Thursday, August 18, 2022

Liz Cheney’s Defense of Democracy Needs a Political Strategy by Jonathan Bernstein

Liz Cheney’s Defense of Democracy Needs a Political Strategy

There are lessons in Cheney's loss in Wyoming, and the answers will help her counter Trump in 2024.


She campaigned as a national candidate against Trump, not as a local politician at all.


Photographer: Al Drago/Bloomberg

By

Jonathan Bernstein


August 17, 2022 at 10:23 PM GMT+9

Two years ago, Wyoming Republican Liz Cheney was on her way to being a future Speaker of the House. She was the third-ranking House Republican with a totally safe seat. She lost that position in the House Republican conference, and now has lost her seat entirely. All because she decided to stand with the Constitution and the republic, and against the crimes of a Republican president.


An under-appreciated factor in Cheney’s rise and fall was that she was always a national politician who snagged a Wyoming seat. She was born in Wisconsin, went to high school near Washington, D.C., and went to college in Colorado before starting a Washington-based career in government and Republican politics. Indeed, her first attempt at winning office in Wyoming — a short-lived 2014 primary challenge to Republican Senator Mike Enzi — struggled with accusations of carpetbagging. In 2016, she was able to overcome that to win the vacant House seat, but her focus has always been on national, not local, policy questions. She never built the kinds of deep connections that many members of the House have within their own districts.


Even her father, who certainly was from Wyoming, didn’t really spend much time in the state after college, especially after representing the state in the House from 1979 to 1989. He, too, entered politics as a national, not a local, politician. There’s nothing wrong with that at all; the same has been true of many congressional leaders. But the weaker the district ties, the more vulnerable the representative presumably is to shake-ups. She won her elections as a strong Republican partisan; she lost last night as one of the only Republicans in Washington opposing the last Republican president.


She campaigned as a national candidate against Trump, not as a local politician at all; her final two-minute ad was explicitly addressed as much to a national as to a state audience. This was not a candidate running as a “trustee” — a representative asking the electorate to trust her to make decisions on their behalf. It wasn’t even a candidate running against her opponents, who she barely mentioned, as irresponsible opponents of democracy. Instead, Cheney was basically asking Republicans to use their vote to oppose a former president who wasn’t even on the ballot. That’s going to be a hard sell, even if Republican voters had serious doubts about Trump.


Whether she was seriously attempting re-election or not, Cheney’s defense of democracy and the rule of law has been superb, as have been her contributions to the Jan. 6 select committee.


She now pledges to continue her fight against Trump, perhaps with a presidential candidacy. It’s hard to see how contesting Republican primaries would achieve her goals, however, if Trump does run in 2024. An explicit anti-Trump candidate would appear to have no chance at all to be nominated. If anything, such a campaign would be likely to split the anti-Trump vote and help him win.


A third-party anti-Trump candidate in the general election might be more successful. In 2000, Ralph Nader concentrated his third-party campaign on contested states, and in those states he worked to secure the votes of those who would otherwise have backed the Democratic nominee, Al Gore. But even if Cheney was willing to campaign in order to elect a Democrat over Trump, it would still be a tricky proposition, since she might wind up winning votes that otherwise would have gone to the Democratic candidate. A true Nader-like anti-Trump candidate would more likely ignore Trump’s crimes and offenses and campaign purely on extreme conservative policy preferences, hoping to peel away some Republicans who might be tempted at the thought of voting for a True Conservative.


Oddly enough, Cheney’s father was on his way to being Speaker of the House when his own career path was altered back in 1989; Dick Cheney was the second-ranked House Republican behind a soon-to-retire party leader, but he became George H.W. Bush’s replacement Secretary of Defense when Bush’s first choice was defeated in the Senate. What’s more, Dick Cheney’s biggest accomplishment during his House career also involved serving on a select committee, in his case the one investigating the Iran-Contra affair — and his role was to limit the political damage of  the investigation, not to help make it effective. It certainly doesn’t appear likely at this point that Liz Cheney will wind up a cabinet secretary, let alone vice-president or president. But as hard as it is to see a next step that helps her fix the Republican Party and revive its commitment to the constitution and the rule of law, she may actually wind up as having the more important political career anyway.


This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.


To contact the author of this story:

Jonathan Bernstein at jbernstein62@bloomberg.net


To contact the editor responsible for this story:

Mike Nizza at mnizza3@bloomberg.net


Sunday, August 14, 2022

Defending Critical Race Theory is impossible without highlighting the moral panic around it


www.skeptic.org.uk
Defending Critical Race Theory is impossible without highlighting the moral panic around it
By Aaron Rabinowitz
27 - 34 minutes

https://www.skeptic.org.uk/2022/08/defending-critical-race-theory-is-impossible-without-highlighting-the-moral-panic-around-it/?utm_source=pocket_mylist

Before I get into the body of this article’s discussion, a little background is first required. I originally offered to write this piece in response to a recent request concerning Critical Race Theory (CRT) from the editor of the US Skeptic magazine, Michael Shermer:
Tweet from @MichaelShermer: Request: I'm editing an issue of Skeptic on "Race Matters" & need an article defending CRT, antiracism, etc. & have been turned down/ignored by a dozen leading scholars/writers/publisher. Plenty of space & we pay. Why won't CRTists defend the theory? DM or email me.

CRT, and what I believe is the moral panic surrounding it, is something I’ve written about in the past, so I reached out to Mr. Shermer, who told me he already had a CRT overview article “that mostly summarizes the history of the movement going back to its postmodernism roots (and before)”, which he described as “mostly neutral, albeit slightly critical on the consequences of accepting fully the belief in system racism by POC.” I later found out that that “article” is actually the CRT chapter from James Lindsay and Helen Pluckrose’s book Cynical Theories, two individuals who played a significant role in developing and mainstreaming the CRT moral panic.

Shermer explained that he and his editor liked my Arc Digi piece on the moral panic aspect of the CRT conversation, and asked me to write a:

    relatively short (1500-2000 words) point-by-point analysis of the problem of extremism over CRT, most notably by the Right by people like Chris Rufo (the screen shots of his tweets are perfect so use those), the problem of turning it into a moral panic, etc.

He also suggested I criticise pro-CRT extremism, citing Scientific America’s article on how the treatment of minority STEM students likely contributes to an ongoing lack of diversity, because

    the only hypothesis they entertain… is that mathematicians (and by extension most STEM professors) are racists (and mysognynists).

It’s important to note that this initial request did not simply ask for a bulletpoint debunking or a pure focus on ideas, it was a request for one explanation of the political and social aspects of the panic. Finally, he explained they were up against a deadline and asked if I could have something for him within two days, which I agreed to do.

After considering the prompt some, I felt that a focus on “extremism on both sides” would not accurately explain “the problem of turning it into a moral panic”, which I explained in an email exchange:
Email from Aaron: Hi Michael and Alex, I've been working on the piece and I wanted to touch based because I'm feeling pulled to a different framing than you suggested. There's already several pieces on CRT moral panic extremism, but not much has been said on how the panic was mainstreamed by individuals who don't identify as extremists. I feel this is a more useful framing because it prevents people from writing the panic off as just an extremists fight, rather than seeing how the talking points are taken up by centrists, liberals, etc and can impact how they address issues. In the process I'll reiterate why I think CRT is valuable and why some of the complaints against it make no sense. Does that sound okay? email from Michael Shermer: Tes, Aaron, that not only sounds okay, it sounds original, innovative, and more important for the reasons you note. I have to admit, even a social liberal guy like me, who even wrote a 500-page book on moral progress (The Moral Arc), If I read enough material from people like Rufo - who I know are gas lighting me for political reasons, I find myself drifting into the camp of dismissing CRT entirely. My guess is that there's a lot of centrist liberals who feel the same. So... go for it! Michael

I considered this a rousing endorsement for my approach, and was inspired by Shermer’s self-assessment to use his position as an illustration in the article, while making clear the criticisms apply to many individuals. I sent through a first draft of the piece, which resulted in a back and forth where Shermer asked for more examples in a way that I believe would have compromised the piece, by asking me to focus on Rufo and not discuss Shermer or Lindsay:
email from Michael Shermer: What we need here are specific examples from Rufo followed by your rebuttal/response to those examples (false, cherry picking, not CRT, etc.) And forget James Lindsay and me. Who cares what we think? Rufo is on Fox News every night talking about this stuff. He's your target. Lindsay is a nobody by comparison, and I'm quite anti-Rufo on Twitter, having gotten into a number of exchanges with him as I go after him for various things, and to say I am not a conservative would be the understatement of the year.

I responded that I was happy to add more examples, but I wasn’t willing to cut out the other material that I thought was essential to understanding how moral panics spread:
email from Aaron: I think the problem may be that we're past 101 level explainers at this point. They've been done to death. If there is one or two specific claim that I haven't already addressed concerning CRT I'll add something in. But this article includes a clear explanation of what CRT is and several examples of how y'all are wrong about it in a way that suggests a lack of serious engagement with the material. I only mention your politics when it relates to your arguments and prescriptions, but I assume as a skeptical atheist you would rightly have increased skepticism if you found out a supposed liberal was a mouthpiece for Christian nationalist conspiracism. That context can help explain why otherwise thoughtful people have gotten taken in by this moral panic. In my experience links are treated as acceptable receipts and a recognition that a 2000 word argument can't contain every important point. But if there are major points you feel need addressing here let me know what they are and I'll include them. Or have me on your show and make the arguments against CRT you find compelling and I'll rebut them.

