was hosting a writing workshop for youth when a girl raised her hand and said she didn’t feel her life had been hard enough to be a writer. I saw this as a failure of my generation. I wish we could erase every single thing we did to convince young people that pain is the only thing worthy of art. Similarly, no one needs to be unhappy to truly care about the world. Empathy actually increases one’s capacity for joy. Feeling into another’s pain wakes us to the love in our hearts and our connection with others. I share this fact each time someone suggests anyone’s care for our world could be measured by their online displays of grief.

7. Call-out culture is breeding an environment where people are afraid to thrive. One of the most devastating things I see call-out culture creating is an idea that one can be protected by their pain. Though the concept is terrifying, it’s not entirely far-fetched. I was diagnosed with ovarian cancer a year ago and since I announced it publicly I have seen an enormous decrease in the amount of raging criticism that comes my way from the left. Some may say people are simply being kind. But if they can be kind now, why not always? What I find literally sickening about this shift is that I have a large youth following who pays attention to such things. Their cells are still deciding what they want to become. If you are someone whose feedback tactics are so vicious they make young people think cancer looks more survivable, or if you’re someone who condones such tactics in others, your apology is the one to be most concerned about.

8. You are not the news. Though it makes a ton of sense why people would be desperate for others to use their platforms as loudspeakers for important world issues, the idea that anyone could speak to everything is, to use one of my least favorite words, problematic. Every day someone online is angry with me about something I’m not posting about, and as I share a lot I can only imagine this is happening to others tenfold. The one year I tried to keep up with such demands, the ‘real me’ was replaced by a performative activist I despised. Now I offer my voice where I trust my voice will help. And I pay attention to where I don’t think my voice will help, as that has always been a good indicator that I want to, and should, learn more about an issue.

9. Don’t apologize if you are not sorry. When someone makes a mistake in public, the demand to apologize with immediacy can make a person feel like they’re inside a moral pressure cooker, and if they don’t hit the “POST” button fast enough, their career and life will burn to a crisp. If you’re someone demanding lightning-quick apologies, please ask yourself if you’re truly invested in accountability, as genuine accountability takes time. If I don’t know what my response is, I give myself breathing room––even if it appears that no one else is willing to. If I still have some curiosity about what I may not be understanding, I might say something like, “I’ve been spending a lot of thoughtful time with this feedback and I am not able to offer an honest apology. That could very well change with more learning, which I’m committed to doing, but right now I’m unwilling to disrespect your life or mine by making up an apology that doesn’t yet resonate with me as truthful.” Harming others is painful, and authentically accounting for wrongdoing is as vital to the person apologizing as it is to the person who was hurt. We all knew by kindergarten that, “Say you’re sorry or you’re grounded!” wasn’t the path to true healing for either party.

10. Leave communities in which it has been collectively decided that cruel feedback is cool. This was the best thing I ever did for my mental health. I am no longer willing to be active in communities that show up to watch the failures and missteps of others like sports games. If you don’t believe people can change for the better, you do not belong in movements working to change things for the better. Additionally, the amount of times I have witnessed people who were causing a great deal of pain in the world brutally call out folks who were for the most part living thoughtful and compassionate lives, has been deeply disturbing. If you can’t see the humanity in others it is very likely you are struggling to see it in yourself. Put liking yourself on the top of your to-do list and you’ll be far less interested in tearing others apart, and far more invested in what we can create together.

Love, Andrea 🖤


Friday, July 1, 2022

America needs supply-side reform by Matthew Yglesias — Read time: 9 minutes

America needs supply-side reform by Matthew Yglesias — Read time: 9 minutes


America needs supply-side reform

It's can't just be an excuse — we need to improve our policies


Economic data clearly shows that the demand side of the economy has been running “too hot” this year, and to fight inflation, the Federal Reserve has to raise interest rates and Congress has to try to reduce the budget deficit.


At the same time, only a relatively small fraction of our economic pain can be attributed to excessively stimulative policy. American Rescue Plan spending isn’t the reason that 2022 crude oil output is running behind the 2019 level, and ARP spending definitely isn’t the reason for the unprecedented ratio of gasoline prices to crude oil prices. It also isn’t behind the global food crisis. The airline industry is creaking under the strain of rising demand for travel, but overall air travel demand remains below pre-pandemic levels due to a decline in business spending. Difficulties are compounded by the fact that during the summer of 2020, major airlines offered pilots financial incentives to take early retirement to cut costs.