After additional back and forth, where Shermer provided examples of the sorts of things he wanted debunked and I agreed to work in material to address his requests, I received the following:
Email from Michael Shermer: Aaron, I'm sorry to put you through all this, but stand down on this project. We found a solution in the form of a Harvard professor and colleagues who clearly outline and defend CRT. That is what we need for this issue. My editor read your first draft and concluded: "this article is pointless. We need people to engage directly on ideas. Clearly spell out concepts that they're talking about and say how they help accurately describe reality (or debunk popular ideas that don't). The 'check the reference it's there' schtick makes this not any different to a rant on social media. I haven't learned anything by reading it." I feel bad you put time into what you've written already, but as I said, you could publish this on Arc Digital or The Skeptic or some other venue and, if you like, I'd be happy to respond to your criticisms of me (although I share many of your concerns about Rufo and Lindsay), and if you want to ahve me on your podcast I can come on and discuss it. Although, again, I'm not sure anyone cares what I think about CRT.

I find the radical shift from “original, innovative, and more important” to “pointless”
disappointing, especially when I was originally asked to discuss more than just the “ideas”. I also think the demand to focus on ideas and not people comes from an information deficit debunking model that I think is out of date. Readers of Skeptic Magazine in the US have ample access to CRT explainers; what I thought they would benefit from was a way to understand why self-identifying skeptics seem caught up in a moral panic, and how to avoid that fate.

I think there’s a problem of credulous “centrist” analysis that makes everything about competing extremes, so they can feel like they’re not contributing to the problem. I would have much preferred this piece get published in Skeptic Magazine, as I believe Shermer’s readership could benefit from considering this sort of pushback. Thankfully, The Skeptic has welcomed the piece, so that readers here can decide if it’s pointless or not.
Explaining the Critical Race Moral Panic

The current CRT moral panic began in the summer of 2020, when the conservative activist Chris Rufo drew on work by James Lindsay and other self-identifying liberals to convince president Donald Trump to pass an executive order banning the use of “divisive concepts” in federal employee training. The executive order never referenced CRT, but it banned the discussion of divisive ideas commonly associated with CRT, as well as topics like “inherent sex differences”. I and many others have repeatedly cited the tweets where Rufo openly declares he’s onboard with Lindsay’s plan, which he appears to describe as conflating CRT with “the entire range of cultural constructs that are unpopular with Americans”:
Tweets from Christopher F. Rufo: "I agree with you. The activists are realizing that their ideas, once put into practice, are generating discontent. Their racial coalition is also breaking apart - Asian-Americans, in particular, are revolting against CRT, which punishes them more than any other group. We have successfully frozen their brand - "critical race theory" - into the public conversation and are steadily driving up negative perceptions. We will eventually turn it toxic, as we put all of the various cultural insanities under that brand category.
Response from Christopher F Rufo to James Lindsay, on Twitter: The goal is to have the public read something crazy in the newspaper and immediately think "critical race theory". We have decodified the term and will recodify it to annex the entire range of cultural constructions that are unpopular with Americans.

To me, and many others who have criticised Rufo, this amounts to a fancy way of saying “we’re doing an ‘everything goes’ moral panic to scare the shit out of Americans by telling them CRT is all the un-American things put together”. The result was a hugely successful moral panic that garnered credulous support from individuals like Shermer who self-identify as skeptical, moderate, and liberal, while quickly expanding to include attacks on all things progressive – including accusing pro-LGBTQ teachers of sexually grooming children.

Rufo and Lindsay have received ample attention for their fear mongering – criticism that the “Post-tribal” media ecosystem that credulously gave their moral panic a broader platform has largely escaped. Individuals like Mr. Shermer have stoked the moral panic around Critical Race Theory and other forms of “wokeness”, while nominally distancing themselves from more extreme culture war figures like Chris Rufo and James Lindsay. I’m going to focus on Shermer as a case in point, but I want to be absolutely clear that this critique applies equally to other anti-woke community leaders.
Moral Panics

A moral panic occurs when a small or nonexistent problem is blown out of proportion, often to the point of treating it as an existential threat to society. Moral panics are often driven by credulous journalism, and tend to follow similar patterns of disproportionate concern leading to unnecessary, harmful legislation. Moral panics often involve conspiracy theories that accuse a specific “they” of orchestrating the attack on society. Moral panics date back to at least the 1700s, with some arguing that a 1744 overreaction to street violence was the first documented case of a modern, journalism driven moral panic. Moral panics have heavily dominated right wing politics in America since at least the 60s, though their roots trace back to the end of slavery. Classic examples include the satanic panic, the red scare, and the lavender scare about homosexuality.

I’m always at pains to emphasise that moral panics trade on actual problems, often involving children – for example the existent issue of human trafficking which is then grotesquely distorted and exaggerated by Qanon believers. Moral panic promoters misrepresent real issues, typically to fit a desired narrative or to make the problem seem scarier. They then offer solutions that provide the same illusion of control that can drive belief in conspiracy theories like antivaxxerism.
What is Critical Race Theory?

Put very briefly, CRT is a cluster of theories explaining why racial inequality persists in predictable ways, despite the repeal of racist laws and the decrease of overt racial animus. Using concepts like ‘intersectionality’ and ‘systemic racism’, they argue that persistent inequality is the result of past and present forms of systemic injustice, including systemic racism. Systemic racism can intersect with personal racism, but it doesn’t require it, meaning that a system where no one acts with racist intent can still predictably produce harmful consequences that are distributed unevenly by race.

A classic example of systemic racism is redlining in the United States. Redlining refers to a wide range of discriminatory practices that negatively impact minority communities, most commonly involving lending opportunities like mortgages, student loans, and credit cards. The term refers to red lines drawn around neighborhoods that were seen as “high risk”, and the designation served as a legal pretext for discrimination.

While redlining was initially based in racist beliefs about financial reliability, it thrived alongside the continued violent enforcement of segregation exactly because redlining arguably counted as “race neutral”. Banks and other business were simply assessing the risk for providing services in various neighborhoods, and were reasonably concluding that low income neighborhoods were higher risk. It just happened to be the case that those neighborhoods contained the majority of the non-white residents.

Redlining’s economic rationale justified a vicious cycle where historically marginalised communities were systematically denied the resources they needed to survive, let alone make up for past injustices. The result was consistently worse economic options and outcomes for minority families, what’s now called the racial wealth gap. The 1968 Fair Housing Act was aimed at fighting redlining, though versions of the practice continue to hurt minorities.

“Digital redlining” and other well documented example of AI based systemic racism have highlighted how emerging technology provides another superficial layer of neutrality while reproducing the same discriminatory outcomes. The concern, as with classical redlining, is that “superficially neutral” AI can learn to assign risk using zip code and other proxies as an effective stand in for race, while the black box nature of these AIs can make it hard to prove they’re discriminating on the basis of race.

CRT scholarship often overlaps with other liberatory theories, including decolonialism and marxism, though these theories also have substantial disagreements. Given the overlaps between these “radical leftist positions”, it’s unsurprising that conservative moral panics about CRT and related theories have arisen multiple times since the theories were first proposed back in the 70’s.

Despite these sustained political attacks, CRT has been fruitfully applied to a wide range of fields, including education and disability studies. For example, critical pedagogy has influenced arguments for adopting culturally relevant pedagogy as a kind of asset-based alternative to the deficit approach to education. Traditional deficit models often treated struggling students, especially minority students, as the product of educationally-defective cultural backgrounds who needed to be assimilated into the supportive mainstream culture. Conversely, culturally relevant pedagogy seeks to engage with students’ diverse cultural backgrounds when thinking about curriculum and learning environments. Critical pedagogy has also influenced the important push for greater accuracy about history, including the use of systems like tracking to effectively maintain educational segregation in “desegregated” schools.
Theory vs. Practice

The CRT moral panic is a mess of legitimate and illegitimate criticisms, aimed especially at the application of CRT in DEI (diversity, equity, and inclusion) trainings, and education more broadly. Critics claim CRT reduces everything down to race, creates an ‘oppression olympics’, and rejects both liberalism and objective truth itself in favour of postmodern indoctrination. Parsing which criticisms are legitimate is significantly hampered by the deluge of misinformation from activists like Rufo, as well as genuine miscommunication about the role of CRT in education. For example, this tweet shows us the full mix of misinformation and miscommunication:
Tweet from Christopher F Rufo on August 3rd, 2022: The critical race theory activists spent a year promoting the lie that "CRT isn't in schools", but according to their recent conference, CRT is absolutely in schools and they want to expand it. They aren't "teaching truth to power" - they rejected the concept of truth years ago. The tweet is accompanied by three images. The first two are screenshots of an event "2022 CRT Summer School - Teaching Truth To Power - July 18th-22nd" from the African American Policy Forum. The final image is a screenshot from Google, reading: Critical Race Theory: "Objective truth doesn't exist". For the critical race theorist, objective truth, like merit, does not exist, at least in social science and politics. In these realms, truth is a social construct created to suit the purposes of the dominant group.

Many critics of Rufo and the attacks on CRT have indeed claimed that “CRT isn’t in schools”, but not because they’re trying to provide cover to secretly smuggle it in. As far as I can tell, most honestly believed that CRT was just a legal theory and that Rufo and Lindsay were doing exactly what Rufo said in his tweets and simply using CRT as a catch-all for “scary race education materials”. That’s why they often said some version of “it’s not in schools but it should be” or “it’s good that it’s taught at the college level but it’s too advanced for K-12”. Others meant that CRT was impacting how teachers think about their approach to teaching, but wasn’t explicitly taught as part of the curriculum. I’ve seen zero evidence – and as far as I’m aware there has been no evidence presented by anyone – that any were knowingly obscuring the role of CRT in education.

I was very lucky to be in an education program that taught about CRT during the start of the moral panic, and I could see the value of these arguments for addressing problems in education. I encouraged other supporters to argue that CRT is and should be impacting how we teach at every level and across every field of study. Unfortunately, the narrative that solidified for many was one of denial that was then debunked with tweets like this, which does in fact show a CRT in education event… albeit an event that appears aimed at combatting the CRT moral panic Rufo has driven.

The bottom right quadrant of Rufo’s moral panic puzzle is the quote from Richard Delgado, undeniably a Critical Race Theorist, expressing fairly radical skepticism about the existence of objective truth “at least in social science and politics”. Contrary to how it’s been painted by Rufo and especially Lindsay, skepticism about objective truth is not a bad thing, or particularly uncommon, especially amongst experts in many fields. People express a wide range of doubts about our ability to access “objective” truths, especially about complex and difficult to observe events like what really drives social patterns. Epistemologists throughout history have sought out viable alternatives, using terms like constructivism and pragmatism, producing ideas like “social construct” and “all models are false, some models are useful”.

Furthermore, Delgado is not the only CRT theorist, and there is open debate about theories of knowledge amongst critical theorists. Here, though, Rufo is using the quote to prove that all CRT activists do not value the concept of truth, which is why it’s so easy for them to lie and cover up their use of CRT to indoctrinate children.

Notice that it took about 500 words to thoroughly “debunk” that single Rufo tweet, which is twice as good as the theoretical average of 1,000 words per picture, but still highlights why trying to debunk this content is asymmetric warfare, and why a 2,000 word count is barely enough to get started.

How then do we calibrate our skepticism so we can decide which concerns are legitimate, and whether someone is raising a concern in good faith? Like with the problem of generalism about conspiracy theories, the best we can do for moral panics is a list of red flags, like the one Michael Hobbes has compiled, that should increase our doubt while we do our best to gather enough information to assess the details of the claims. When assessing whether someone is arguing against CRT in good faith, I do my best to see whether they’re acknowledging the legitimate responses to their criticisms and providing substantive counterarguments. It’s a red flag when someone claims to have substantial knowledge on an issue but continues to nod along to easily debunked lines of attack.

Folks like Rufo and Lindsay are easy cases for setting a baseline. It should be clear to anyone who reads their twitter feeds (at least prior to Lindsay’s recent permanent ban from Twitter) that there has been a deliberate partisan strategy to generate a moral panic around the concept of CRT, and to conflate many ordinary liberal perspectives with the topic. Similarly, it should be clear that Lindsay and others have further expanded the CRT moral panic into a more concerning “ok, groomer” queer theory moral panic, wherein even normal sex education classes are being deemed as unacceptable. Recognising these wedge strategies, as we did with intelligent design and ‘teach the controversy’ campaigns, is essential to confronting conservative activism presented as anti-woke rhetoric. Unfortunately, Shermer and other members of the US skeptical community have proven highly susceptible to these tactics.

For what it’s worth, I believe that CRT-style language can be used in a variety of harmful ways. All impactful theories carry a risk of misuse, as skeptics of quantum woo can attest. In particular, CRT-based approaches to counteracting existing power dynamics rely too much on identity-based deference politics, and so make it difficult to address when there are other issues.

I worry, in particular, about the spread of CRT-adjacent language about “alternative ways of knowing” into conspiracism and pseudoscience ecosystems. I’ve recently been writing on the Better Way antivaxxer conference, where I noticed heavy messaging around the switch from “alternative medicine” to “indigenous medicine”. I’m worried that “wokeness” will make some percentage of well-meaning social justice activists more susceptible to harmful pitches like this.

Unfortunately, anti-woke sentiments don’t appear to inoculate one against naturalism fallacies and antivaxxer conspiracism, since the conference was headlined by Bret Weinstein and Maajid Nawaz. Shermer recently interviewed Weinstein and his partner Heather Heying about their new book, but neglected to challenge them on their Covid antivaxxer conspiracism.
The Mainstreaming of a Moral Panic

Consider the question in Shermer’s original tweet. “Why won’t CRTists defend the theory?”. Taken literally, the question seems absurd. Critical Race Theory may be the most over-litigated culture war flashpoint of the past two years. Proponents of CRT have written countless explainers and defenses of CRT. I’ve personally defended it in multiple formats, and continue to teach it as part of my intro to education course. So, it’s clearly not the case that CRT advocates won’t defend the theory.

Perhaps Shermer was instead asking why CRT advocates wouldn’t agree to write a defense in his magazine. There are, of course, plenty of good reasons to not write for any given publication. CRT advocates might simply feel that enough defenses already exist, and that the widespread vilification of the topic by partisan activists like Rufo and Lindsay has made it pointless to engage further on the subject.

Or, they may have done some research and concluded, rightly in my opinion, that Shermer and his Skeptic Magazine have themselves contributed to the mainstreaming of a moral panic around CRT and “wokeness” more generally, through their uncritical promotion of the “conceptual penis” and “grievance studies” hoax papers, as well as Lindsay and Pluckrose’s Cynical Theories, which garnered substantial criticism that was then dismissed as nitpicking by the authors. Indeed, as I’ve highlighted already, the latter book was Shermer’s go-to source for what he described as a “mostly neutral” article on the history and consequences of CRT.

While Rufo has received the lion’s share of credit for inciting the CRT moral panic, Lindsay et al’s anti-woke activism served as the social and ideological springboard for the CRT moral panic, because it gave the impression that the movement grew out of concerns expressed by self-identifying heterodox liberals. Shermer even personally promoted Lindsay and Boghossian’s grievance studies appearance on Joe Rogan, an episode full of easily debunked misinformation.

Given these facts, CRT activists might reasonably conclude that it would be harmful to lend credibility to an outlet that could use it to offset further unsupported attacks. That was certainly my largest concern in deciding whether to write this piece, which was originally commissioned by Skeptic Magazine in response to my conversation with Shermer. Ultimately, I lean towards engagement, even when the chance of persuasion is likely to be low, but we don’t have remotely enough evidence to decide on the best approach to engaging with individuals and organisations that appear caught up in a moral panic.

I believe the original question was actually something of a dog whistle, aimed largely at other critics of wokeness. It served to signal that CRT advocates can’t defend the theory, and that they are too ideologically captured to admit defeat, so they instead avoid debate entirely. Douglas Murray made this accusation explicitly in his recent interview on Shermer’s podcast, around 40 minutes in. He claims it is a major red flag that CRT advocates like Kendi and DiAngelo are unwilling to engage in public debate. In the interview both men credulously repeat one of Rufo and Lindsay’s most absurd accusations: that the woke are too fragile and fanatical to risk open debate.

I don’t consider it a red flag to refuse to debate, since there is good reason to question the efficacy of such debates. However, if you do consider it such a warning sign, it’s disingenuous not to highlight that Rufo and Lindsay also routinely deride and avoid debate, to the extent of actively blocking people who attempt to engage them in good faith. Lindsay and Boghossian have claimed that social justice advocates are such “uniformly such dreadful conversationalists” that it’s pointless to engage with them, beyond learning how to counter their tactics. How could such well-poisoning be worthy of praise when it’s coming from the architects of the CRT moral panic, yet serve as a red flag when assessing CRT advocates? I think the most plausible answer is the existence of an ‘anti-woke’ in-group bias.

Shermer’s interview with Murray highlights why CRT advocates are rightly skeptical of engagement. The interview reveals the lack of serious engagement from anti-woke CRT critics, even when CRT is construed in the broad sense of “anti-racism”. Shermer and Murray treat Kendi and DiAngelo like they’re interchangeable, when they have widely different approaches. Kendi is primarily a strict-consequentialists about race, arguing that we should focus on addressing unjust outcomes and not get caught up debating intent. Conversely, DiAngelo fits more in the psychoanalysis tradition, seeking to expose psychological features that undercut racial progress. Both approaches have their strengths and weaknesses, but Murray and Shermer struggle to identify or recognise those differences, and instead fall back on complaining about how much money CRT advocates are making. Once again, there’s no consistency in their criticism, since a ‘follow the money’ critique would also involve acknowledging how Lindsay’s anti-woke business was funded and is managed by Michael O’Fallon, a Christian nationalist anti-globalist conspiracy theorist.

During their exchange over CRT, Murray and Shermer lob a series of weak objections that very clearly derive from Rufo and Lindsay’s work. One straightforward example is their claim that CRT reduces everything down to race. A key concept in CRT is intersectionality, the theory that our outcomes in life are impacted in complex ways by the overlaps between the various aspects of our identity, such as gender, class, religious affiliation, etc. If CRT truly reduced everything down to race, intersectionality would be a pointless concept. It would also contradict another common complaint, that CRT and other woke approaches set up an ‘oppression Olympics’, where the person with the most intersecting identities wins at being the most oppressed. If everything comes down to race, why would any of the other features matter? A more accurate summary of the CRT perspective is that race has had a significant and lasting impact on our society in a way that filters down into many parts of our lives, sometimes in ways that are difficult to recognise and study.

Another thoroughly debunked claim is that CRT can’t explain why certain non-white racial groups appear to be more successful than white people in a supposedly white supremacist society. This ignores significant work by Mari Matsuda and others on issues like the model minority myth, and the diverse challenges that are obscured by using such a broad category as “Asian”. Maybe Shermer and Murray don’t find those arguments compelling, but if so they ought to at least acknowledge that they exist and address the evidence supporting them. The same goes for their parroting of Thomas Sowell’s argument that black culture, not systemic racism, is causing the persistence of racial inequality. It’s disingenuous and misleading to present these ideas like they’re uncontested in the public sphere.
Renewing Skepticism Against Anti-Woke Moral Panics

The CRT moral panic has exposed how anti-woke tribalism can make one more receptive to appropriately packaged moral panic conspiracism. I’ve referenced several members of the ‘Intellectual Dark Web’ that have slid from broad skepticism about “mainstream media” and “liberal hegemony” into antivaxxer sentiment, anti-globalist conspiracism, and anti-trans conspiracism (it’s a topic I’ve covered on my podcast, including in this episode). Shermer seems, at times, to recognise the danger of Rufo and Lindsay’s slide into extremism, especially when it leads to censorship and other illiberal actions, but he and others fail to see that Murray’s “war on the west” conservatism is similarly undermined by boilerplate anti-wokeness and great replacement conspiracism. Murray has a nicer patter, and is better than Rufo and Lindsay at keeping his more extreme positions less directly stated, but his ideas and the world they would lead to are no less illiberal or “extreme”.