But stepping back from the Twitter trench warfare, I think there’s something a little perverse about the dialogue surrounding the role that ARP spending played in inflation. We’re stuck in a game of rhetorical ping-pong in which ARP’s critics, who raised the specter of inflation, are spiking the football now that inflation is here while the Biden administration and its allies defend ARP by emphasizing all the supply-side factors driving inflation.


But the argument we should be having is the one about making policy right now.


If all our economic problems were due to the ARP, then the good news is ARP spending is phasing out and the Fed is raising interest rates and it’s all going to be fine.


Except that things might not be fine, because even if you believe ARP is to blame, these negative supply-side issues are real. You can’t wave them off as excuses — whether ARP was “too big” or “just right,” it definitely wasn’t too small — but the economy is fully-stimulated for the first time in the 21st century. This means that economic growth is going to need to be powered by supply-side reforms.


Both things matter

If you’re interested in the supply versus demand argument, I recommend Adam Shapiro’s research brief for the San Francisco Fed which shows — tada! – that both are factors.


In particular, looking at overall inflation, which includes food and energy prices and drives overall living standards, it’s clear that Russia-related supply shocks have, in fact, been a very big deal.



But demand-side factors are also an important part of the overall inflation story, and that’s especially true if you focus on core inflation.



In other words, it’s not “did we overstimulate the economy or did we face negative supply shocks?” It’s “we both overshot the target on demand somewhat and also are facing a bunch of negative supply shocks.”


And the fact that it’s both is unfortunate because it tends to muddle the dialogue. For example, I both support what the Fed is doing in raising interest rates and also worry that the Fed will soon go too far. But that’s not a good tweet!


The conversation has veered away from the sort of boring, basic economics that people got lazy about during the Great Recession when it seemed like a good time to throw the whole neoliberalism playbook out the window. But when the economy is a bit overstimulated and also hit by negative demand shocks, it’s the perfect time to talk about boring neoliberal stuff like free trade.


The classic case for free trade

There’s been a fair amount of discussion of the Trump tariffs and the possibility that the Biden administration might back off of them.


But it’s worth recalling the bigger-picture, classic textbook economics case for free trade. The standard comparative advantage argument is that opening up the borders to trade costs some jobs in the short term, but that labor is eventually reallocated to its best use, resulting in higher living standards for everyone. This argument was politically discredited by the lived experience of the past 20 years. But at no point during that period did we ever have a really robust job market with strongly rising nominal wages and plentiful job openings. And if you think about that standard case for free trade, it implicitly assumes that sort of robust demand as a background condition.


That turns out not to be a law of nature. You can have really prolonged labor market slumps, creating periods where protectionism really does create jobs.


But we are not, right now, in a period like that. The United States, for example, levies tariffs on a lot of the products that frackers use to drill for oil and gas.


Absent those tariffs, yes, some people might lose jobs in pipe factories. But other people would gain jobs in the oil and gas industry. And cheaper natural gas prices would help other American industries, save people money on their electricity bills, and help bolster the economy.


And this is the general situation throughout the economy. The Biden administration is looking at regulatory policy measures to increase the housing supply, which is good. But the United States has, for a mix of longstanding and Trump-specific reasons, a bunch of tariffs on foreign-made construction materials.



Some of this is China-specific and can be written off as the cost of our foreign policy objectives. And I suppose there’s an argument that solar panels are a national strategic industry. But quartz countertops from India? Steel nails from Vietnam? Japanese cement? Those are our allies.


And it goes to the same point as the pipes. In a tight labor market, allowing more imported construction materials doesn’t mean fewer jobs; it means a transition of jobs out of nail-making factories into making houses with nails. And that means an overall more prosperous economy.


Efficiencies everywhere

It’s become fashionable to deride “Econ 101” thinking.


But my view is that Econ 101 has become badly underrated as a result of the prolonged labor market slump. Paul Krugman wrote a book way back in 1999 called “The Return of Depression Economics,” and its prescience made him one of the most influential writers of the 21st century. The point of the book is that for various reasons, major world economies were at risk of slipping into recessions that couldn’t be easily ended by quick interest rate cuts from the central bank. And when that happens, you are in a world of “depression economics” where the rules of Econ 101 don’t apply. It’s a great book, and Krugman got to write a lot of columns based on depression economics themes because he was basically right.