In his interview with Shermer, Murray insinuates that “they” are trying to make it unacceptable to praise Churchill or Jefferson, and by extension any of the good things they fought for. He leaves the scary open question as to what the nefarious end goal is for such a project. On August 6th, 2021, Murray went on Tucker Carlson’s Fox News show, where they both praised Orban’s repressive regime for its handling of immigration and speculated about a “sinister” plan to legitimise and enact regime change against any conservative government. In a December of 2020 article for The Spectator, Murray argued that China must pay Covid reparations, and engaged in what could most charitably be called conspiracism hypothesising or cheap talk skepticism about the origin of Covid as a bioweapon released to damage the US’ economy and undermine Donald Trump’s re-election bid:
Is it a conspiracy theory to believe this could have been deliberate? I wouldn't have said so, and nor do many people int he intelligence world. In 2020 China achieved one of the greatest coups in financial history. The effects of the Trump administration's trade wars against China were beginning to be felt, and by accident or design the CCP found itself in the lucky position of their main competitor's economy (like the rest of the world) having to shut down completely. As a bonus, the President, who appeared to be the only person in the world willing to take on the CCP, was taken out in the election which followed. Now, as the American public survey a political and financial mess of gigantic proportions, China is happily sailing into 2021 with increased growth.

In a more recent article for The Spectator, Murray again engaged in cheap talk skepticism about covid as a bioweapon, and signaled that he was ready to jump in on monkeypox conspiracism if that gets big enough:
Screen shot from The Spectator article: We have only just begun to come out of the wretched Covid era, and the world still seems none the wiser over whether the cause of that two-year-long misery was a bat-eating Chinese man or a perfectly innocent leak from a top-secret bioweapons lab. Who is to say? And now along comes monkeypox.

These are the kind of conspiracism and double standards that one would expect skeptics to recognise, but the anti-woke ideology seems to lead to uneven levels of charity.

Unfortunately, Rufo and Lindsay’s antics make it easy for folks like Shermer and Murray to appear moderate by comparison, while having a polite conversation where Murray declares “this is a cultural revolution” and that the people who defend and praise Mao are winning. Rufo and Lindsay may have significant influence in conservative politics, but the CRT moral panic has proven so wildly successful because self-identifying moderates laid the foundation for it and promoted it long after it was explicitly admitted as an orchestrated panic. Rufo openly tweeted his strategy in March of 2021, and Shermer was still promoting an anti-woke moral panic chart from Boghossian and Michael Shellenberger in July of 2021. I’ve written on the chart and how it shades into the same depopulation conspiracism that Lindsay started promoting when he joined up with O’Fallon.

It is possible for anti-woke folks to learn from the CRT moral panic. There’s no need to follow Lindsay and others as they move on to the “ok, groomer” queer theory moral panic. However, listening to Shermer’s recent interview with Helen Joyce, where she promotes anti-transhumanist conspiracism and claims that children are being ‘groomed into trans identities’, I’m concerned it will be difficult for some to avoid endorsing every anti-woke panic that comes along.

I sincerely believe that “wokeness” is nowhere near the top of any reasonable list of existential threats. If anything, toxic “wokeness” can be seen as an over-reaction to feeling powerless in the face of real existential threats like climate change, the rise of overt Christian Nationalism, and the GOP’s accompanying spiral into violent conspiracism.

These problems can’t be solved by attacking CRT as a religion or a communist plot to destroy “the West”. They may not be solvable at all, but if they are, it’s going to require more robust pushback against both the extremists and the “centrists” pushing these anti-woke moral panics.

What do American conservatives see in Orbán?


thehill.com
The Hill
Kim Lane Scheppele, opinion contributor
5 - 7 minutes

The Conservative Political Action Conference, known commonly as CPAC, recently met in Dallas with former President Donald Trump as the headliner. Speaking alongside Trump on the program is the U.S. conservative movement’s favorite foreign leader, Prime Minister Viktor Orbán of Hungary.

What do American conservatives see in Orbán? Why would the leader of a country the size of Indiana with a population less than New York City have such an outsized effect on the Trump-wing of the Republican Party?

Orbán is proof of concept that a proudly un-woke leader can repeatedly win elections by leading with illiberalism. Over the 12 years, Orbán has been in power — extended for four years with his reelection in April 2022 — Orbán has set off culture wars. From demonizing Hungarian-American George Soros with dog-whistled anti-Semitism to fighting immigration as a global plot to mix races to campaigning against gender fluidity and LGBTIQ equality, Orbán has been the bad boy of Europe, seemingly enjoying the discomfort of European leaders whose values he attacks. Most recently, he generated controversy by using Nazi terminology to refer to those who are not Christian Europeans as belonging to completely different species.

Behind the culture wars façade, however, lies another threat to democracy, one that CPAC’s leaders may value even more than Orbán’s anti-wokeness. Orbán has demonstrated how to translate roughly one-third support in the polls into overwhelming election triumphs by designing election rules to guarantee victory. Orbán provides proof of concept that elections are won or lost by rigging the rules at least as much as they are won or lost on actual voter support.

One of Orbán’s first acts as prime minister in 2010 was to cut the size of the Parliament in half. Halving the Parliament allowed Orbán to redraw all of the districts and create a “wild gerrymander” that ensured that his party would win the vast majority of the districts for years to come. Of course, gerrymandering was invented in the U.S., but Orbán has exploited it to extremes. 

When it looked like his power was slipping, Orbán changed the rules again so that splintered opposition parties could only win by combining forces into a single coalition against him — a strange-bedfellows assemblage that couldn’t agree on a message but that weakened each of the parties individually. When the opposition persisted anyhow, Orbán changed the rules again so that he could move his voters anywhere in the country to shore up close districts with an influx of support.

During this time, Orbán controlled the media environment so that the opposition found it nearly impossible to get its message out. In addition, Orbán understood that packing the courts blocks challenges. As the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) election observers diplomatically noted about Hungary’s April election, legal challenges to election infractions “fell short of providing effective legal remedy.”

Like Orbán, Trump can claim a little over one-third of the voters as a solid base while a party-controlled media empire blasts out his messages. Getting to a victorious plurality on election day relies on a combination of anti-majoritarian sleights of hand and training the party media on the opposition like a weapon.

The election system is very different in the U.S. than it is in Hungary, so Orbán’s innovations must be tweaked to travel. But the principle that elections can be won by clever lawyering has clearly caught on among Republicans and some of Orbán’s innovations have migrated. Republicans are already racing to rewrite the rules.

The U.S. Constitution establishes an Electoral College, which provides many opportunities for mischief as we saw in the last election when Trump’s lawyers tried to generate confusion over the choice of electors that handed President Jos Biden his victory. This confusion was manufactured by their edgy readings of the Constitution and the Electoral Count Act to favor Trump’s cause. It almost worked. 

Now, Republicans are advocating a once-fringe interpretation of the Constitution that gives to “state legislatures” the power to design federal election rules. According to the “independent state legislature theory,” neither governors nor state courts can intervene in this process.

Republicans have for years wildly gerrymandered state legislative districts to produce overwhelming Republican majorities in close-call swing states but they are less likely to control governors and courts. The new theory cuts these wild cards out of the Republican rules-writing loop. The now conservative-packed federal Supreme Court’s acceptance of this theory in a case they have agreed to decide next term will allow federal election rules to be written reliably by the party faithful, just as Orbán’s pliant parliament and packed courts allowed Orbán to design an election system that guaranteed he would never lose.

Orbán provides a formula for the permanent power of a minority party. Lead with culture wars to fire up the base. Discredit opponents through party-controlled media. Engineer the election rules by controlling their design. Orbán has demonstrated that this playbook works — and the Republicans are paying attention.     

Kim Lane Scheppele is Laurance S. Rockefeller professor of sociology and international affairs in the Princeton School of Public and International Affairs and the University Center for Human Values.

Saturday, August 13, 2022

Dog days of mailbag

Dog days of mailbag

Matthew Yglesias — Read time: 24 minutes


Dog days of mailbag

Facebook, vacation, workhorses, and adversarial legalism


I am really not a fan of August weather in general and wish the Inflation Reduction Act had a provision to make this level of heat and humidity illegal.


But until then…


Melinda Crawford: Can you please go on Bill Maher and promote your book? Maher has a lot of interesting ideas but he is completely obtuse when it comes to all things regarding families and children (which is like, the most important issue for most other Americans, i imagine)


I promise you that I am not turning down invitations to go on television and promote my book! It’s all a question of which guests Bill Maher wants to have.


Laurie Clark-Michalek: Hey Matt, I work for FB. I have a few reasons for working there, mostly that my coworkers are great, and the problems are interesting, and the pay is better than you find elsewhere. But beyond those selfish reasons, I do also believe that letting people talk to each other is probably good, and effective advertising is better for the world than ineffective advertising.


You really don't like Facebook. What would Facebook-but-good look like to you?


I want to try to be clear about this: I don’t have any particular dislike of Facebook, but I think that Facebook is pretty trivial compared to some of the things happening in the technology world.


To give an example, I personally like tortilla chips a lot. But if I heard that a really smart, hard-working, and talented friend was going to work for Tostitos to try to help sell more tortilla chips, I’d think that was kind of sad. Because we know it’s actually pretty bad for you to eat lots of highly processed snacks, even if the snacks in question are delicious. If that person told me the reason he wants to dedicate his life to getting more people to eat more Tostitos is that the pay is good, the colleagues are fun, and the work is interesting, I would sympathize — those sound like good self-interested reasons to work in the chips industry. But the fundamental reality is that if someone told you one of their goals for the coming year was to eat less fresh food and more tortilla chips, you’d think that sounded like a pretty bad idea. So if you spend your life working on the problem of how to get people to consume more tortilla chips, you’re dedicating your life to something that’s not great.


I always feel torn about the Facebook question, because the company is subject to a lot of criticism that I think is over the top and unwarranted. But it’s still true that if someone said, “I’m planning to do marginally less sleep, exercise, socializing, housework, cooking, and hobbies next year and more time scrolling on Insta,” you’d think that person was mapping out a bad plan for her life. I think there are a lot of tech companies that are doing more worthwhile stuff.


Sam S: Should the US or state governments mandate employers provide a minimum amount of vacation time, and if so, how much? 2 weeks like is mandated in Canada (and many US jobs already give), or 4-5+ weeks like in Australia, New Zealand, and Europe?


Why hasn't a single deep blue state enacted such legislation, or even come close to it? Compared to a lot of other reforms the left is discussing, I would think it'd be a relatively straightforward and popular thing to do.


Rather than minimum vacation time, as I wrote on Juneteenth I’d like to see more effort on creating federal holidays and deploying policy levers to maximize the number of people who get those days as days off. A vacation mandate is basically a straight trade of more time off for less money. Holidays, by contrast, help solve an important coordination problem — it’s much more fun to have the day off work when other people you know also have the day off. And really only the government can solve that.


Doug B: A few years ago, I sat next to an English partner of mine who had participated in some conference with “Chatham House Rules” (what you say behind closed doors is sacrosanct and won’t be divulged). He sat next to Ted Cruz and came away with the view that Cruz was the most personally repugnant person he’d ever met, and not based just on the substance of what he said. My point is, everyone who has met Ted Cruz, senators, college roommates, etc., with the possible exception of his wife and mother, thinks he is a tremendous asshole personally. Even Donald Trump, I’ve heard, can be (or used to be) charming in certain settings. My point/question is, how does a person who no one appears to like at all carve out a successful political career? Don’t you need supporters, mentors, donors to like or at least admire you? Who exists like that for Cruz, who has done nothing but exhibit raw ambition succeed as a politician to the extent Cruz has? Are there others with no charm or appealing characteristics who have been as successful as him?


I was once on an airplane with Ted Cruz and as we deplaned, you could see he’d left a pile of McDonald’s garbage in his seat. Bad guy!


But he’s also an example of modern, media-focused politics. U.S. Senator was his first elected office, and he got it by beating the Lieutenant Governor of Texas in a primary based on support from out-of-state celebrities like Sarah Palin and Ron Paul, plus money from the Club for Growth. Texas is a gigantic state, both in terms of its population and its size, so presence in the media matters a lot more than retail politics. And for figures like Palin and Paul, backing Cruz was about larger intra-party factional disputes rather than personal affection for Cruz. He’s consistently underperformed as a general election candidate, but Texas is conservative enough that a sub-par conservative politician can keep winning there.


JM: What's your take on youth sports and its impact on broader culture? Compared to when I played youth/high school sports in the 80s/90s, I find that for kids under 8 years old, it's pretty much the same — lots of casual, open-participation leagues. But the specialization and cost starting around age 9 seems to have gotten really out of control. Thousands of dollars for U-10 travel teams in minor sports? And compared to my youth, where kids of all abilities would play together until around age 12 at least, now there seems to be two separate tracks — competitive and casual — leading to significant drop-offs in participation starting around age 10 as the “talented” kids get siphoned off into club teams. I can't imagine this is healthy long-term for sports participation (or professional sports viewership).


I haven’t done a deep dive on this, but the impression I’ve gotten from some of Robert Putnam’s work, reinforced by some of the latest from Raj Chetty and his team on cross-class friendships, is that the rise of travel sports teams is really bad for society.


It both, as you say, seems to reduce the total number of kids who play sports (a good fun and healthy thing to do) but also contributes to social balkanization even in towns or neighborhoods that have reasonable levels of economic integration. Now obviously sorting kids at a young age into highly specialized and relatively resource-intensive sports can have some benefits for cultivating athletic excellence. But that’s ultimately a lot less important for the future of the country than cultivating a broadly fit and active population in which kids have friendships across class lines and parents interact on the sidelines with people they wouldn’t meet through work.


Arthur Bahr: Welcome back from Italy! As a medievalist who loves physical evidence of the past but who also believes in building more homes (I did my PhD at Cal and saw first-hand the suffering NIMBYism can cause), I've always wondered if and how you build historical preservation into your YIMBY vision. I imagine (though I might be wrong, which would be interesting!) that you don't think cities like Rome and Paris should allow their ancient and medieval sites to be developed into housing blocks. So unless you *do* think that, which would make me sad, there has to be some form of historical preservation regime you're okay with. Where and how do you draw that line?


I mostly write about the United States and the U.S. historic preservation regime, which I think is really bad and generates incredibly high costs and almost no benefits.


I do not think that logic applies to Paris or Florence or other European cities that clearly have enormous tourism industries that are driven in large part by the preservation of the historic built environment. Then in Rome and some other places, you have the question of priceless ruins. Long story short, I think in these cities the balance of costs and benefits is clearly different from in Washington, D.C., and the case for preservation measures is strong. Something I did say about Italy is that they do not seem to interpret preservation to mean “new things that are adjacent to old things should be made to look like they are old.” This is a weird idea that is very prominent in American planning but actually has nothing to do with the case for preserving genuine old things.


But in America, none of the stuff we are preserving is particularly old. And beyond that, nobody is coming to D.C. because they want to see the 1880s rowhouses of the Logan Circle Historic District. It just doesn’t play that kind of role in our culture, our society, and our economy. Now if we got to a point where 19th-century rowhouse neighborhoods were becoming genuinely scarce due to redevelopment, it might make sense to flip the preservation switch back on. But that’s not the current situation.


Chris Brandow: What does matt think about the longtermism aspect of EA? To me it seems very vulnerable to the future being hard to predict. The recent Vox article on EA makes me think that in part it is being artificially inflated on the agenda due to excess of $$ in the space. It also seems like another way for liberal, college grads to become further out of touch with normal concerns.


I want to write about this at greater length, but I’m struck recently that the main “longtermist” causes aren’t actually very long-term at all. The main people I’ve read on AI risk, for example, think we more likely than not will have transformative AI within the next 30 years. Now maybe you think that’s wrong. But if it’s right, then the case for worrying about the direction of its development doesn’t depend at all on short-term vs. long-term considerations. In fact the main reason you might want to prioritize AI risk over global public health and economic development is precisely that bringing prosperity to Africa and South Asia is necessarily a long-term project, and the AI safety community doesn’t think we have that much time to waste.


So while I think the prioritization debate is interesting, to me it’s not accurate to see it as a debate about long-term vs near-term thinking.


David Abbott: You’ve begun throwing shade at “adversarial legalism” in recent posts. What is the alternative within a presidential system? If the British House of Commons thinks a minister is not following its laws, it can deny confidence and/or supply. In our system, doesn’t Congress need the federal courts to make executive officers follow laws they don’t like? Aren’t we basically stuck picking some point on a spectrum running from complete executive lawless to mindnumbing adversarial legalism?


Adversarial legalism isn’t about presidential vs. parliamentary systems, it’s largely about the English-speaking legal tradition versus the continental/Napoleonic one.


It is probably true that interbranch conflict within the federal government plays some role in propagating support for the adversarial approach, and it may have some benefits or justification here. But I think it’s more worth considering in the context of federalism. If Congress authorizes a program for the Department of Transportation to make grants to cities to experiment with congestion pricing, and the Secretary of Transportation thinks New York City has a plan endorsed by the mayor and blessed by the state legislature, then does it make sense to have a supplemental round of environmental review in order to ward off NEPA litigation? I don’t think it makes sense. And I definitely don’t think that the right way to characterize the situation is legislatures checking out-of-control executives.


The issue is that the thesis of NEPA is “requiring lots of environmental review before changes happen will be good for the environment.” That partakes of a larger culture of adversarial legalism which holds that, in general, having contentious lawsuits about everything is the best way to arrive at the truth. The reality, though, is that requiring contentious lawsuits before anything can change is a heavy thumb on the scale of the status quo.


Ben Mitchell: Who are the people in Congress, including their staff, who you think do the best job at rigorous policy analysis and legislating? I know there are always many hands involved, including lobbyists, think tanks, etc., but I'm curious who you think are the true “workhorses” in Congress?


No piece of legislation is ever one senator’s work, but the Inflation Reduction Act fundamentally represents years of hard work by Ron Wyden and his team. Now to be fair to all the non-Wyden senators, part of the reason for this is that Wyden is great, but the other part of the reason is that in the modern structure of Congress, chairing the Senate Finance Committee is a much, much more important job than any other role in terms of “workhorse” legislating. So it’s not like, I dunno, Debbie Stabenow or Cory Booker screwed up — they didn’t have the opportunity to shape major legislation in a substantive way. But Wyden did have the opportunity and he seized it.


THPacis: A day before your Monkeypox post the NYT published a long article that seems to me even more damning. It suggests US health agencies dropped the ball on monkeypox response not once but repeatedly, in multiple different ways, and over two months. The mistakes are frustratingly similar to those of the COVID response and suggest public health agencies seemingly chronically unable to perceive urgency or act upon it appropriately. Would you agree with this assessment ? If so, what do you think is the source of the problem? Underfunding ? Bad/outdated structures? Career bureaucrats who are frankly not good enough at their jobs? Presumably it can’t all be on elected officials and political appointees since we’ve now seen ample evidence for failure under both Trump and Biden admins?


In short, what can be done so these mistakes aren’t repeated again for the next disease that may well be far worse?