But guess what? We’re not in depression economics now. Interest rates are going up and inflation remains high. So “101”-type considerations dominate.


For example, I’ve long complained about how weird it is that the New York City Subway uses conductors on its trains rather than single drivers like almost every other mass transit system in the world. Depression economics says laying those conductors off might save the city money, but it’s also macroeconomically cruel.


Today, though, New York is dealing with a critical shortage of bus drivers. Paying transit workers to do unnecessary work even while important transit work goes undone is just a disaster of inefficiency. Of course the impact of changing this one thing would not be that large relative to the scale of the entire American economy. And it drove me crazy back in 2009 and 2010 when conservatives would point to various micro-inefficiencies in an economy that was badly starved for demand and say “see! that’s the problem!” Because when the economy is depressed, providing a fiscal and monetary boost is a much bigger and faster-acting lever. But the economy isn’t demand-constrained right now, so we don’t have a giant fast-acting lever. What we have instead are dozens and dozens of small switches we could flip.


The Jones Act barring the use of foreign ships to move goods between domestic ports may raise the price of gasoline by as much as 15 cents per gallon. Experts estimate the impact of rescinding the Trump tariffs as shaving somewhere between 0.25 and 1.3 percentage points off the consumer price index.


None of the impacts here are all that large, so it’s easy to look at any one thing and say “eh, why bother.” This is fine as long as it’s just one thing. But as is often the case in life, ignoring lots and lots of small problems adds up to a big problem.


Supply-side forever

Timelines are another roadblock.


When a problem becomes acute, political leaders really want to do something about it and do it quickly. But the Biden administration’s willingness to increase crude oil supply is constrained by the existence of bottlenecks in oil refining — nothing they do on crude will dramatically alter short-term gas prices. Skanda Amarnath at Employ America argues that this is a little misleading. Current crude oil stockpiles remain abnormally low, so there is plenty of room for global markets to absorb more supply. But I do think it’s basically true that there isn’t a quick and easy button the administration can press to make gas cheaper.


Or take another case: the shortage of airline pilots.


In a proximate sense, this is the short-sightedness of airlines encouraging early retirements coming home to roost. So why don’t we just train more pilots? Well, back in 2009, a Colgan Air flight crashed. The investigation revealed that the crash was due to pilot error, which inspired the passage of the Airline Safety and Federal Aviation Administrative Extension Act of 2010. As a result of that law, the number of hours flying required to get a commercial license increased from 250 hours to 1,500. To be clear, the pilots in the Colgan Air flight in question had over 1,500 hours of flight time. This new rule had no particularly intimate relationship to the safety issue at hand. At the time, though, labor scarcity wasn’t a big concern.


But as Gary Leff writes, the more stringent rule is now making it hard to get new pilots into the air. The problem isn’t just that it takes longer to gain 1,500 hours of flight experience — it also costs more money, raising the number of years of work a pilot needs to do to earn back their investment. That not only makes piloting less desirable as a career, but it dramatically increases the risk profile for people who may not be sure they want to dedicate their whole life to piloting. Safety is obviously very important. But American passenger aviation was already very safe in 2009, and this new rule doesn’t seem to have improved anything. We could roll back to 1,000 hours or perhaps the European 500-hour standard.


What this won’t do, unfortunately, is suddenly eliminate summer flight chaos. Improving the “pilot supply chain” is doable and beneficial, but it would still take time to work. And the same is true of most supply-side reforms. This means that if you think of deregulation as a dirty word that you’re only willing to invoke to solve acute crises, you won’t do it.


But that’s the wrong way to think about it. The right way to think about it is that the economy is either suffering from depressed demand or it isn’t. If it is, you should fix that. But if it isn’t, the only path toward growth is a steady drip drip drip of supply-side improvements. We hope that a lot of that will come from innovation and new technology. But it can also come from steadily improving public policy. It’s true that the gains will often come with a lag, but if the demand-side authorities are doing their jobs right, then the economy is always going to be supply-constrained — there will always be things you wish you did 18 months ago, it’s just hard to predict which things those are going to be. That’s why there’s no time like the present to get cracking.