At a very high level, here’s what I think the issue is. The CDC originated as an adjunct to the United States military, which during World War II was using a lot of bases in parts of the American South where malaria was endemic. The generals wanted to safeguard their troops from malaria, so they created the CDC — that’s why it’s in Atlanta. There were obviously medical doctors and biologists involved in this effort at high levels.


But they were involved in the same sense that physicists were involved in the Manhattan Project — it was fundamentally an operational military project whose purpose was to do things.


If you watch depictions of the CDC in movies, that’s what you always see. The CDC is springing into action and making stuff happen in the real world. But the actual CDC over the decades seems to have evolved into a mostly academic-type institution that has funding silos for various things and publishes papers on different topics. It’s like the kind of institution that the original CDC would hire scientists away from because they needed knowledgeable infectious disease experts and mosquito scientists in order to run their malaria eradication op. But what we no longer have is an operational institution that does things.


Ezra: What will Milan get out of college that he couldn’t get from spending four years in New Haven coffee shops? And to what extent does your answer support the “human capital” model of education versus the signaling model?


I can’t really be objective about Yale, so I thought I’d let Milan answer for himself and he says:


This is all speculation because at the time of writing I have not yet started school, but I think there are two main things I'll get out of going to Yale that I wouldn't just by hanging out in Atticus for 4 years. The obvious one is the social aspect of college — I'll be living in a dorm surrounded a bunch of other kids my age rather than living in an apartment in New Haven by myself. I'm a pretty social guy and frankly after a (very fun) year of mostly living at home with my family I think I'll have a lot of fun and hopefully make some good friends. But the other thing is rigor and structure. If I was sitting in a coffee shop by myself all day I'd mostly be reading about things that already pique my interests; at Yale I'll be forced (in a good way) to expand my horizons. As an example, I've signed up to take Directed Studies in my freshman year, which is basically a Great Books program. If I wasn't in DS, I probably wouldn't read and take notes on books like “The Iliad” or Plato on my own time. And I probably wouldn't have people to discuss the particular things I'm reading with if I was hanging around a coffee shop full-time. I happened to attend a get-to-know-each-other/Q&A Zoom for incoming DS students on Monday night and people were talking about how the book of Exodus illustrates some concepts about nation-building and national identity — that's something I definitely didn't think of when I read it over the summer!


On a more personal level, attending a top school was a dream of mine since the 5th grade, so it's wonderful to achieve that and I like to think my parents are proud of me, etc. And I got a free Class of 2026 t-shirt which is nice.


Tracy Erin: Isn't it time for the progressive pundit class to zero in on one or two likely Democratic presidential nominees and start talking about their accomplishments and getting them more media visibility? Before Amy Klobuchar ran she spent a lot of time going on cable news and NPR and she was top of my hypothetical list for 2020 (until those stories about how she was a mean boss which it seemed very hard for anyone to overcome, but especially a woman because women are harder on other women) but I only knew about the Senator from Minnesota because she was getting booked on national radio and tv. I am fine with picking a purple state Governor as the 2024 nominee, but it seems like it will soon be time to start getting a couple of those folks more airtime nationally so people can gauge if they like them. Gretchen Whitmer seems the most promising to me of the folks you tend to mention because Roy Cooper seems dull and Jared Polis a little too quirky and so I guess I am asking what it takes to start getting her more attention nationally so that we are not stuck with the 2020 field, none of whom seemed well positioned to win the Electoral College vote.


I think it probably is! I will look into it. But it’s also time for the base to temper their expectations. Part of the edge that back-bench members of Congress tend to have is that Elizabeth Warren can assert that she would make “big structural change” while Gretchen Whitmer is stuck with the dreary reality of actually governing, where you tout stuff like zero-tuition community college programs in Grand Rapids.


Justin: I hear a lot that “inflation” for political purposes is synonymous with “gas prices.” Electric car adoption is accelerating. When do you think this trend will cause significant changes to the attitudes and behavior of in US voters and political leaders? And what do you think those changes will be? Of course “fewer short-term voter freak-outs when oil prices go up,” but what are less obvious changes we're likely to see in US politics as more people fill up with a wire instead of a pump?


The main thing is that electricity prices are likely to become a much bigger deal — especially if we electrify everything and have a renewables-heavy grid, the new backlash moment will be when a period of unexpectedly low wind leads to electricity price spikes to try to keep supply and demand in balance.


Sam Jacobson: You recently visited Baltimore’s Inner Harbor. What development/growth ideas do you have for what I would call “satellite” cities… i.e. smaller cities that orbit larger ones (Baltimore - DC, Milwaukee - Chicago, etc.)?


I don’t know anything about Milwaukee, but I’ve written before about the infrastructure investments and operational reforms that would help knit D.C. and Baltimore together better.


Sarah: You talk a lot about how housing abundance creates enormous surplus, which can be shared in a way to make everyone better off. Practically speaking, how can we make this work for the people who currently rent units that should be torn down and replaced with bigger buildings? In theory it is doable with "Pareto improvement" magic, but I'm not sure how, and I have well-meaning friends whose concern for displaced renters takes them in NIMBY directions...


I think it’s important to be clear that preventing teardowns doesn’t prevent tenant displacement — tenants get displaced for the purpose of condo conversions all the time. But I think a smart strategy is to pair more market-rate development with more funding for rental assistance programs like Section 8 vouchers.


M Bartley: How well do you think this post has aged? I remembered reading it when it was released and being heartened by the conclusions, but as a layman, I have recently grown more worried that the fed will need to provoke a real painful recession a La Volcker in the 80s or Greenspan in the 90s to tame inflation. Am I wrong to think that? Has your view on the hydraulic vs expectations theories of interest rate rises changed at all?


I wonder myself. I think the people whose recent inflation commentary has been most insightful are mostly partisans of hydraulic theory and that is nudging me in their direction relative to what I used to think. It also seems to me that the income —> rent mechanism has become fairly prominent in inflation and may require a hydraulic solution. At the same time, five-year breakevens have been falling since March without any big rise in unemployment or even a slowdown in hiring.


The fact that so far the pace of job growth hasn’t slowed at all makes me think it’s premature to throw in the towel on the possibility of a soft landing — we haven’t seen so much as one month of sluggish hiring to evaluate what the impact of that would be, so how sure are we that we’d need a painful recession?


Dave Coffin: I was just listening to Josh Barro's podcast with Adam Ozimek on the impact of remote work on housing. Do you think remote workers moving to low density, affordable property areas poses a new challenge to densifying urban areas? How do you think urban planning plays out in world where home buying is increasingly decoupled from the geography of available jobs?


I don’t think “densifying” should be a policy goal — allowing density should be. I think people should be allowed to build apartments wherever they think there is demand for them. If there’s no demand, then nobody will build, but there’s no reason to make it illegal to build them.


But broadly speaking, I think a big shock to people’s location decisions makes flexible zoning more important, not less. The biggest reason is that remote workers are wanting larger homes so that they can have home offices and such. It’s possible to interpret that as “well, because people want home offices, they want to move to the exurbs where there are large newly-built dwellings.” But it’s possible to construct large dwellings in urban cores and inner-ring suburbs, you’d just need to make it legal to do so. The other is that I think we may see a lot of people wanting to move to leisure destinations — places near beaches, mountains, ski slopes, pretty lakes, etc. — that don’t currently have a lot of housing supply, and we need to make it possible to add units there.


Brian T: There was recently an article in the Atlantic about noise, and the divergence between working class and middle class values on the subject.


What are your thoughts on this as it relates to YIMBYism and urbanism? I'm definitely on Team Quiet myself, but I do admit that there's a real tension here.


The author and I both grew up in New York at around the same time and then went to Ivy League colleges at around the same time, and I experienced essentially the exact same noise norms shift that she describes. Since I grew up in comfortable economic circumstances going to private schools in NYC, I think she’s actually injecting a class element into this that doesn’t exist.


What happened to both of us in college isn’t that we met rich kids, it’s that we met kids who grew up in the suburbs. Then after college, a lot of suburban-raised kids ended up moving to cities. And I think there’s just no denying that cities are louder than the suburbs. Personally, I find it hard to sleep when it’s too quiet — I’m used to noise and I find silence unnerving. But other people have different experiences. This strikes me as an area where it’s probably best not to overthink things too much.


Eric Kumbier: Tyler Cowen posted a partially formed critique of the IRA yesterday. He claimed the minimum corporate tax is basically a tax on investment (since that's what companies write off/deduct) and that some of the buy American provisions are problematic (no current EVs qualify for the tax break because they don't have enough American parts).


He expressed uncertainty about the act and outright skepticism that it would reduce inflation. To me, the biggest benefit of the act is its climate investments, and the biggest problem is that it adds complexity to the tax code rather than eliminating loopholes. By now, I know loosely what's in the bill. What is the likelihood that the bill will do what it claims: reduce inflation and the deficit and spur a massive wave of climate investment and emissions reductions? You've been a huge cheerleader for it, but do you have any doubts?


I mean just between us, I think we can all admit that the Inflation Reduction Act is not optimal inflation-reducing legislation. It’s primarily a bill designed to promote the production of zero-carbon energy that’s then structured so as to be anti-inflationary in its aggregate impact. And I think it clearly will promote the production of zero-carbon energy and it will, at the margin, have an anti-inflationary impact. So I think that’s good.


In terms of Tyler’s take, while I accept the logic of the view that it’s better to tax consumption than to tax investment, I just don’t buy into the idea that taxing investment is really bad. If I did, I would be a conservative like he is. But I don’t. I also think that, frankly, he always holds Democratic bills to a super-high standard of technocratic rigor while setting a much lower bar for Republican ones — to be generous, he maybe does that to counteract what he sees as a prevailing left bias of econ Twitter.


But to me, taxing investment with one hand while subsidizing investment with another is pretty good, especially paired with deficit reduction and permitting reforms. What I do think is true is that the total impact of the bill is going to hinge a lot on what ultimately comes of those permitting reforms. There’s a school of thought on the left that sees this as a painful concession made to secure Manchin’s vote, but I think clean energy badly needs permitting reform on the merits, so following through on this is going to be very important.


J Willard Gibbs: Any response to the investigation into the lab leak hypothesis? Angie Rasmussen twitter thread here:


I’m largely where I have been on this — do you think it’s an implausibly weird coincidence that a lab leaked virus would have experienced its first major spread at an animal market or do you think it’s an implausibly weird coincidence that a zoonotic viral crossover would have happened in a city that had a major virology lab? To an extent, we’re just volleying back and forth at each other based on our priors. The evidence in that paper is clearly consistent with a zoonotic hypothesis, but they don’t have specific evidence of a source animal.


Stephen: Matt's original hometown of NYC is holding primary elections soon, and redistricting has given new yorkers multiple competitive districts- particularly interesting are the 12th (Nadler/Maloney/Patel) and the 10th (no incumbent running, open field). I'm hoping for your help in deciding who to support. Any endorsements or thoughts on these races?


I grew up as a Nadler constituent in what’s now NY-10. Unfortunately, I don’t really have a strong recommendation as to who is best in the NY-10 field. But if you’re uptown in the NY-12 zone, I really think you should give Patel a try. The differences between Nadler and Maloney are just not significant enough to make it worth your time to worry about spoiling, and Patel is a fresh face and a fresh voice that would be a real asset to Congress in terms of thinking seriously about abundance and a progressive supply-side agenda.


Doug Orleans: For All Mankind takes place in an alternate timeline where Gary Hart was president (1984-1992). What do you think would have been the significant achievements of a Hart administration?


It’s worth understanding that 80s/90s politics had a rightward trajectory throughout the western world, including in countries like France and New Zealand where center-left parties were in power or in a place like the United States where Bill Clinton won in 1992 but governed largely within a consensus defined by Reaganism. So I’m sure a Hart administration would have done stuff, but I wouldn’t anticipate any big progressive wins. The main thing is the course of Supreme Court history would have gone very differently, with President Hart replacing Thurgood Marshall rather than Clarence Thomas taking his seat.


Vishal: I'm surprised you're open about your favorite bands (and other culture / taste preferences). Would it bother you if Emily Haines went on Twitter and made clear she was one of your legions of haters? (No idea where she stands on anything, but using that example as you've talked about Metric a bunch recently.)


Well, she last tweeted in June 2018 so I think it’s pretty unlikely that she’s going to do that.


My whole thing about politics is that everyone needs to be more normie, more least common denominator, and less expressive. That’s basically the opposite of what you want in art, so I would never be surprised to learn that a great artist’s instincts about politics run in the other direction.

Not Everything Is a ‘Grift’

Not Everything Is a ‘Grift’

&c by Jonathan Chait 

There is a strain of crude materialism on the socialistic left that attributes any disagreement with its position to personal corruption. That style of thought was exposed badly by Joe Manchin’s decision to support a major climate bill.


I don’t have any problem with raising red flags about Manchin’s financial entanglements in the coal industry, which pose a legitimate ethical concern. My problem is with the thought system that imagined his interest in the coal industry supplied the entire motivation for his behavior. The progressive media has been filled with stories like “Did Joe Manchin block climate action to benefit his financial interests?” and “The real reason Joe Manchin is sabotaging the U.S. clean energy plan.”


“Manchin is best understood as a grifter from the ancestral home of King Coal,” claimed Rolling Stone. “He is a man with coal dust in his veins who has used his political skills to enrich himself, not the people of his state.” A Sunrise Movement activist who organized protests against Manchin called him the “final villain.”


If Manchin’s primary motive was to enrich himself by protecting the coal industry, then he could have simply killed the bill immediately by announcing he would not support any partisan legislation. Alternatively, he could have supported the social spending elements while insisting it remove its clean energy subsidies. Instead, Manchin did the opposite. He vetoed nearly all the social spending measures in the bill — which he has no personal financial incentive to do — while supporting a fairly robust array of green energy subsidies.


Whatever your position is on the merits, or whether you agree with Manchin’s negotiating method (I personally was not a fan), it simply does not comport with the idea that he was motivated by greed. Indeed, the coal industry is “shocked and disheartened” by the law Manchin helped to craft.


Human motivation is complex. Corruption is one of the factors motivating people’s political view, but the left is massively over-indexed on the belief that everybody who disagrees with its position on anything is engaged in a “grift.”



One example of the above tendency I have highlighted is the conviction on the left that charter schools are a “grift.” The only motive anybody can possibly have to support them must be a hidden profit motive, not a genuine belief they can improve educational outcomes for underprivileged children. (Hence the annoying obsession with my wife’s work at a nonprofit institution that works with both traditional and charter public schools and does not advocate for education reform.)


What people outside a narrow class of specialists don’t grasp is that research shows a pronounced upward trend in the effectiveness of charter schools at improving education outcomes for urban children. Another recent example comes from a new series of three studies by Credo, in Denver, Memphis, and Baton Rouge. All three cities have found charter schools boost school performance. (And no, they are not doing it by “skimming” the most motivated students — studies are also finding that charter schools improve overall performance by the entire states and districts that introduce charters.)


Credo is notable because it found in 2009 that charter schools on the whole perform no better than traditional public schools. This finding became famous, and is continuously cited to this day to “prove” charters don’t work. But the director of Credo told me it’s badly out of date, and new studies continue to show the sector is developing scalable models that yield important benefits for urban children.


The people who keep repeating charter schools are a “grift” may not be grifters. They’re just ideologues. And they’re wrong.



One of the aspects of the Inflation Reduction Act that progressives don’t uniformly love is a side deal to reform permitting standards. Manchin demanded a promise to support a bill to make it easier to green-light energy projects. This will make it easier to build green energy infrastructure, but also fossil-fuel infrastructure.


The catch is that because this isn’t a fiscal policy change, and the IRA was enacted through a rules procedure that only allows changes to taxes and spending levels, it requires a separate vote. Republicans ought to be in favor of this, given their passion for deregulation. However, the Journal reports that there’s a snag. “Though many Republicans have long supported streamlining permits to reduce bureaucratic delays to new energy projects, party leaders are upset over the tax-and-climate bill it is linked to, which raises some corporate taxes and allots nearly $370 billion to address climate change.”


They’re upset. These are paid elected officials refusing to adopt a policy they believe would help the country, because it hurt their feelings.


Lindsey Graham tried to rationalize this position in a press conference, claiming, “I will not vote for a continuing resolution that’s part of a political payback scheme.” A “political payback scheme” is another way of saying that Manchin crafted a deal to package regulatory reforms with subsidies. That isn’t a scandal. It’s how legislation is supposed to work.


Now, as I argued in my last edition of &c, I think the way to understand this position is that Republicans see progressive taxation not just as bad policy but as a moral violation. This explains why they are lashing out in retaliation, and treating anything even touching the IRA as the fruits of a poisoned tree. I don’t see how this worldview can be seen as anything other than pathological.



Casey DeSantis, who is reportedly a close adviser to and partner with her husband Ron’s political career, has an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal touting Florida’s anti-poverty program. This line stood out: “Since 1964, when President Lyndon Johnson announced his ‘War on Poverty,’ more than $23 trillion has been spent on federal and state anti-poverty programs, with no meaningful improvement in poverty rates.”


This is completely false. There are several different ways to define the poverty rate, but by every single one of them, the rate has fallen since the War on Poverty began. The traditional measure of poverty shows the rate has fallen by 4 percentage points. But the traditional poverty rate does not measure non-cash benefits, like free school lunch and access to health care, so measures incorporating a broader and more accurate suite of metrics reveal and even deeper decline in poverty.


Ronald Reagan used to say “poverty won” the war on poverty, and generations of conservatives have taken this quip as a literal truth. Casey DeSantis’s empirically false belief is a reflection of her orthodox conservative thinking on social spending. If you’re looking for a Republican who will advance creative poverty solutions that go beyond Zombie Reaganism, DeSantis probably won’t be supplying them.



There was a throwaway line in Matt Yglesias’s newsletter that I think deserves more attention. “The ACA exchanges,” he wrote, “despite their flaws, are one of the main reasons I’m able to do this job.”


The Affordable Care Act had several goals. One of them was to regulate a market for individual health insurance policies that was so broken by adverse selection it was unusable for anybody who wasn’t young and completely healthy (and even for them, it often had shocking costs if they did get sick.)


Advocates of Obamacare believed this reform would not only have humanitarian benefits, but also social and economic ones. People who had been forced to work at a job that had employer-provided insurance (which, in the pre-ACA world, was the only way for working people to avoid adverse selection) would be freed to go into business for themselves if they wanted.


Nancy Pelosi said, “We see it as an entrepreneurial bill, a bill that says to someone, if you want to be creative and be a musician or whatever, you can leave your work, focus on your talent, your skill, your passion, your aspirations because you will have health care. You won’t have to be job locked.”


Conservatives endlessly mocked and distorted this statement to make it sound like Pelosi was promising people they could quit their jobs and become lazy moochers. “Able-bodied people can quit their jobs, safe in the knowledge that the suckers working man will foot the bill for any health care they may need,” sneered Michael Cannon, a libertarian opponent of universal health care.


Of course that isn’t what Pelosi meant at all when she said the bill would enable people to be “entrepreneurial.” Yglesias is a good example of this. The broken individual health insurance market before Obamacare created economic inefficiencies by forcing workers into employment arrangements that did not optimize their talents. Obamacare has made the market work better. It’s an effect that isn’t widely noted, but it’s a pretty big deal.



Learn more about RevenueStripe...

MORE FROM JONATHAN CHAIT

 

 

Stay informed about business, politics, technology, and where they intersect. Subscribe now for unlimited access to Intelligencer and everything New York.

Thursday, August 11, 2022

There's no need to exaggerate Biden's legislative achievements


www.slowboring.com
There's no need to exaggerate Biden's legislative achievements
Matthew Yglesias
12 - 15 minutes

People like to amp themselves up after a win, so it’s not that surprising to me that with Joe Biden notching a couple of bipartisan legislative wins this month along with the Inflation Reduction Act, his once dead-in-the-water presidency is now being hailed in some quarters as the Second Coming of Lyndon B. Johnson.

I want to push back against this puffery for a couple of reasons.

One is that I think it’s factually wrong. Biden is getting some good things done for the country, but his policymaking record is not equal to that of Ronald Reagan or Barack Obama.

The other is that wishful thinking in this regard is going to teach people the wrong lessons. Comparing Biden’s legislative achievements to Obama’s, I think you can make a strong case for Biden once you adjust for the degree of difficulty. But in absolute terms, it’s just not possible to do as much with narrow majorities as with landslide wins. And it’s important to remember that and to continue trying to win big.

But also, I think this kind of progressives-psyching-themselves-up is politically counterproductive. Relatively few people self-identify as progressive or share the commonly-heard-online criticism that Democrats are insufficiently left-wing or don’t do enough stuff. Joe Biden’s falling approval ratings were driven by things like harsh coverage of his Afghanistan policy, rising commodity prices turning real income growth negative, and the fact that instead of “beating the virus,” his team managed to disappoint Covid hawks while annoying Covid doves. Responding to a big win on reconciliation by running around telling the country that Biden is doing sweeping policy change isn’t going to help — it’s far better to describe these changes as modest, common-sense reforms.

It’s also important to move away from high-profile discussions of climate change and toward a laser-like focus on doing everything possible to improve the supply side of the economy.

I’m not sure that Joe Biden has actually healed the soul of America. But he’s absolutely shown that many of us over-learned the lessons of the Obama administration and it’s still perfectly possible for Congress to function in a bipartisan way.

That’s the story of the infrastructure bill, the burn pits funding bill, the CHIPS and Science Act, and much more. We even got a gun control bill out of this Congress. It’s a really small-bore gun control bill that nobody thinks is going to make a serious dent in the problem because Republicans are very skeptical of gun regulation. The controversial aspects of the Endless Frontier Act were ditched, so the less controversial ones got done. CHIPS and Science is good, but it’s a huge retrenchment of ambition relative to what had been a bipartisan bill all along. Here, it’s the opposite of the gun control problem: some Republicans wanted to do a genuinely big science funding overhaul, but though the White House was supportive, they weren’t willing to burn political capital, and the path of least resistance in Congress was to reduce the ambition.

And I’m happy to see veterans get health care funding. But even though it’s in everyone’s interests to make a big deal about it, the burns pits bill is ultimately pretty minor legislation.

The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act is a much bigger deal, in terms of dollars spent and lives impacted. But I don’t think this is something we’re going to see discussed extensively in the history books of the future.

What’s significant about all this in terms of Biden’s promises and legacy is that it comports roughly with a normal person’s sense of how Washington ought to work. A weird dynamic persisted for years with a cross-party consensus on boosting infrastructure spending, but it kept not happening as the parties quibbled over fiscal offsets. Under Biden, they got a deal done, paying for it mostly with smoke and mirrors.

This all amounts less to a historic bout of policymaking than to a historic vibe shift, one that owes at least as much to decisions made by Senate Republicans as to Biden personally.

But I think it does turn out to be true that Biden understands the Senate and the legislative process very well, and grasps that less is more. Obama liked to argue both sides of an issue, conclude that he understood what the conservative position on it was, incorporate that into his proposal, and then proclaim that Republicans “should” like the Affordable Care Act because it reduced the deficit and slowed the growth of Medicare’s unit costs. Biden has done better at letting Republicans speak for themselves and make the deals they actually want to make (an infrastructure bill with fake pay-fors) rather than the ones that theoretically comport with their ideology.

Still, the fact is that Obama swept in with huge majorities and passed a lot of laws.

Even though Biden has played a difficult hand skillfully, I just don’t think you can get around the fact that more gets done with a better hand.

The Affordable Care Act was a bigger, more impactful bill than the IRA. And that’s true even though the ACA in many ways fell short of its authors’ biggest hopes. But Medicaid expansion brought health insurance to millions of people. The ACA exchanges, despite their flaws, are one of the main reasons I’m able to do this job. The insurance market reforms have made life better and more comfortable for millions of people. The health care cost curve did bend in accordance with Obama’s plans. They closed the “donut hole” in Medicare Part D coverage and made prescription drugs cheaper for almost every senior citizen in America.

The ACA was such a big bill that it contained a sweeping overhaul of the student loan industry as an afterthought. Obama’s stimulus bill contained tens of billions of dollars in clean energy subsidies that jump-started the American renewable energy industry. Mitt Romney famously accused the stimulus legislation of propping up “loser” companies like Tesla, now one of the most successful businesses in the world. And of course the Obama administration enacted a major overhaul of the financial regulatory system.

Most importantly, though, he had a ton of wins on the scale of the burn pits bill — stuff people talked about a lot at the time but that aren’t discussed much today. Here’s a list:

    Repealing Don’t Ask Don’t Tell, allowing gay and lesbian service members to work openly in the military

    The Matthew Shepard Hate Crimes Prevention Act

    The Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act

    An S-CHIP re-authorization and expansion that also raised cigarette taxes

    The biggest public lands bill in decades

    A law giving the FDA the authority to regulate tobacco products

    A credit card consumers’ bill of rights law

    An enhancement of the federal school lunch program

    A law creating special benefits for 9/11 first responders (this was Jon Stewart’s big thing before he took up burn pits)

    An update to food safety regulations

That’s all over and above several small follow-on economic relief bills that were added to the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act.

Now I think a lot of people, especially people on the left, look back at the 111th Congress and mostly feel disappointment. They served at a moment when the material and political circumstances of the country felt much friendlier to large-scale policy change than they did in 1977-78, 1992-93, or 2021-22, and there’s a sense that Democrats sort of fumbled the ball. And I sympathize with that. If congressional Democrats had correctly understood the depth and severity of the recession and the implications of secular stagnation for their situation, they could have done a lot more.

Still, that was the Congress for which one has to go back to the heyday of the Great Society or the New Deal to find a precedent. Biden’s achievements are more pedestrian because his majorities are smaller. Which is fine.

What I think is weirdest about Democratic Party choices in this regard is that one of the main reasons their legislative majorities are so narrow is that lots of people don’t particularly want sweeping policy change. Chuck Schumer’s claim that the Inflation Reduction Act features the “boldest climate package in U.S. history” is factually true, but it feels like a message aimed at Schumer’s donors rather than the constituents of his frontline members.

I think what the constituents of Catherine Cortez Masto, Maggie Hassan, Raphael Warnock, Michael Bennet, and Mark Kelly want to hear is that this is a very prudent energy bill that is going to reduce emissions without upsetting too many apple carts while retaining America’s strengths as a fossil fuel producer.

I’m not really saying anything controversial here. Democrats out on the campaign trail are pretty clearly all getting advice to emphasize the prescription drug provision and the moderate nature of the energy proposals, and those who are actively campaigning in contested races seem to be doing more or less this.

But most nationally prominent Democrats aren't in frontline races, and they are running with a message that isn't so helpful to their colleagues who are.

This speaks, I think, to a larger problem in Democratic Party politics where the leaders generally work hard on identifying the right things to emphasize in their paid advertising but then don’t bring that same energy to their public-facing communications and earned media. The problem is that while paid media is good, ultimately earned media is more important in shaping people’s perceptions. Unfortunately, the people who do paid media are happy to let elected officials overestimate how influential they are. And the people who work on the communications side seem to enjoy being free from the burdens of message discipline. But the result is you end up with Democrats seeking coverage that emphasizes how progressive they are and then receiving coverage that emphasizes how progressive they are.

I think the right way to talk about the energy provisions publicly is probably to use the messages that worked privately on Joe Manchin, since Joe Manchin is actually a really good example of a person who doesn’t like Republicans but also isn’t sold on the progressive movement. That would mean emphasizing that this is a moderate, balanced approach that, for the first time ever, makes our energy policy technology-agnostic with equal support for nuclear, geothermal, hydrogen, CCS, and direct air capture alongside wind and solar power. The bill breaks with a lot of the dogmas of the neopastoralist and degrowth wings of the environmental movement and fundamentally refutes the notion that overthrowing capitalism is necessary to address climate change.

If Democrats want to make some brags about the energy title of this bill, that’s what they should brag about — they are ultimately much more pragmatic and much less beholden to left-wing groups than many people think. But messaging as if the groups themselves are the target audience is pointless and counterproductive.

The biggest factors in the upcoming midterms, by far, will be the general state of the economy and Donald Trump’s proclivity for picking bad candidates.

Whatever Biden can do to make the price of food and energy commodities go down relative to wages will help him a lot. And anything he does that doesn’t impact that just won’t change things very much.

But to the extent that messaging matters at all, the key thing to keep in mind is that midterm backlashes are mostly driven by people who voted for President X but are now concerned that X and his co-partisans are going too far and changing too much. Above all else, you have to reassure people that Biden and the Democrats are not enacting sweeping ideological policy change, that in fact a huge share of their time has been spent on uncontroversial stuff like aid to veterans or admitting Finland into NATO, and that they are the only thing standing between you and very radical Republicans.

One reason Dobbs has been very good for Democrats is it’s created a situation where the right is on offense, policy-wise, even though Democrats hold the majority. Defending the status quo is just always much politically easier than going on the attack.

Of course that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t pass laws when you have a chance — governing is the whole point — but leave the bragging and LBJ comparisons for your memoirs. Practical politics is about minimizing the extent to which you are pushing big change while talking about how the other side is full of morons who want to defund the FBI.